Resolved: That development of natural resources for the present is more important than protection of the environment for the future.
On May 3, twelve students from New York City public high schools competed in the final round of the seventh annual Lincoln-Douglas Debates, sponsored by Chemical Bank and the Board of Education. The three-member debate teams were from four high schools: John Adams and Cardozo argued as novice teams, and Bronx Science and John Bowne argued as experienced teams.
The debates are named after the famous debates between Abraham Lincoln and Stephen Douglas in the race for the Illinois Senate seat in 1858.
Teams from 86 New York public high schools competed in this year’s tournament, arguing the value of developing natural resources versus protecting the environment. The debates promote and reward skills in oral communication and public speaking.
Martha Graham, assistant vice-president at Chemical Bank, explained that although much needed attention was being given to the basic skills of reading, writing and math, “nobody seemed to be talking about the spoken word…We felt that was an area lacking in attention.”
Growing Interest In Debating
Much has changed since the inception of the Lincoln-Douglas Debates in 1983.
“When we were first planning this, only seven New York public schools had debate teams,” noted Graham. “Now, because of the Lincoln-Douglas tournaments, many schools are instituting speech and debate classes, or making speech a part of their English or social studies class.” She said that 75% of public schools now have debate teams.
“The caliber of the presentations has improved consistently …Schools all the way down the line are coming with stronger and stronger presentations,” Graham added.
Chemical Bank provides funding for the awards, sites for the tournament, and recruits judges, timekeepers, and moderators for the rounds. The Board of Education handles the immense workload of coordinating the schools, scheduling the tournament, and training the judges, timekeepers, and moderators. The Daily News is also involved in publicity and presentation.
In the finals, Benjamin Cardozo HS won the novice division against John Adams HS, and Bronx Science defeated John Bowne in the experienced division. Both of the winning teams argued for the affirmative: that present development is more important than protection of the environment for the future.
“I thought that [the resolution] was difficult to research. The negative has more publicity than the positive,” said Lisa Outar, 16, a member of the John Adams HS team. “Personally, I feel that the environment does take precedence.”
Decided By a Coin Toss
Each team’s position-either affirmative or negative-was determined on the day of the tournament by a coin toss; they had to be prepared to argue both sides of the resolution. This uncertainty added to the many pressures of the debates.
“The psychological aspect was very straining,” admitted Sharon Eng, 16, of Cardozo HS.
“Time constraints were a problem,” added Mark Sourian, 17, of Bronx Science.
Each team had only a few fleeting minutes in which to state the main points of their argument, cross examine the opposing side, and rebut their assertions. As a result of their intensity, the debates develop a wide range of abilities in participating students.
“Debating is an amazing experience. It is one of the few available things in high school that develops oral and literary skills, and quick thinking,” said Eng.
“It’s helped a lot in terms of organization and structure… being more confident about yourself in public,” agreed Sourian.
“I’m more assertive now,” stated Outar. “My strong point is arguing and that reinforces my interest in law.”
The winners were given $10,000 each, and their schools $5,000. Those in second place received $4,000 each, their schools $2,500. Furthermore, each contestant in the final tournament is to be given a summer job by Chemical Bank.
Lincoln-Douglas Debates: A Proud Tradition
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.