My Dream Boyfriend: Too Good to Be True (Part I)

Note: The names in this story have been changed.
It was my first year in high school, and everything was going very well. I had been a straight A student ever since the first grade. I had many friends, I was well known, and very well respected.
People used to tell me that my grades would go down in high school because the school I go to has a bad reputation. On top of that, my sister told me that high school was a whole different scene from junior high. “It’s a lot more bigger,” she said. “which means, there will be a lot more people-particularly guys.”
“It doesn’t matter, it’s not like I’m going to change who I am,” was my comeback. Little did I know, she was right!
On the first day of school I saw cuties left and right, everywhere I turned there was a good-looking guy. I had already made up my mind, that I would not make any friends or have any boyfriends, because my intention was to transfer out of that school and into Clara Barton. Then I saw a friend of mine who had graduated from the same junior high school as I did. So I decided to hang with her.
Only eight days passed by and I already had a boyfriend. My sister warned me that I was beginning to mess up. Already I had started cutting class, I wasn’t doing my homework, and my grades were going down the tubes.
Excuse Me, Miss
One morning I was coming into school, already late for class, and was not in the mood for anything. I passed by the guidance office, and someone called out, “Excuse me.”
I kept on walking.
Then he said, “Excuse me, Miss.”
This was no “Yo girl,” or “Shorty come here.” So I turned around and was quite surprised when I saw who it was.
It was a guy I’d been eyeing since the term began. This was my chance to find out who he was. He walked up to me and asked if he could walk me to my class. “Sure,” I said modestly, hiding the excitement inside of me.
His name was Dennis. The first question he asked was whether I had a boyfriend. Quickly I lied and said no.
We engaged in small talk. He was telling me about himself and he really impressed me. He told me that I wouldn’t be able to find anything negative about him. He was captain of the football team, the principal was his godmother, and he maintained a 92 average. I was impressed.
The Perfect Guy!
Here was everything I had been looking for in a guy: he was intelligent, popular, cute, and athletic. He gave me his number and made me promise that I would call him.
Later that evening I was very nervous, but I called. When he got on the phone he greeted me as if we’d been longtime friends. To my surprise he asked, “You did your homework already?”
I knew he was just beating around the bush. I told him that I really had a boyfriend and that I couldn’t go out with him at the time. After that we’d pass each other in the hall without saying a word.
A few days later I broke up with my boyfriend, the shortest relationship I ever had (10 days). A couple of weeks after that I saw Dennis again. We got to talking and I told him that I no longer had a boyfriend.
He grabbed my hand, took me to an empty place and asked me to be his girlfriend.
With no hesitation I said yes, and thought that it was a start of a beautiful relationship-boy, was I wrong!
In the beginning everything was picture perfect. We’d cut a whole day of school and stay in the back staircase talking. We talked about our past relationships and the things that went wrong in them so that we’d know how to prevent anything from breaking us up. I never thought I’d find a guy who was this open and honest about his feelings.
Heavy Romance
He asked me to promise him that I would always be faithful and honest, no matter what, and if there was a problem that I would come to him with it. He was like someone you think only exists in fairytales.
We’d walk the halls hand in hand. It seemed as if we were together all the time. And when we were not in school we were on the phone.
I’d call him up as soon as I got home from school. We’d stay on the phone from 3 o’clock until 6 and then I’d ask him to call me back in 15 minutes. After that, we’d stay on for another three hours. Then I would call him back, and this would go on until the middle of the night.
I wrote many love poems for him, telling him how I felt about him, and all the things I’d do for him. He told me no one had ever done that before. I gave of myself wholeheartedly. I even got in trouble for him, but did not regret it one bit.
Sex In School
A month went by and things began to cool off. We were still happy, and were “doing it” on a daily basis in the back staircase at school. One day while we were back there I asked him if he ever used birth control (such as a condom). He didn’t answer me, he just quickly changed the subject.
It was November, and we weren’t all snugly-snugly, holding hands in public anymore, but I didn’t want to think negative. So many people tried to tell me that he was a player. They said he had a different girl for every period at school, and that I was just one of them.
I didn’t want to believe them. He seemed so perfect. I thought that because he told me he loved me that he wouldn’t try to play me out. But I was hurt to know what other people thought about him.
When I confronted him about these rumors, he set the story straight. He said that a lot of girls were after him, so it would be likely for them to say those things just so I would break up with him. He told me not to believe it, because I was his girl.
I had never let a guy get too close to me before but Dennis was different. His words would knock me out like a blow from Mike Tyson. He talked his way into my heart. He made me feel sorry for him by telling me sad stories about his childhood. It turned out he’d told other girls the same stories.
I still thought he was perfect. Then he stopped calling me, and I wondered why. I was always the one calling him. Then he started passing me in the halls and ignoring me. I knew that I hadn’t done anything wrong, so I asked him about it. He’d say he had said hello; I just didn’t hear him. At this point I knew something was really wrong.
December came and things only got worse. I stopped calling him since he wouldn’t call me. I didn’t see him as often as I used to and when I asked him why his reply was, “I was busy.” Many times he upset me and I didn’t say anything. Now I know that I should have.
I became very depressed and needed someone to talk to. I was just about ready to slit my wrists until I realized that my life is not worth taking for some guy who doesn’t appreciate my being there.
Then I had to deal with waiting for my monthly flow (period) to arrive. I did not want to face the possibility that I was pregnant. But I was. Over Christmas vacation I decided to call Dennis and tell him.
Two Months Pregnant
He asked what I was planning to do, as if he had no intention of helping me. I said “abortion” and he quickly agreed. Only then did he tell me that he wouldn’t leave me, because his father had done the same when he was young.
He called it “our problem” but it was really my problem because I was the only one fixing it. I waited two weeks to go to the doctor, and they told me that I was two months pregnant. A week later, I had an abortion. I did it all by myself with no help from him.
We didn’t speak for three months. When I look back on the things that I did for him, it makes me feel stupid. I bought him a Christmas card and gift and I did not get so much as a “Merry Christmas” from him. This is why I had not wanted any boy to get too close to me, because I knew that love is sooner or later followed by pain. And this one was the hardest.
I’m in trouble, only 14 and already I’ve been pregnant! No more straight A’s. My average is now a 75 and I’m failing many classes, all in my first year in high school.
Now we’re friends again-just friends. I finally decided to speak to him, instead of giving him dirty looks. He says he has tried to contact me during the three months. He says he wanted me to keep the baby, and that this whole ordeal was just a misunderstanding. Although deep down inside I still have very strong feelings for him, I also have this whole experience to remind me why we separated in the first place.
Girls, remember, most guys are all talk. Some may hide it better than others, but when you get right down to it, they’re not apt to be what you expected. Mine certainly wasn’t. He built the relationship on lies alone, and what hurts me the most is that I believed him.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.