New Discipline Policy Is Criticized as Excessive

On December 14, 1988, Chancellor Richard Green issued a special circular to high school superintendents and principals.
The circular discussed new guidelines for suspending and expelling students to increase safety and discipline in the public high schools.
According to Diana Autin, managing attorney at Advocates for Children, a private organization which fights for students’ legal rights, “The guidelines are different in two ways. First, they expand the range of behavior that is punishable. Second, they increase the severity of the punishment for prohibited behavior.
“Because of the new guidelines now encompassing more behavior and calling for more severe penalties, more students are being suspended and more parents are requesting due process hearings,” she said.
“Issuance of these guidelines was clearly a message to schools that they were free to suspend or expel students that previously they would have treated differently.
“With the old guidelines, it was presumed that students of any age would be reinstated in school at the end of their suspension period. The special circular presumes that a student who is 17 or older is going to be expelled from the school system,” Autin continued.
New Guidelines For Discplinary Action
In other words, these students must apply for readmission to the school system-they aren’t automatically reinstated.
According to the circular, students may be suspended or expelled for the following behavior:
1. Possessing or using any weapons such as knives, guns (air or bullet), billy clubs, etc.
2. Using any force against school personnel or extreme force against students.
3. Possessing, selling, or distributing illegal drugs or controlled substances.
If you are accused of any of the above behaviors, you may be suspended from six to 30 school days, or expelled for one calendar year. If you are accused of possessing a gun-even a plastic or fake gun-you are automatically expelled for one year even if you have a clean record.
According to Advocates for Children, those who are using the new policy are not using it just to get truly dangerous students out of the schools.
Students are being kicked out for ridiculous reasons that are made to apply to the suspendible behavior listed in the circular, Autin said. There have been cases of students being expelled for possession of anything that might be used as a weapon, such as pens, nail files, and index card boxes.
Accused of Swinging Bat
One case dealt with a student named Michael, who was accused of threatening a teacher with a mini-bat.
Michael, 17, from John F. Kennedy HS, explained: “They said I was in possession of a small bat. I was given… a choice to take a five day suspension and transfer, or be arrested because she [the teacher] said I threatened her with the bat.”
Michael claimed he was outside school after a substitute teacher dismissed the class. The teacher came outside to the parking lot, saw him with the bat, and told him to stop swinging it at her. He told her he wasn’t. She went back into the school to report him for threatening her.
Although he has student witnesses who back his claim, it is his word and the word of other students against the teacher’s, and victory under these new guidelines usually belongs to the teachers.
Michael added: “I feel it was unfair, because in my school there are so many people who don’t do anything, and they’re always outside, and nothing is said to them. But they picked on me.”
According to Autin, students re being expelled for an accidental push or a reflex action interpreted as an attempt to do harm to a student or personnel. Several students have been expelled for hitting back after they were punched or slapped by teachers or school security guards, she said.
This type of situation caused Todd Randall, 18, of August Martin HS, to transfer to another school. “They claim I had assaulted two cops. I feel that it was unjustified, but I don’t have any hard feelings,” explained Todd.
An angry step toward an official with a pen in your hand could be classified as attempting to inflict injury. The smallest misunderstanding on anyone’s part could result in the expulsion of an innocent student whose only mistake is being in the wrong place at the wrong time.
Are Hearings Fair?
Advocates for Children, which represents students at suspension hearings, claims that student’s rights are being ignored.
“This automatic expulsion policy violates state law, which says that schools should consider both the seriousness of the offense and the student’s prior disciplinary record before deciding on a punishment,” stated Autin.
As the result of a Federal Supreme Court case, no student can be suspended without a chance to explain her side of the story. When a student is accused of one of the above behaviors, the principal asks the student to write a statement about the incident.
But often students are not being told of the importance of this statement. Students’ written explanations are being used as evidence against them in the suspension hearings.
Someone called an “Investigating dean” is assigned to the case, and gathers information from the person making the charge and other witnesses.
This dean is supposed to get statements from other witnesses, including students, before recommending that a student be suspended.
But, according to Autin, “Students are often suspended on the unsupported word of teachers or school staff without any real investigation taking place.”
A student’s parents are supposed to be notified of their child’s suspension and the hearing date on the day the charge is made. But parents are frequently getting notification the day before the hearing. Parents have no time to seek legal advice or prepare for the hearing.
In this case, parents are allowed to postpone the hearing so that they can seek legal advice. But their child has to stay out of school until the rescheduled hearing is held and the hearing office issues a decision.
At the hearing, the hearing officer determines the accuracy of the charges against the student, and makes a recommendation to the superintendent. The superintendent makes the final decision about the student’s fate.
The investigating dean and not the person making the charge is usually present at the hearing. The student has no opportunity to question the witnesses against her.
The hearing officer has to make a determination based on the student’s word against the word of the investigating dean. Who do you think is at a disadvantage?
Must Apply For Readmission
Most of the time the student is suspended or expelled. Students under 17 are supposed to be provided alternate education.
In most cases, if they are 16 or younger, they are transferred to an alternative high school. They may wind up in G.E.D classes, which they are too young to take.
Seventeen-year-olds are usually just expelled without any alternative education offered. A few have been placed in G.E.D courses.
These students have to wait a year before they can apply for readmission to the public school system.
The process to petition for readmission is complicated and long, and there is no guarantee that the student will be reinstated.
Hector [not his real name], 18, of George Washington HS, described a feeling of powerlessness at his hearing: “I don’t think that whether I was there or not it have would have been different.”
Although the Board of Education has implemented the new policy, it did not go through the proper legal channels to implement it, Autin said. The public was not given an adequate chance to respond to the policy before it was approved.
Safety in schools is a goal no one can argue with. But are these policies the way to achieve it? Nothing is accomplished by removing students from school without giving them a fair hearing or trying to help them before kicking them out.
If you are expelled under this new policy and would like some help, contact Advocates For Children at 718-729-8866.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.