My So-Called Friends

Names have been changed.
I started high school knowing I needed to make new friends. Again.
Although I hung out with kids in my neighborhood once in awhile, we didn’t really connect; I knew them as family friends. I always made my real friends at school.
But because I’ve gone to seven different schools in my life, it’s sometimes been hard to keep those friendships. My relationships with “school friends” never lasted for long after I moved on to my next school.
Making Friends With Mike
I’m very friendly, so I usually didn’t have trouble starting over in a new school. During the first few weeks of freshman year, I started conversations with lots of different people, including Chris, a guy I recognized from my junior high.
One day when he and I were talking, we were joined by Mike, another guy from junior high. Mike and I didn’t really know each other. He used to hang out with a group of kids that I didn’t like and had seemed immature.
Once we started talking, though, I found out that Mike and I had a lot in common. We’d both gone to yeshivas (Jewish schools) for elementary school and knew a lot of the same people. We began to hang out. We’d listen to music, talk about what was going on in school, or just sit around and do nothing.
Tara, the Direct One
Once we got to know each other better, we started seeing each other outside of school as well. We’d go to each other’s houses, watch movies, play basketball and go online. We’d almost always have a good time.
Mike and I hung out with Tara, who sat behind me in Hebrew class. She too had gone to yeshiva and knew people from my old school.
Tara was blunt and usually said what she thought. She’d go up to a complete stranger on the bus and say, “I really like your shoes” or tell a friend that her hair looked awful. She had strong beliefs about politics and religion, which she’d stand up for even if everyone else disagreed. I admired her honesty and enjoyed discussing things with her.
Even though Mike, Tara and I had a lot in common and felt comfortable with each other, in some ways we were very different.
For one thing, school’s a very important part of my life. I want to go to a good college, so I’ve always taken hard courses and tried to get the highest possible grade in every class. I’m the kind of person who stays after school for extracurricular activities and then goes home to study.
But Mike and Tara saw school as a place they had to go to, not a place they wanted to be. Tara got good grades but didn’t put a lot of effort into it; Mike sometimes cut classes and got other people to do his work for him. And once the school day was over, they’d both run out as soon as possible.
Mike and Tara’s Other Friends
Unlike me, Mike and Tara both had good friends outside of school-people they’d known since elementary school. When we first became close, Mike and Tara would divide their free time between our group of three and their old friends.
We’d usually hang out together on Friday night and then I’d spend the rest of the weekend alone at home or going places with my family, while they saw their other friends.
Then, sophomore year, both Tara and Mike started to incorporate their closest friends into our group. Mike brought Boris and Robert and Tara brought Elizabeth, Debbie and Martha.
Mike, in particular, liked the idea of having a big crowd to hang out with all the time. I didn’t like the new people as much as I liked Mike and Tara, but I did like having a more active social life.
Back to Being Rude
We’d all meet after school at least once a week and every weekend we’d go out to dinner or to the movies or sit around at one of our houses watching a video. I always had something fun to do and I got to spend more time with Mike and Tara, even though it wasn’t just the three of us.
Although I got along well with almost everyone on a one-to-one level, I felt a little alienated from the group as a whole. Being with their other friends brought out my least favorite sides of Mike and Tara.
Mike’s rude, immature streak, which had diminished since junior high, came out in force when Boris and Robert were around. With them, he was more likely to do things I hated, like burp, fart or make racist and homophobic remarks. And the guys shared interests like wrestling and computers, which I couldn’t care less about.
Gucci This, Gucci That
As for Tara, she and her other girl friends shared the same tastes in music and fashion, which were different from mine. They were more concerned about their looks than I was; it seemed like whenever they got together, a copy of Seventeen or some bridal magazine was also present.
While I dressed pretty conservatively and always thought brand-names were a waste of money, the other girls, especially Martha, were really into designer clothing and talking about Gucci this and Gucci that.
I let them influence me; the more I hung out with them, the more makeup ended up on my face. And, even though my clothing remained relatively conservative, a few pricey low-cut shirts made their way into my closet.
Their Music, Not Mine
When it came to music, I liked everything, from pop to reggae to country, but they only listened to what was popular on stations like Z100 and WPLJ or to Middle Eastern music, since a few of them were from Israeli families.
I was willing to listen to their music, but whenever I tried to get them to listen to something different that I liked, they refused to let me put it on.
It was the same story when it came to movies. I was terrified of scary movies, so I’d always say, “Whatever you want, as long as it’s not scary,” and then they’d drag me to the scariest movie they could find, like Hannibal. Whoever was sitting next to me would hold down my arms so I couldn’t cover my eyes.
Acting More Like Them
Still, I had fun with them. Their music wasn’t bad and even though the movies were scary, they were never as scary as I made them out to be.
I did sometimes wonder why I was hanging out with people who were so different from me. But the more I hung out with them, the more I started acting like them. School and good grades mattered less to me and I began to focus on more superficial things like looks.
Whatever happened with the larger group, Mike and Tara and I had a special bond. On my 16th birthday, for example, the two of them surprised me with an assortment of 16 balloons. That was one of the sweetest things anyone’s ever done for me. I felt lucky to have such good friends.
Turning Back to School
But things changed during junior year. I realized that college was coming up and I had to improve my grades. I was still very close to the group, but they didn’t seem to appreciate how much stress I was under.
I killed myself working all day and night, and by the middle of the school year, I was physically and emotionally tired. I continued to spend what little free time I had with them, but I was no longer as willing to put up with attitudes and behavior that I didn’t like.
Growing Tensions
Before when someone in the group said something stupid or racist to me, I’d responded by either giving them a look or a nudge with my arm; now I unloaded on them, saying very bluntly just how much I hated those comments.
Things started to get tense between us: I was liking most of them less and less and I could tell that they were starting to think that I was a b-tch. By the spring of junior year, the only person in the group I really felt close to was Tara.
One day in April, Tara called me and begged me to come over. Mike and Boris were on their way and she said she didn’t want to be alone with them. I wasn’t in the mood, but decided to go anyhow. Elizabeth went too.
As we sat in Tara’s room, Mike and I bickered over stupid things-it was as though we were bored and trying to provoke each other. He’d start with a racist comment, or just say something mean, and I’d reply with my opinion, which I did not state very nicely.
Singing Above the Tension
At dinner, I tried to ignore him and pay more attention to the other people. On the way back to Tara’s house from the restaurant, we cranked up the radio in the car and sang along to “Lady Marmalade” at the top of our voices. At that moment, I was really happy, even though the tension between Mike and me was just beneath the surface.
When we got back to Tara’s, everyone started joking around. Mike and Elizabeth pretended to fight. I was standing near them and Mike kept falling back on me. I told him to stop, but he kept doing it.
One of his falls squashed my hand against Tara’s dresser. I yelled, “Stop! Get away from me!” but he continued pretending to fight with Elizabeth as if nothing had happened. My hand didn’t hurt that much but I still left Tara’s house very annoyed.
A Handful of Pain
When I woke up the next morning my hand was killing me. My mother joked, “Maybe you have arthritis,” but I knew why it hurt. By the middle of the day my hand had started turning purple and I couldn’t move it.
I rushed to the doctor thinking that it was broken, but it wasn’t. The doctor told me that I had tendonitis-not horrible, but painful. I’d have to wear a brace for a while.
I e-mailed Mike to tell him what had happened and asked if we could talk about it over the phone. He repeatedly typed “No!” in instant messages. He seemed more concerned about whether I was going to blame him than the fact I was in pain.
That bothered me. I needed him as a friend to say, “Sharon, are you OK?” He didn’t.
The next night, dazed on painkillers and feeling alone, I got a phone call. It was Martha, the person in the group I was the least close to.
Martha never seemed interested in anything I had to say; when I was talking about something I cared about, she’d say “Sharon, stop babbling,” which hurt my feelings. We didn’t talk or see each other outside of the group, so I had no clue why she was calling me.
“Sharon, you’re an instigator…a horrible person…you hate everything and everyone…and no one likes you!” she said harshly. She told me that everyone laughed about me when I wasn’t around and that I was nothing but “stupid.”
How Could She Do It?
I hung up the phone. I felt as though my heart had been pulled from my body. I’d never gotten a call like that; it was the absolute meanest thing anyone has ever done to me. What made it worse was that I was sure that either Mike or his friend Boris had put her up to it. How else would she have gotten my number?
I immediately called Tara and told her what had happened, crying hysterically. She calmed me down and told me that none of what Martha had said was true.
“That’s just what Martha does,” she said. She explained that Martha had said similarly mean things to her countless times when they’d fought.
Betrayed and Depressed
I was disappointed in Tara’s response. “Just what Martha does?” I thought. “How could anyone justify someone doing something that horrible?”
If I’d thought Martha was just acting on her own, I would’ve felt bad, but it wouldn’t have hurt as much as it did. But things had gotten so bad between Mike and me that I was sure he had something to do with it.
I was convinced that one of my closest friends had betrayed me and that the other people I’d spent most of the past three years with had turned against me. I felt depressed and alone and I hated it. I cried for the rest of the night.
No Longer in the Group
That was it; I was no longer part of the group. No one was talking to me except Tara. The people who used to call and e-mail me every night had nothing to say to me anymore.
I wanted to call Mike and Boris to confront them, but I didn’t feel that I could trust them anymore. I imagined them lying about how Martha got my number and telling me again that Mike hadn’t hurt my hand.
My birthday was a week away and I didn’t want to face it. Tara and my family offered to celebrate with me, but I said I’d rather not; I was too depressed.
I told Tara that all I wanted for my birthday was balloons. But when I saw her at school, she was empty-handed. She’d forgotten. She wished me a happy birthday and we parted ways.
That night I got a phone call from Mike.
I don’t remember exactly what he said, other than wishing me a happy birthday. It was nice that he remembered, but strange that he acted as though nothing had happened between us. When we hung up, it was clear to me that our friendship was over.
I still considered Tara my friend, even though she remained close to the others. I decided that didn’t matter; I still wanted to be friends with her and I knew it was unfair to expect her to choose.
Tara Chose Them Over Me
But after I stopped hanging out with the rest of the group, Tara seemed distant. We’d always gotten together every day before school to talk; suddenly that changed.
Tara met me less and less, and when she did, she didn’t talk very much. We stopped seeing each other outside of school. On Saturday nights she was still going out with the group, while I was at home by myself.
I remembered how Tara had begged me to come over the day all the trouble started because she didn’t want to be alone with the very people that she now seemed to be choosing over me. I was confused and angry.
Reuniting with Old Friends
When I told Tara I wanted to know whether or not she was still my friend, she acted surprised. She told me that of course we were still friends. But she wasn’t acting like it. I made an effort to keep our friendship going but she never called me or returned my calls.
With time, I was able to get over the whole mess. I was busy with different school activities. And friends and acquaintances I hadn’t seen for a long time reappeared to comfort me when they heard what had happened.
I reconnected with Jeff, a close friend from junior high; it felt great talking to him again. I realized that he was a true friend, making sure I was all right and willing to take me back after I’d stopped talking to him for so long. He helped me get through my hard time.
In a way, I’m grateful for what happened because it taught me the people in the group were not the right friends for me.
I Wasn’t True to Myself
They say opposites attract, but my ideas and goals were too different from theirs. I’m not the stereotypical just-want-to-have-fun teenager; I’m more interested in accomplishing as much as I can and leaving a mark.
Being part of the group was fun for a while, and maybe I needed to prove to myself that I could have a social life that didn’t revolve around studying and extracurricular activities. But I should’ve realized when I started spending more time on other people’s interests than on my own that I wasn’t being true to myself.
I don’t know who I’ll be friends with at school this year and I don’t know how I’ll handle it when I see Tara and Mike there, but it doesn’t scare me. I’m happy with what I have now, even though my social life isn’t what it used to be.
I do miss the friendship I once had with Mike and Tara, as well as the days of automatic weekend plans with a crowd of people. But I wouldn’t go back. I know that I have a great year ahead of me-prom, graduation, getting ready for college-and I can’t wait!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.