Partying, Parenthood, Boredom-Four Teens on Their Obstacles to Graduation

Rafiat, 19, says that five years from now, she hopes to be “heading into my first year of getting my master’s degree.” She hasn’t always been as committed to education. After several years of cutting school, she moved to Texas, caught up, and is now finishing her final semester in Brooklyn, New York. She will graduate in June.
Matthew, 21, fell behind in school, but caught up just in time. The age limit for New York high school students is 21, and Matthew will graduate in June. He hopes to become a chef, a lawyer, or a child psychologist.
Alexis, 19, dropped out of high school when his daughter, who is now 1½, was born. He eventually re-enrolled in a transfer school and graduated in March. He plans to go into business management.
Marco, 17, wants “to do aerospace engineering and study propulsion systems” in college. If he doesn’t sound to you like someone who hates academics, you’re right. Marco’s obstacle is that he hasn’t felt challenged enough in school. Marco is graduating on time, in June, but says he wishes he’d had more opportunities to, for example, take AP classes and electives during high school.
What have been your greatest obstacles in school?
Matthew: My biggest obstacle was staying focused. The work they give me is easy, but I catch myself dozing off, looking out the window, or being on the computer and just wasting time.
Rafiat: Sometimes I’d go to school with my sneakers totally busted and my hair mussed up. I’d get teased and that would really hurt me, to where I wouldn’t want to come to school-so I wouldn’t. The more days I missed, the less I’d care. A week turns into months; months turn into a semester. I don’t know how I was getting promoted to the next grade, since I was never in school.
My mom was sick and tired of me skipping, so she shipped me off to Texas. It was a huge change in my life. Then my mom got sick, so I came back to Brooklyn and I signed up at a transfer school.
Alexis: My biggest obstacle was people. People laugh at you for studying. You do good and it’s considered bad.
Rafiat: Sometimes I would have a book in my hand and my friends would be like, “Why are you reading? What is this? What’s wrong with you?” I’d tell them, “I love to read, because it’s more interesting than staring at a flat-screen TV. Sometimes I like to imagine things.”
How much do you think your friends have influenced your commitment to education?
Rafiat: My friends were the ones who got me started ditching. In 5th or 6th grade they were like, “You should come over,” and I was like, “I got school,” and they were like, “don’t worry about that; you know you don’t gotta go.” It became like an addiction.
Now, of those five or six friends, I only hang out with two of them. Those two both have kids, and now they encourage me to go to school because they’veseen the difference not having an education makes since they’vehad kids. They can’t get a job; they have to depend on men; they can’t provide for themselves; they have to hustle. I’m the only one who doesn’t have kids, so they’re like, “We love you. Please go to school because you’re the last hope for all of us.”
Alexis: A lot of my friends dropped out, but even so they’re like, “Nah, nah, you going to school, though.” I used to get dressed to go out to parties with them and they’d say: “Where you going?” They would ditch me, basically because they didn’t want me to go party and to drop out.
When you were in elementary school, do you remember liking school, hating it, or feeling indifferent?
Alexis: I used to actually like school, but everyone around me hated it. My brother: “I hate going to school.” My sister: “I hate going to school.” Even my mom. Eventually, I’m like, you know what? I don’t want to be the only outcast. So I’d say, “I don’t like school, either!” Eventually, if you say something often enough, you believe it. That’s why it’s important to have a positive mindset.
Rafiat: I’d hate going to school because I had to deal with students who wanted to mess with me and I’d have to fight them to show them that I could defend myself. And I’d hate coming home because my aunt was right there, and if I didn’t do my writing or my math homework right, I’d get beat and sent to the bathroom to think about what I’d done wrong.
How has your family influenced your feelings about education?
Alexis: They’re supportive, as long as it doesn’t take nothing out of their pockets or affect them in any way.
When I was in 9th grade, I started getting into a lot of problems that almost cost my life. I’d ask my uncles if I could go stay with them in different states, and they’d say, “Oh, I got my own problems.” Yet, you’re calling me and telling me you love me? I’m telling you that people are shooting at me!
You encourage someone by showing them that you’ll be there. My big brother was my father figure and if I really needed something, he was the only person who would take time out of his life and give it to me.
Matthew: My mother is the biggest supportive influence on my education. It surprised me when I learned two years ago that she had her GED and not a high school diploma. She told me that she had to leave high school after getting into a fight.
The whole time I was in high school, I didn’t think I’d ever finish by the age limit of 21 and I said, “Let me try to get my GED.” My mother said I was better off with a high school diploma because it looks better on a resume. Even though the GED is supposed to be equal to it, she taught me that it’s viewed as a dropouts’ qualification. So she has been the biggest influence to keep me in school.
Marco: When I was younger, my uncle would buy me something to show me that he cared about me every time I did well in different programs. And later I helped my little cousin, his son, with math and advice on making the most out of high school.
Rafiat: I always thought that my mom didn’t care, so what sense did it make for me to care about my education? Whether it was parent-teacher night, or grades, or report cards, my mom never bothered to ask about it, or to go talk to my teachers.
But when I went off to Texas and she heard I was getting all A’s, she started to care a little more. She was happy to hear I was doing better. Then I came back to New York and I had to start asking her for things, like money to get my hair cut, and the senior dues. And she’s actually paying for those things. I see that she’s trying to put in the effort. She’s becoming supportive.
Was there a point when you went from not caring about school to realizing you really wanted to graduate from high school or further your education?
Alexis: My daughter was born and I dropped out so my girlfriend could finish school. It was extremely hard changing diapers, putting up with the crying at night, making bottles, going to appointments, and everything else.
When I got back to school, I realized I’d wasted so much time before. Now I had work, school, and then I had to come home and take care of my daughter. I thought, “What was I doing all that time when I only had to go to school? I could have been done!” And I feel extremely motivated now because I want to be an example to her.
Rafiat: Summer of 2009, my friend shoplifted and I was with her, so I got arrested as an accomplice. While we were in bookings, the other females we were locked up with were trying to make it a little bit fun so we wouldn’t be so bored in there. We was talking and laughing it up, and I had a moment where I started thinking: “Why am I laughing? I’m in jail. It smells. I can’t see sunlight. I don’t want this.” Everything just kept going through my mind: do I want to be the type of person who’s in and out of jail?
I got in front of the judge, and the judge looked at me and said, “Get your life together, and stop letting friends decide for you and take you the wrong way.” Right there and then I was like, “I’ve gotta change this. I do need to get my life together.” That was my turning point.
Marco: My uncle, my aunt, and my dad all went to college, but they all dropped out. When I found out that they had all dropped out of college, I wanted to show them that I could go and graduate. I felt motivated and tried my best in school.
What do you think schools can do to help students succeed?
Matthew: I think they should have smaller class sizes. It would increase the number of graduates. Having one teacher for 30 students is like throwing a bucket of water at a burning building. It will only take care of a small area. If there were smaller classes, the ones who really want to graduate would get more attention from the teacher.
Alexis: The problem is not the classroom size, it’s the people who make up the class. I don’t care if it’s just two kids; if somebody wants to be a fool, they’re going to act a fool. My aunt used to teach in China, a class of 55 students, and not one of them used to make a sound. They never whispered without her permission. They were all trying to do better and progress.
That’s why I think people should be separated. I think students who want to work should be placed in a school together. There are people who have this positive attitude, but they’re afraid to show it because they don’t want to be an outcast in front of everybody else.
Matthew: China is a more disciplined society than America. Their parents are more forceful about education than American parents are.
Alexis: So, you have the answer: You have to be more strict!
Rafiat: But if you put some strict rules on these American kids, they’re not going to come to school. Right now, you can’t bring electronics into the school and what happens every morning? There are kids who try to sneak them in, and if they get caught there are outbursts: “I don’t know why we have this stupid rule, anyway!” China has been a law-abiding culture for generations. In America, throwing more strict rules at us isn’t going to motivate us to do better in school-it’s going to motivate us to not go.
Alexis: Well, if people don’t want to be educated or disciplined, then you should let them know what they’re going to become. You should let them know what to expect, how far they will get. You should say, “If you don’t do well in school, if you want to drop out and be in the streets, these are your options…
Rafiat: Yeah, your options are: jail; dead; drugs; baby momma; baby daddy…
Alexis: Right. And homelessness, being without a family. Just let them know these things; don’t try to tell them that education doesn’t matter or that there’s always going to be a second chance.
Marco: About China, my teacher told me about his Asian friend whose family, once a week, would announce the highest grades out of all their kids. All the brothers and sisters would hear it and be motivated to do better. They taught them discipline from a young age and showed their children: This is where you’re supposed to be; this is what it means to be successful. I think that competition encourages kids to want to do better.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.