Is your school overcrowded? Are you often late getting from one class to another? Have you ever gotten stuck in the middle of a fist fight that had nothing to do with you because you couldn’t move out of the way?
I’m Caitlin, and I spent my junior year at Newtown HS in Queens with about 4,500 other kids, which is double the number the school was built to fit.
And I, D’nashia, go to Abraham Lincoln HS in Brooklyn. Last semester, I had as many as 37 students in some of my classes. I’ve been able to get the attention I need from teachers because I speak up and push my way past the crowd, but a lot of other students get overlooked.
As Angelica Manugo, one of my fellow students at Lincoln, put it, “I feel I’m not being taught enough. There are 36 kids in my average class. I don’t feel I get enough attention from the teacher because there are too many people in the classroom.”
Splitting Up Big Schools
Right now, almost 75% of the city’s public high school students attend overcrowded schools, according to the New York City Independent Budget Office (a publicly-funded agency that analyzes city problems).
In my (Caitlin’s) interview with Schools Chancellor Klein, he said that he is trying to stop overcrowding. He’s asking the New York State government for enough money to “create 73,000-76,000 new seats in the system” by building new schools or adding on to existing schools.
Also, Klein and a nonprofit organization called New Visions are using money donated by various foundations to split some overcrowded schools into smaller high schools. In many cases, the smaller schools share the same large building but have separate administrations (that is, principals and faculties). In some places, each school has its own floor.
I (D’nashia) visited the Bronx Academy of Letters, one of the city’s 41 new small high schools. The school opened this past fall with 78 9th graders; next year it will add another freshman class of the same size and continue this way until it has all four grades.
Unlike at Lincoln, I felt comfortable and relaxed at the Bronx Academy of Letters, which takes up part of a middle school building in the South Bronx. The hall (there’s only one because the school is so small) is wide enough for everyone. The students were friendly, respectful and calm, and they gave the school a sense of safety.
I asked seven students what they liked about their school, and almost all of them mentioned getting lots of attention from their teachers.
Joanne Briacero said, “I like this school because everyone knows each other. Everyone gets the attention they want. Everyone is recognized for their personality.”
According to Joanne, a minor disadvantage of the personal attention is that every few weeks, a teacher calls her parents to let them know how she’s doing. “I don’t like that they call home always,” she said.
Sometimes Two Teachers For One Class
While at Lincoln we have one teacher for every 35 students, at the Bronx Academy of Letters there’s a teacher for every 15 students. Student Onyebuchi Chilako shocked me when he said, “Sometimes there are two teachers in one class.”
Like the other new small schools, the Bronx Academy of Letters has a theme. At some schools it’s medicine or business. At the Bronx Academy of Letters, it’s writing.
To get into the school, Joanne, Onyebuchi and their fellow students had to write letters explaining why the Academy appealed to them, and they also had to be interviewed. They were competing against about 90 other kids; this year more than 400 kids wanted one of the school’s 78 spots.
Will Georgantas, program administrator at the Academy of Letters, told us that the school is going to try its best to stay small even as it gets more popular.
Klein said that the Department of Education is trying “to do a better job at distributing students more effectively so we don’t have overcrowding, but the truth is, overcrowding results partly because people want to go to particularly good high schools, and so they end up, obviously, trying to get into schools that they think are good.”
I’d rather go to a school like the Bronx Academy of Letters than go to Lincoln. But when I was choosing schools four years ago, I didn’t get into any of the schools I wanted. Lincoln wasn’t on my list of schools, but I had to go there because it’s my zone school.
Because of situations like mine, this year’s 8th graders have to make a list of 12 high schools they’d like to attend. It’s guaranteed that each student will get into at least one from their list.
Said Klein, “we’re focusing people on making the choices.”
Not Enough Good Schools For Everyone
Klein admitted that “There’s no quick fix” to the overcrowding problem. He said that people in good schools that are overcrowded don’t want to transfer. “They’d like other people to transfer someplace else, but they don’t want to leave the school they’re in.” So those schools stay overcrowded.
Klein acknowledged that creating new schools like the Bronx Academy of Letters and getting more money for new buildings won’t help kids like me who are now in overcrowded schools. He said, “One of the things that I think we need is to do a much better job of imposing order [in the hallways and classrooms].”
But, he continued, “The truth is, we don’t have enough good options, and it’s a real problem. That’s why we’re doing this whole high school reform, to try and see if we can create enough good choices for people. Every high school should be a choice high school.”
Lost in the Crowd
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.