Now that the New York State Department of Education Commissioner Richard Mills has ruled that alternative schools have to take the Regents, some are protesting the decision while others are busy getting ready for the exams. NYC reporters visited a few alternative schools to hear what students and teachers had to say about the Regents.
At Manhattan’s Institute for Collaborative Education (I.C.E.), some students are upset that Mills feels their portfolio work can’t compare to a Regents exam. “I want to be judged by what I can do on a daily basis, not my test grades,” said Min Cheng, 18, who recently graduated from I.C.E. “A portfolio school is better because it has more depth to the grading policy. [It’s] not just a calculation of numbers.”
Portfolios Show ‘Progression’
“A portfolio school requires more thinking,” said Sophie Reite, 14, who attends I.C.E. She said that she prefers portfolios over Regents because portfolios show that students have understood what they’ve learned. Sophie said that basing one’s graduation on one test is unfair since students may get nervous when taking tests or be having a bad day.
David Frui, a 15-year-old sophomore at School for the Physical City in Manhattan, also prefers portfolios because “you can look back on the work you started in the 9th grade and compare it to stuff you did in your graduation year. It shows how you progressed over four years.”
Still, David said that it’s fair for alternative school students to take the Regents as well as produce portfolios in order to show that they’re capable of meeting both standards.
Some Teachers Say They’ll Quit
But 15-year-old Brian Mayfield, a School for the Physical City sophomore, said that the Regents isn’t fair for students who have become used to a portfolio system.
“The whole time they’ve been prepping us for portfolios and all of a sudden halfway into high school they throw the test on us,” he said.
Mark Burnhill, an English teacher at School for the Physical City, said that he feels the school will suffer if they have to integrate Regents requirements. Sue Schutt, a humanities teacher there, said that some teachers said they would quit if forced to teach for the Regents.
But Leonard Morochinck, a physics teacher at the NYC Lab School, said that portfolio schools are worse than schools where the Regents is required.
Portfolios a Cop-Out?
“[Portfolio schools] are a cop-out,” he said. “Its like ‘Our students can’t handle Regents, so we’ll make them do projects,’ but those projects are too thin.”
Still, Morochinck isn’t crazy about the Regents either. “A lot of teachers end up revolving their careers around a three-hour test,” he said. “I’m not going to do that.”
He said that he feels like his curriculum is too restricted by a need to prepare for the Regents. (Regents exams at Lab School are given but weren’t required for graduation.)
“We don’t get to see too many topics in detail,” he said. “When we do, I end up having to cut other topics outâ
Where’s the depth? Where’s the beauty of the topic?”
Brooke Jackson, a Lab School English teacher, said that she likes the new English Regents since it’s based on essay writing.
As for whether the Regents should be required to graduate, she said that depends on what the exam is supposed to be measuring.
“If it’s testing the school’s performance then it should be mandatory,” she said. “If it’s testing the students for college or something, then the student should be able to choose whether to take it or not. I find it odd that as a teacher I can’t always be certain of what it is actually assessing.”
Jackson also favors school systems like Lab’s where some classes have both portfolio reviews and Regents exams.
“I’d like to feel that it doesn’t have to be Regents vs. portfolio. I’d rather they both be used as modes of learning,” she said. “I don’t think one is necessarily better than the other. They’re both flawed.”
(Reporting by Benjamin Berelson, Shavone Harris, Matt Kamel, Jonathan Maseng, Melissa Rodriguez, Brant Schwartz and Abilene Selvon)
Other Alternative Schools Speak Out
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.