Lost in the Equation

Starting this school year, public schools across New York City are all using the same methods of teaching reading and math. Before, schools chose their own ways of teaching these subjects.
Of these changes, I’m happiest about the math program. I’ve had three different styles of math teaching since I started elementary school.
Now that I’m in high school, I look at numbers like I’m reading Chinese. My mind goes blank and I give up. Whether it’s algebra or geometry, math does not make sense to me. I’ve had this problem since the 5th grade and I think it’s partly because each school I was in taught math a different way.
New York City Department of Education chancellor Joel Klein has aimed the math changes mostly at elementary and middle schools, to ensure that students like me learn the basics. He believes that students will do better if they all learn through the methods that Department of Education has picked.
Never Learned Long Division
My past math experiences have left me feeling like I’m quite possibly the worst math student in the world. Give me a simple problem to solve and I’m sure I’ll sit there, scratch my head and then throw the paper on the floor in frustration.
My teachers in my elementary school didn’t spend that much time on math. In the three years I spent at P.S. 41, from 3rd to 5th grade, I remember studying more about Native Americans than fractions. I didn’t even learn long division.
Since the P.S. 41 curriculum didn’t emphasize those skills, my parents forced me to go to a tutoring program separate from the school to learn long division. Instead of teaching a concept once and only once, my tutor actually gave me practice math problems that I’d have to solve over and over again. Although it was tedious, I learned something.
My weak math skills from elementary school messed me up for middle school. At Baruch Middle School, we used a series of textbooks that seemed to jump from topic to topic. After we were done with one section, we moved on to something else, and I couldn’t figure out the connection between the two units.
Word Problem Hell
These books had a lot of word problems, like “The school has a new plan to install lockers, and they need to do it in the smallest amount of space possible. What is the smallest amount of space the maximum number of lockers can take up?”
Since I couldn’t recall any basic math skills that might help me, these assignments were an exercise in frustration.
To make things worse, the questions in the book built on each other, so if you couldn’t grasp the book’s method of solving the simplest problem, you were helpless for the rest of the section.
High School Math is a Mystery
Any skills that I might have gained from that program were lost the year I started high school and the Arise math program. Arise seems like it has nothing to with my middle school math. The assignments in Arise seemed to build on skills that I’d never learned.
I wasn’t the only one who was frustrated. Other students in my class felt the same way. And not even my parents could help me with the work, since they couldn’t figure out what the textbook was trying to teach us.
Because of my confusion, I felt anxious about taking standardized math tests like the SAT and the Regents. In the Arise program, we spent a lot of time working on how to read graphs and their slopes, but that wasn’t a big part of the Math A Regents. My teacher had to put aside the Arise textbook for a couple of weeks to prepare us for Math A. I got a 67-at least I passed.
I’m not surprised that more than 62% of elementary and middle school students failed the citywide math exams last spring. And while the June 2003 Math A Regents was controversial because so many students failed it, even on the June 2002 test, only 51% of New York City students passed.
Like me, they probably didn’t learn the basics, or they moved from elementary to middle to high school, only to encounter an entirely different method of learning the subject at each level. This chaotic approach made me feel less confident that I’ll ever be able to understand math.
To address the unusually high number of students who fail the standardized math tests, the city has chosen to impose a standard curriculum. In kindergarten to 5th grade students will use a program called Everyday Math, and Impact Math will be used for the 6th to 8th grades. The new high school math curriculum will build on Impact Math and focus on preparing students for the Math A Regents exam, which is usually taken at the end of 9th or 10th grade.
One Math Program For All
But not all schools are required to teach the new curricula. Last spring, the Department of Education came up with a list of what it considered to be the top 200 or so schools, including my school, the NYC Lab School. These schools won’t have to change the methods they are using.
Many schools aren’t happy about having to switch the way they teach. Some staff argue that their school does a good job of educating students already, so they should stick with what they’re doing. Many critics of the standard curriculum say that there’s more to academic success than test scores, and that their students-and their teaching methods-are being treated unfairly. Others argue that the city’s new standard programs aren’t the best methods available, so they shouldn’t be forced on schools.
But I say, why not include all the schools? I think the new standardized curriculum would have helped me. But as a student in one of the top 200 performing schools, I won’t benefit from these changes, nor will students like me who may attend here in the future.
It’s Too Late for Me
It’s tough coming into a school where the math is different than the math you were learning before. Even if changing schools is simply a matter of graduating from one grade to the next, switching from one style to another makes math more confusing for those of us who have difficulty with the subject. If the high school program picked up where the middle school program left off, then maybe we’d feel more confident about what we know, and our test scores would improve.
If the city wants better test results for all its students, then I think it’s smart to impose a uniform curriculum on every school. We all have to take the same standardized tests, and we should all be learning the same material. I’m a senior now, so it’s too late for me, but other kids shouldn’t have to feel as hopeless as I do about math.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.