My Boy-Stealing, Backstabbing Best Friend

(All names have been changed.)
Not long ago, I ended a friendship. It was the hardest decision I’ve ever made. For five years, Shannon was my best friend. It hurt to end the friendship, but I finally realized that being her friend hurt me more.
Shannon and I became good friends in 6th grade, and by high school, we were best friends. Shannon was outgoing and made me laugh. We’d make fake scenes in public, acting like we were retarded, or pretending to argue.
We confided in each other about things we didn’t tell other people. We were so close we even had a secret language which we could speak when we didn’t want anyone to know what we were saying.
Wherever I was, Shannon was, and vice versa. I went to her house almost every day after school. We’d go to the store for 50¢ sodas and junk food, then head to her room to listen to music, talk, call people-even do homework together. Everyone at my house is grown up; Shannon was like a sister my own age.
Cold Comments, Cold Shoulder
Shannon’s very pretty, and could be vain at times. Once she told a boy, “You should be happy I’m even talking to you; it’s a privilege just looking at me.” That didn’t trouble me, because I admired her confidence, since I wasn’t very confident myself.
But there were other things that bothered me about Shannon. When she was down, I tried my best to listen to her and console her. But when it was time for me to cry on her shoulder, she’d say things like, “I guess I’m not a good friend because I don’t know what to tell you,” instead of comforting me or giving me advice.
And sometimes she’d say negative things about how I looked or the colors I was wearing. Her comments hurt me, but I usually laughed them off or tried to pay them no mind. Once in a while, I told her how I felt about something she’d said, but she’d just say, “It’s the truth.”
The Big Problem: Boys
Even though I didn’t like those sides of Shannon, for a long time I thought I needed her in my life. It seemed like without her, there was no me. I loved having a best friend, always having someone to go places with me.
We had so much history together. It felt good walking into Shannon’s house as if it were my own and having people greet me like I lived there. It’s hard to walk away from something you’re so used to.
In the end, though, the big problem that kept getting in the way of our friendship was boys. Even though I thought she was prettier than I was, and boys tended to be drawn to her more than me, I got the feeling she was jealous of me.
Competition Brewing at McDonald’s
Every time a boy liked me instead of her, she’d get mad. Starting in 9th grade, she’d pursue any guy I liked in order to show that she could get him, even when I liked the guy way more than she did. And because she was pretty and a big flirt, she could.
When she tried to race to a boy I liked, I sometimes wondered why I was friends with someone so selfish and competitive.
But what should have been the last straw was when she started messing with the guy she knew I had a big crush on at our job.
Joey was the new manager at McDonald’s, where we both worked. I told Shannon I might talk to him. I thought if I told her I was interested, maybe I could stop her from going after him. But I was wrong.
That weekend she couldn’t stop talking about him. I could feel the competition brewing in her voice. But I wasn’t planning on giving this one up.
She Ruined My Birthday
Over the next few weeks, I got to know Joey pretty well, which made me like him even more. On my birthday, Shannon and I went to pick up our checks. “Do you think my baby is going to be there?” I said.
“Maybe,” said Shannon. “He said he was coming when he called me last night.”
I felt a rush of heat come over me and had to bite my lip from screaming. I hadn’t even known that he’d asked her for her number.
When we got to work, Shannon and Joey were all over each other, kissing and hugging. I was “tight” and hurt; she ruined my birthday.
Later that night, though, Shannon said she’d back off if I liked Joey because she didn’t want him coming between us. I was surprised and cautious, because it didn’t sound like her. But I said, “Yeah, back off.”
Like a Knife in My Back
The next weekend, Shannon said that Joey had invited me to the movies. “He wants me to come?” I said. “Are you sure? Because I’m not going to be a third wheel for you and him.”
“Girl, he wants you to come,” she said. Shannon made it seem like she was giving me a chance with Joey and that she’d told him that I liked him. I was surprised by her generosity and thoughtfulness.
But when Joey came to pick us up, it turned out the only reason he wanted me to come was so the friend he’d brought along wouldn’t be alone. Shannon then proceeded to make out with Joel all night, right in front of me.
I had to fight back the tears with everything I had in me. My heart broke.
Shannon had set me up. I felt like a knife was stuck into my back. At that moment, I felt like I could never trust her again.
That week, I knew I was right to be mad at her. But later that month, I began to doubt myself. I thought about everything I’d lose if I stopped being her friend, like our familiarity and closeness. I still loved her, so I told myself, “I don’t know Joey that well. I’m not gonna end our friendship over him.”
Friends From Habit
Soon enough, Shannon dropped Joey. I still hung out with Shannon a lot, but it didn’t feel right because the pain was still there. I felt like we were friends more out of habit.
It was the David incident two months later that finally broke that habit. I’d gone out with David before. I knew him well, and we were going out again. He was important to me. When I was having problems at home, I called David, not Shannon. I’d never felt for anyone how I felt for David, and Shannon knew it.
David had recently broken up with his old girlfriend, Nasia. They were still friends, talking often, and David had told me that she still wanted to be with him.
Turning to Shannon: Big Mistake
One night, David and I had a real big argument about Nasia. That night David called me and said that we needed a break, so then I thought he really was still with Nasia.
Upset, I turned to Shannon. “If David wants to be with Nasia, then he should just tell me,” I told her.
A few days later, I’m ashamed to say, I let Shannon’s boyfriend Leon call Nasia on three-way; I overheard her saying that she still went out with David. I was confused and hurt.
David soon called me and when he asked, I confessed to calling Nasia on three-way. Then he broke up with me. “You said if I wanna f-ckin’ be with Nasia, I could be with her,” he said.
“What! Who told you that?” I’d only told Shannon that, in confidence, and I hadn’t really wanted David to be with Nasia; I was just venting.
I felt like crying, not only because he broke up with me, but because I’d hurt him and because Shannon had betrayed me again. I felt like there was nowhere to turn for peace.
The Hurt Lingered
Later that week, David and I apologized to each other and made up. But Shannon had shaken my trust too many times. Over the next month, I chilled with her sometimes. I felt bad for her because she didn’t have many friends. But the hurt lingered every time I looked at her.
I kept thinking about what she’d done and realized it was finally time to end our friendship. Having David back in my life made it easier to let Shannon go.
I knew that if we talked, she’d cut me off and yell. Since I feel more confident and comfortable writing, I wrote her a well-thought-out email, so I could say what I felt without interruption.
In an e-mail, I explained to Shannon that I didn’t trust her anymore. “I love you, but I have to love myself too, because all you do is hurt me,” I wrote. “It’s taken me a while to love myself, and I finally do.” I explained to her the ways she hurt me in the past and why I didn’t consider her a friend anymore.
Shannon practically yelled at me back through e-mail, cursing. She said she didn’t know what she did that would cause me not to trust her.
She Was Stealing My Shine
I didn’t want to argue about it anymore. I was tired of letting her step all over me. I had to get away from her hold on me.
Now when I see Shannon, it’s like we don’t know each other. It’s been about six months since we stopped being friends. Every day I wonder whether I made the right decision to end the friendship, but then I think about all the times she hurt me.
I’ve also tried to keep myself busy with work and college planning so I won’t think too much about it.
David’s taken Shannon’s place, in a way, as a best friend. For a while, I neglected my other friends because I was scared of them hurting me. But I came to my senses and apologized to them. Now I feel like each of my friends fills a part in my life that Shannon once filled.
Maybe I thought I needed her because my confidence was low. But she was holding me back, stealing my shine. Without her I am a stronger, more self-assured person. And I won’t let anyone make me feel inferior again.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.