Men: Are They Friends or Fiends?

Sometimes when you are alone with a guy, he’ll act like a little puppy clinging to you as if you were his mother and trying to amuse you with his pleas for attention. But get him around his friends and he’s so hard you couldn’t break him with a chisel.
I have two different opinions about guys, both based on personal experience. It’s hard for me to say that all men are scum, creeping out of the crevices of the dirty earth, because of the love that I have for the ones that are my friends. But, because of my past disappointments, I can’t say that I would completely trust a boy that I got involved with either.
In sixth grade, my friends and I were violated by three boys who enjoyed grabbing our bodies wherever they desired. We always tried to fight back but we couldn’t do much, so we got beat up. In seventh grade, I found out that a friend of mine was being raped continually by her own stepbrother. After running away every week, she ended up in a foster home.
Since entering high school, many of my friends have been date raped and beaten by their own boyfriends. I have tried to convince them to leave these relationships but their “lovers” seemed to have a hold on these girls’ self-respect as well as their mental stability.
I myself almost became one of those girls when I began to date a violent boy. He tried to make me stay with him by telling me that no one else would understand and love me.
I was weak at the time and looking for something to hold on to. I thought I needed him because he was the first boy to understand my pain. But, further into the relationship, he began to be my main source of affliction and I realized that it needed to end.
Friendship Is One Thing. . .
Because of these experiences, I think I would be justified if I spoke of men as if they were animals and fiends. However, my eyes are not the kind to look at an entire gender with prejudice. I cannot say that I hate them, because ever since I was a young girl most of my closest friends have been boys.
In fact, I got over my idea that all men are a-holes because these friends were so incredible and we understood each other’s interests and beliefs. Guys used to seem evil to me, but I learned from my male friends that there are stupid people in the world and you cannot blame other people for their actions.
My male friends cared for me as they would for a sister. Since they were so good to me, I figured that other guys would be too, even if we were more than friends. I went on believing that one day I would meet a boy like one of them that I could be friends with as well as other things.
Boyfriends Try To Change Your Hair, Your Clothes, Your Mind
But when I started to go out with guys, it seemed that there was no escaping being judged as just another piece of ass before I even had the chance to speak. I have found a lot of guys to be conditioned into hating women and taking out this hatred on their girlfriends. Once you become somebody’s girl, you are looked at differently than a friend. You become a physical object, sometimes appreciated but most of the time looked down upon.
I’ve seen the way some of my girlfriends let their boyfriends abuse them in cruel ways. These guys looked at them as people to improve and tried to change them by ridiculing them. They would tell my friends to color their hair or change the way they dress or even assign them books to read. I can’t tell you how many times I got woken up in the middle of the night by a friend crying in hysteria after being treated this way.
They asked me what they should do but they would never really follow my advice. I would ask, “Why are you with him then? Don’t you understand that you’re letting this happen?” Their responses always turned out to be the same: insecurity, fear of loneliness, the love they thought they felt.
Don’t Call That Love
“That’s not love,” I would say. “Love is a beautiful mutual feeling that in no way should bring pain and uncertainty to someone.” But they didn’t listen. The next day always came and whether the truce was accomplished with flowers or just a simple “I love you,” it was enough to make these girls forget the pain they felt the night before.
I was in a relationship like that myself and it was hard to break away. For a long time, I thought that he was all I had. I was younger then, I thought I needed and loved him. But he violated my trust with lies and mind manipulations. Every time I tried to leave him, he ran back pleading for another chance. But the more destructive he became, the more I began realizing that it wasn’t my fault or concern and that he just needed psychological help.
One time we got into a fist fight after I tried to end the relationship. It was the first time that he hit me. When his fist hit my face, I got him on the floor and with several severe kicks, indented my boot print into his skull. That was the very end of our “romance.”
Even though I had come to the realization that I did not need him months before, it took that night to totally throw whatever feeling I had for him away. Four years have passed but I’m still afraid of him.
This bad relationship did not stop me from dating other guys because I didn’t blame all of them for what he did. But I think if I had, it would have saved me a lot of trouble and headaches. Just staying good friends with guys has been really hard. I see their beauty, as they see mine, and therefore I love and care for them. But I’m always shocked by how, in front of me, they’ll speak of how stupid girls are and brag about getting over on them.
Ain’t I a Woman?
My friends don’t seem to understand that it bothers me to hear them talk this way about women. They think that because they’re not talking about me directly I shouldn’t care. Don’t they realize that I am a girl and that no matter who they are speaking about when they say “b-ches” I am included? My guy friends tell me that if my boyfriend treats me with any form of disrespect, they will kill him. But how different can he treat me from the way they treat their girls?
For instance, I went to the movies the other night with a guy. We saw The Piano, a flick about a mute woman who was married off to someone she did not love. The boy I was with said to me: “I don’t understand why that guy in the movie was so stupid. If I had a wife that never talked, I’d be the happiest man in the world.”
I began screaming at him to shut up because he knew that what he was saying was not true. He admitted that, but said he couldn’t resist making a chauvinistic remark. I think he knew that if his male friends had been around, they would’ve praised him for saying that.
Some day I may meet the boy of my dreams, and he may be worth all of my confidence and dedication but I may not give it to him because of my fear of trusting guys. I’ve become a cynic about love and marriage and all those other beautiful things I once believed were possible.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.