Let the President Take Charge

The U.S. Constitution gives both the President and the Congress certain powers. Congress has the power to declare war, but the Presiden tas commander in chief of the armed forces can exercise his executive power to protect the interests of the United States.
Since 1941, Congress hasn’t officially declared war. Instead, several Presidents have taken the matter into their own hands by sending U.S. armed forces overseas to war or into situations that were equivalent to war.
A Quick Decision
Perhaps Congress’ sole power to declare war has proven to be impractical and must be redefined to meet the needs of our ever changing society. For example, wherever the President goes, a military aide is present carrying a briefcase filled with all the codes necessary to order a nuclear attack. The creators of the constitution could never have foreseen the modern scenarios that warrant such immediate presidential action.
Last August, President Bush was forced to make a quick decision and deploy troops to the Persian Gulf to protect Saudi Arabia. By the time Congress would have reached a decision, Hussein could have taken over Saudi Arabia.
And in 1989, President Bush invaded Panama in an effort to capture Noriega and curtail his drug trafficking. If Bush had waited for Congress to declare war on Panama, his plan to invade would have become public knowledge. This would have given Noriega extra time to assemble his army and go into hiding.
As leader of the armed forces, the President must be able to defend attacks against the U.S. and its interests. If he had to consult with and report to Congress before committing U.S. troops to war, it would harm his ability to hold tough, confidential negotiations-the kind that could prevent a war altogether. Leaders at the other end of the bargaining table would also have the upper hand if they didn’t have to get permission before going to war.
Congress Protects local Interests
Concerns about re-election can influence both the President’s and Congress’ decision whether or not to engage in a war. But since the President is elected by all 50 states, he is more likely to vote in the nation’s best interest. On the other hand, Congressional representatives, who are elected by their state, are more likely to vote in a way that protects the interests of local supporters. A member of Congress representing a state with a military plant, for example, would most likely favor a war since it would increase employment for his constituents.
I feel that the decision to declare war should no longer be off limits to the President. It’s just not practical. If a situation warrants immediate action to protect the interests of the United States, the President should be able to use his judgment to commit troops without Congressional consent.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.