My Abused Friend
She Needs More Help Than I Can Give
By Anonymous
The names in this story have been changed.
When we were little kids, my friend Carmen always told me how her mother would beat her after she did something wrong. At first, I just figured that she was getting “disciplined” like everyone else. It wasn’t until one morning when I was 6, that I found out the truth.
Carmen lives pretty close, so we’d walk to school together. When I got to her house, Carmen’s mother was brushing her hair into a ponytail. She re-did that same ponytail maybe three or four times, causing Carmen to get restless. Mrs. Nichols started yelling that Carmen wasn’t sitting up straight, and was going to make her late for work because of all the time she was spending on Carmen’s hair. Then she pulled my friend up by the hair and hit her in the face with the hairbrush.
Carmen sucked her teeth in at her mother and got a hard slap across the face. Even though I was only 6, I knew that this wasn’t right.
Mrs. Nichols finished with Carmen’s hair and told her to hurry on to school. As Carmen packed her schoolbag, her mother gently smiled at me. “Good morning, Cindy,” she said and walked over to her bedroom.
Walking to school, I asked Carmen if she felt okay, and she nodded. “I told you,” she said a little later. And that was all.
The Hardest Thing I’ve Ever Experienced
As the years passed, the beatings have only increased in number and gotten more severe. Mr. Nichols cheats on his wife and has another child. Because he’s physically stronger than she is and has been known to beat her really badly, she takes her problems with him out on Carmen.
Sometimes you can hear yelling and crying coming from the house and, if the light was on in her bedroom, occasionally you’ll see Carmen’s mother moving around, trying to hit her.
This situation is probably the hardest thing in my life. I feel helpless and I never really know what to do. What can I do? What can I do that I know will work out, and truly benefit my friend? I’m not sure and neither is she.
As I’ve gotten older, I’ve tried different ways to help my friend deal with this situation. Whether it’s an ear to listen, a shoulder to cry on, or words to comfort, I always try to be there for her any way I can.
Sometimes Carmen will say that if she didn’t have friends over after school who drank all the juice in the refrigerator or other things like that, then her mom wouldn’t get so mad and hit her.
It’s Not Her Fault
I always try to let her know that she isn’t responsible for her mother’s actions and shouldn’t feel guilty. It isn’t her fault that her mother and father’s problems always seem to come down on her. I tell her that I think her mother still loves her, she just doesn’t know how to deal with her problems. (Although sometimes I have a hard time believing that.)
But what I think really helps her the most is my just listening to her explain what happens each time and let her feelings out, something she’s not allowed to do at home-It’s considered “backtalk.”
Now that Carmen is 14, her mom will call her a “tramp” and mean names just because a lot of older guys who she doesn’t give the time of day notice her. I advise her not to argue with her mother for whatever reason-even if she knows her mother is wrong and she has a deep desire to yell back at her.
Because of her anger at her mother, whenever someone at school gives Carmen problems or gets jealous of her and talks behind her back, she’ll fight them. And since she can really bust ass, she’s the one who gets in trouble and gets her mother called in for a parent conference, a poor conduct grade, and usually a suspension (not to mention another beating).
Let It Out
Recently, I told her to release her emotions through writing because that has always worked for me. Although she previously hated writing, she likes it more now, and frequently writes her “memoir essays,” as she calls them, and some poetry.
Meanwhile, the beatings continue. If I’m around when it’s happening I try to stop it. Sometimes I’ll try talking to Mrs. Nichols right then and there. Because she is usually convinced that Carmen is to blame, I’ll apologize for her. I’ll say that Carmen didn’t mean it and that everything is going to be okay and will work itself out. I hate to lie, but I think I sound pretty convincing.
Other times I’ll approach her in the most indirect way possible so she won’t think her daughter put me up to it or that we’re plotting something against her. (I don’t want Carmen to get wrecked after I leave.)
I’ll start off saying, “How are you doing today, Mrs. Nichols?…Yeah that’s nice…Yes, I’m doing okay in school…” Then I ask her how she feels about the bad things that are going on with her husband and whether she really feels Carmen is responsible. I’ll ask her if she really thinks “getting mad” will change anything.
Black Eyes Don’t Just Happen
I try to let her know that this really bothers her daughter and I make it really clear that Carmen still loves her, maybe to soften up her heart a little. She never says whether she will stop or not but, because we get along so well, at least she’s willing to listen and even admit in the most indirect way that it is a problem.
But most of the time Mrs. Nichols only says that Carmen was “trying to act bright with me,” and that the beatings “just happen.” I’m sorry; black eyes, swollen cheeks, and overflowing tears don’t just happen, not in my opinion.
Several times I’ve tried to find places for her to stay where she’d be safe and away from her mother. I tried hooking her up with friends and relatives on Long Island. Although Carmen wanted to get away, she always refuses to go for fear that her mother will find a way to get back at her for trying something like running away.
Carmen always gets scared when taking a step toward solving the problem. She feels that there isn’t any solution and that she’ll just have to live with it until she’s older and can get out of the house and get her revenge.
Fed Up
One day last spring, after Mrs. Nichols woke her up in the middle of the night and hit her because Carmen was upset that Mr. Nichols was getting home late, she finally decided that she’d had enough. She came to school the next day with her left cheek all swollen. She was real distant in class and everyone could tell that she didn’t want to talk about it so nobody really pressed her for information.
Not until later in the day did Daquan (another friend that tries to help her sometimes) and I try talking about it.
“What’s up, Carmen? You alright?” Daquan asked. “What happened wit you moms?”
“Oh, she was just whackin’ my ass from 3 in the mornin’ because my daddy came home late,” she replied.
“Do you want me to get some ice for your cheek, Carmen?” I asked. “Or get some cocoa butter from my bag?”
“No, it’s okay, y’all. I’m just feelin’ real dizzy. I need to go home.”
But Daquan said, “That’s f-ked up though, cuz she there now.”
I suggested that she go to the nurse’s office and lie down for the rest of the day. But she said she was fed up with “all this sh-t” and decided to talk to a school guidance counselor.
Our friend Daquan and I walked Carmen to Mrs. Buckley’s office. Carmen explained what had been going on and, without telling Carmen what she was planning to do, Mrs. Buckley called her mother. She told Carmen’s mother that she was aware of the problem and gave her some kind of warning, I believe. Carmen arrived home that afternoon to find her mother prepared to whip her for what she’d done.
Needless to say, Carmen felt betrayed and gave up whatever hope she might have had of trying to take any kind of action.
A couple of months later, I was walking down the block one evening and heard Carmen crying hysterically up in her room. Her aunt let me in and muttered something about Carmen’s mom “hurting that girl.”
I went upstairs and Mrs. Nichols was in the hall with the most peculiar look on her face. It was like this half-sad, half-mad expression. When she’s beating up on Carmen she’s always mad but this time it was different. It was as if she was beginning to feel sorry for Carmen and regret what she’d done.
I asked her how she was, although a part of me wanted to smack her.
“Alright, Cindy,” she said. “It’s just Carmen. You know how she is-never listening, trying to act bright with me. I didn’t want to, but she just…Oh, you know, it just happened.”
The Worst It Had Ever Been
Standing outside Carmen’s bedroom door, I braced myself. I closed my eyes for a second and prayed it wouldn’t be as bad as I thought it might be.
It was even worse. It had never been like this before. Carmen was sitting on her bed with her beautiful hair all in her face. She didn’t have that usual distant look that she gets and she wasn’t trying to act like nothing happened. She was just crying and crying.
I went over to her and slowly, painfully pushed her hair from her face and pulled it back into a pony tail. It was hard to look directly at her. Her left eye was swollen shut and she had black and reddish bruises all over her face. The right side of her nose was scratched and there were little marks all up and down her arms and a cut on her left knee.
My heart was breaking for her and I think it was my crying that finally got her to stop. She just sat there perfectly still with the most distant look on her face that I’ve ever seen on anyone.
I went to the kitchen to make her some peppermint tea because she always says that makes her feel better inside. This time I had to force her to drink it. Then she finally told me what happened.
Wrecked Up For Washing Her Hair
It seems Mrs. Nichols had told Carmen to wash her hair only on a certain day of the week so she wouldn’t use up all the shampoo in the house. Now Carmen is very conscious of her looks, especially her hair, and she washed it anyway. When her mom came home and saw that the shampoo was finished Carmen said that she slapped her all over her body, punched her repeatedly in the face, kicked her and pulled her around by the hair, whacking her in the face with a vacuum cleaner attachment.
She wrecked Carmen up so bad. I didn’t even think Mrs. Nichols had that much strength in her. She seems so fragile herself.
After she finished telling me what happened, Carmen blurted out, “I’m going to call Child Welfare on that b-ch, so that they can make her pay!”
Child Welfare (CWA) is the agency that deals with child abuse. We’d talked about it before. We didn’t really know what it was going to do but we just felt that it might get something started towards finding a way out. Once I even handed her the phone but she wouldn’t go through with it because she was afraid her mother would find a way to get back at her. This time it was the same thing.
She said that she didn’t want to talk about it anymore and we went to the living room and watched MTV. But neither one of us was really paying attention. I mean, how could we?
“It’s Like I’m Trapped”
After that day, when Carmen would come to school all sad and beaten up I’d accompany her to the nurse’s office so she could lie down for the day. She’d rather do that than go back to a guidance counselor because she doesn’t believe that would solve the problem. The counselor would probably only call her mother up again and then her mother would be waiting for her when she got home from school. “It’s like I’m trapped,” she once told me.
That night with the shampoo was the worst it’s ever been. But Carmen says that she survived. “How much worse could it get?” she asked me.
The thing is that we both feel deep down that it is going to get a lot worse. Sometimes I worry that she’ll wind up in a coma one day.
Many times I feel that I should do more but I don’t know what more I can do. So for now, I’ll just be there to offer my ear and that peppermint tea that she likes. I just want Carmen to know that whenever she needs it, help from me is dependable. My ear, heart, mind, and door are always open.
My Abused Friend: She Needs More Help Than I Can Give (Part I)
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.