(All names have been changed.)
Last fall, there was a guy at school I really liked. He was so cute. Being with him made me feel like I was on a roller coaster plunging downward-he took my breath away. I could’ve drowned in his baby blue eyes, gotten lost in his sandy blond hair. And his bark-like laugh-to die for. He had me under a spell. I became his tutor just to be with him. I developed a need to see him or I’d become upset. He drove me to obsession.
One day he called my house and left a message on my answering machine. I was so excited I wouldn’t let anyone erase it and I listened to it so often that I memorized it.
“Hello,” he said in the honey-toned voice that made me melt inside. “I’m calling to speak to the parents of Ariel Gonzales. This is Mr. Smith. I’m Ariel’s biology teacher. I’m just calling to touch base here at the beginning of the year. Ariel is doing a great job in class so far. Um, if you have any questions or would like to talk, my number isâHope you have a nice week. Bye-bye.”
Yeah, the guy was my teacher.
Man of My Dreams
I’d heard that Mr. Smith was a cool teacher, so I signed up for his biology class my senior year. But even though I thought he was gorgeous and I liked him, I didn’t like him like him. That is, until I had the dream.
In the dream, my cousin was kidnapped, and Mr. Smith suddenly appeared and told me that the kidnappers had put her in a potato sack. Then he took a potato sack and put it over the two of us. Of course, having no place to move around, we tripped and fell on top of each other. I suddenly found myself sitting on top of him, saddle-like. Then I looked into his awesome blue eyes. And out of nowhere, I kissed him!
The dream continued from there, but it was that part that really stuck with me. On the way to school the next day, I kept giggling and smiling. That was the day that everything changed.
At school, I couldn’t look at Mr. Smith the same way. He wasn’t just my cute teacher. He was the guy I kissed in my dreams. I kept staring at him. I did all my homework just to impress him. I wanted him to notice me, talk to me. I couldn’t control myself. I realized I was becoming obsessed.
Stalker Mode Again?
I was once obsessed with a pop star and I chased his van on foot for about five blocks. I was afraid that this would happen to me now, because I know how I can get when I’m passionate about someone. I go into stalker mode.
I’ve followed a couple of boys I’ve had a crush on through the hallways before, and I always spooked them away. I didn’t want to go into stalker mode again. It’s kind of pathetic. I hoped that my crush on Mr. Smith wouldn’t overtake my better judgment.
I couldn’t help how I felt, though. I always rushed to class as soon as 2nd period was over, and after class I’d pretend to look for something on the floor or in my bookbag, just to have an excuse to talk to him for a couple of minutes before I left. I wanted so much to hang out with him.
Hanging Out After School
Then, a week later, after my last class of the day, I ran into Mr. Smith in the hallway. I could tell that my face lit up.
“Hi Mr. Smith, how’s your day going?” I asked.
“It’s going great, and yours?” he asked back, smiling at me.
“It’s OK. Hey, are you doing anything now?” I asked hopefully.
“No,” he said, still smiling.
“Can I hang out with you?” Immediately I felt a bit foolish for asking-it sounded so needy.
But he answered with a small laugh and said, “Of course,” which made me feel a whole lot better. We hung out in the lab room, talking about where we live and how to get there. There were a few other students there, but they were insignificant to me. It was so dreamlike to hang out with him. He was laid back and relaxed and he joked around. He was just so cool.
After that, I went to him every day after my last class just to hang out, except when he had lab once a week. Usually there were other kids there too, but they stayed out of the way. Being with him made me feel like I’d never stop smiling.
I guess what made him so special was that he knew how to listen. And unlike other guy teachers, I didn’t feel so dumb when I talked to him.
I imagined marrying someone like him one day. He was considerate of people’s feelings when it mattered, but he could joke around too, and not immaturely like all the boys in my school.
He wasn’t just hot and young for a teacher, but smart. He always had something to teach me, about school or life. He even explained that cousins once-removed thing I’d always wondered about.
Teaching the Teacher
Then parent-teacher night gave me a golden opportunity. When I told Mr. Smith that my parents mostly spoke Spanish and not much English, he asked me to teach him Spanish so he could speak with them. It was all I could do to keep myself from leaping for joy.
So, 7th period became Spanish class as I prepared him for parent-teacher night. I successfully predicted the questions Mom would ask him about me, and I was impressed by how well he handled his Spanish challenge.
This fed my attraction even more. It meant something more every time he looked at me. I’d melt, turn red and look away. I wanted him for myself, and it was bad.
Reality Hit Me
I thought it wasn’t fair that I couldn’t have him, but I knew it could never be. First, he was engaged. I wouldn’t want to be “the other woman” or a home wrecker. Second, he was my teacher. He would’ve gotten fired for being romantically involved with a student. (I checked.)
Third, he was too old for me (he told me he was 36, but I refuse to believe him). In general, I prefer guys my age. Besides, I don’t think he had the same feelings for me.
Of course, if he’d turned out to be in his 20s, unattached and had feelings for me, I would’ve said, “Score!” After all, I was going to graduate and he wouldn’t be my teacher anymore. And I was 18, so he wouldn’t have been sent to prison for statutory rape if we’d done anything (age of consent is 17 in New York).
But that was in my imagination. During our lesson one day, reality hit me like a foul ball. His fiance was picking him up after school. “Would you like to meet her?” he asked.
It had been easier to pretend that she didn’t exist. Still, I was excited to meet the lucky lady that Mr. Smith deemed worthy enough to marry. And soon after 3 p.m., a pretty woman walked into the room, so petite in her red coat with her hair tied back. Mr. Smith’s eyes lit up when he saw her. I couldn’t help but be a bit jealous.
I couldn’t even hate her, though. She was really nice and when he introduced us, she said she’d already heard a lot about me from Mr. Smith.
My Feelings Exposed
Rather than discourage me, meeting his fiance made me like him even more. Seeing that he had the capacity to love someone that much was so romantic, even if that someone wasn’t me.
My infatuation with him grew stronger as the days went by. He was everywhere. I heard him when I listened to my Jason Mraz CD, I saw him in Ryan Gosling when I watched The Notebook. I even saw him in the pizza guy from the Domino’s 555 Deal commercial.
I wanted to express my feelings to someone but the thought of liking my teacher still embarrassed me. I involuntarily made it obvious, though, and one day when we were all in the computer room, another teacher jokingly accused me of having a crush on Mr. Smith.
I could have died at that very moment. I could feel my face burning. How could he? Mr. Smith was right there!
I didn’t dare turn to look at Mr. Smith, but from the corner of my eye I could see he had no expression, as if he hadn’t even heard it. But how could he not have? The room had been quiet. I felt so exposed.
I Had to Tell Someone
The next day, Mr. Smith acted as sweet and normal as ever, but I still had that murky feeling that he knew my deepest, darkest secret. In fact, he must have already known. How could he not? I wear my heart on my sleeve and people can easily guess how I’m feeling.
I decided I had to be more careful about how I acted around him. I didn’t want to jeopardize his feelings towards me. I was afraid that if he knew how much I liked him, he’d close opportunities for me to hang out with him to discourage any thought of a relationship.
I tried to think about something else every time his image popped into my head, but it was no use. I enjoyed his image too much to think about something else. Eventually, my infatuation became so enormous that I had to tell someone other than my diary. So one afternoon, I told Lola, my closest friend in school, “I like Mr. Smith.”
She stopped and turned to me with a sly smile. “You said what now?”
“I have a crush on him,” I said.
She started giggling, and asked, “Since when?” Then I told her the whole story.
Did He Feel the Same?
It felt good sharing my secret with someone. I needed someone to talk about my feelings with and have them respond back (my diary was no help).
From that point on, I talked to her about him. She didn’t make fun of me, and she’d listen to how I felt about him and obsess with me over little gestures like him looking at me and smiling or touching my arm for a fraction of a second.
“You know, I think he might have a crush on you,” she said matter-of-factly.
“What! No, that can’t be possible. He has a fiance,” I said. I’d thought he might like me back before but I’d told myself that it was my imagination. Now that Lola noticed it too though, it excited me.
“When two people start hanging out together as much as you two do, it’s only natural that they develop a crush on each other,” she said.
What if he did have feelings for me? Would he do anything? Would I do anything if he did anything? My thoughts started to freak me out. Why couldn’t I stop fantasizing about a taken man who was clearly not in my age range? Why did I let myself get delusional about how he might feel about me?
Language of Love
I knew my obsession was pathetic but I couldn’t drop it. I actually felt like I had to see him sometime during the day so I could function. That’s when Lola decided that I needed to get my mind off Mr. Smith. She looked for a boyfriend for me and hooked me up with a guy in my class I had some feelings for.
I really liked him, but I still had my head in the clouds with images of Mr. Smith. We broke up after a week because I didn’t pay enough attention to the relationship. My problem was even worse than I’d imagined.
I couldn’t keep away, though. I would race towards our Spanish lesson after my last class with great enthusiasm, retouching my lip gloss and dabbing on some Curve Crush perfume. Even when I’d had the worst day, I couldn’t help but cheer up and grin from ear to ear when I saw him. And it made me happy that he was speaking Spanish so well. I felt like it gave us a special connection.
Devastating News
But I knew it couldn’t last. Soon I’d graduate and start college. I hated the thought of not seeing him but cheered myself up thinking that I could always go visit him at school.
Then, I heard the devastating news: Mr. Smith was moving back to his home state at the end of the year. I couldn’t believe it. As soon as I could, I picked up a U.S. history book and turned to the map of the United States. he’d be 888 miles away from me. How could I ever see him again?
I felt like crying because he was leaving. Then I felt like crying because of how pathetic I was. He was my teacher for heaven’s sake. I kept thinking, “I’m such a loser. I’m so sad. I’m completely loony.” I talked to Lola about him leaving and she said maybe it was for the best. All I felt, though, was as if I were standing in the rain without an umbrella.
My Final Goodbye
Every time I saw him, I felt like time was running out. On the last day of class, I took pictures with him. I acted as if they were no big deal, when I was really thinking that I’d treasure those pictures forever.
He was at graduation with his fiance and they both hugged me to congratulate me. It was the first time that I’d hugged him and it felt so heavenly. Then Mr. Smith said they had a gift for me. It was a card in which he wrote something in Spanish and then in English, and a gift card to Barnes and Noble. I was so overjoyed that I hugged him again. I felt so special. I couldn’t stop smiling.
On the last day of school, I went looking for him to say my final goodbye. “You’re taking off?” he asked.
“Yeah, I have to get to my internship,” I said.
“OK then, take care of yourself, and keep in touch.” He gave me my last hug.
“I will. Now let me get out of here before I start weeping.” He probably had no idea how much I meant that. After I walked out the door, a deep sadness came over me. I felt a few tears coming and I went back downstairs to an empty stairwell, where nobody could see me.
Getting Over It
I left the school with my boyfriend, who I’d recently started dating again. he’d figured out that I had a crush on Mr. Smith and though he didn’t like the idea that Mr. Smith and I had spent so much time together, he tried to comfort me by joking that he would dye his hair blond and wear blue contacts just for me. I thought it was sweet and cheered up a bit.
But when I got home, I listened to that message on the answering machine over and over again. It was a sort of calming therapy. I could still listen to his voice.
But now that I wouldn’t see him anymore, I promised myself I’d get over him. Over the summer, I kept myself busy with work and hung out with my boyfriend a lot. I only thought about Mr. Smith while writing this article or during the few times he emailed me.
I realized that my feelings for him were slowly diminishing as the summer progressed. But I still felt that something was holding me back.
âIt’s Done’
Then one night at the end of August, I turned to the phone and stared at the flashing number one on the answering machine-the one message I hadn’t allowed anyone to erase.
I picked up the phone and took it into the bathroom where I sat and listened to the message three times. The sound of his voice made me freeze for a second, but finally I pressed a button. Beep! A computerized voice said, “Message one erased.”
“It’s done,” I told myself. I felt like I could finally move on.
Looking back, I think I might have let my crush become an obsession because I figured that since nothing could ever happen, why not focus all my attention on him? Longing and fantasy only fuel a crush. Plus, it was dangerously close to being inappropriate, which gave my crush a naughty touch that was fun.
Real Life, Real Boyfriend
Now that I’m in college though, I’m too busy with real life to waste time on a fantasy. Besides, I have a real boyfriend now, one my own age, who walks on the edge of the sidewalk so I can walk on the inside, and who pushes my hair out of my face right before he kisses my forehead. I wouldn’t exchange him for any fantasy guy, even Mr. Smith.
I admit that I liked the feeling Mr. Smith gave me in my stomach, sort of what you feel when you’re on a roller coaster, like your stomach is left up in the sky. For me though, the ride has ended, and I’m glad to be back on the ground.
My Forbidden Love
I Couldn't Have Him, But I Couldn't Get Him Out of My Head
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.