Let Alternative Schools Stay Alternative

Dear Chancellor Klein,
Since the state mandated Regents diplomas a few years ago, many of the city’s best alternative public schools have had to change the way they teach. These schools, like Humanities Preparatory Academy, where I go, used to have students create portfolios, collecting their work in different subjects. Now, they are replacing senior portfolios with the Regents. That’s going in the wrong direction.
Students learn best when a teacher can design an educational plan suited to their needs. Now, instead of creative teaching and learning, classes are boring because teachers are just teaching the test.
They’re more concerned with teaching students how to pass the test than with actually teaching us how to analyze or write about the material they’re covering. Moreover, the pressure put on teachers by the test makes it harder for them to accommodate students with varying skill levels.
Not too long ago, I complained to my adviser that my math class is too easy. My adviser said that the Regents has made it very hard for math teachers to give students special attention.
When schools or teachers are given the freedom to run their own classes, they can choose what material to cover, and how to make the class engaging for the students. They can really prepare students for college by teaching us how to study, research, write and analyze, not memorize facts.
I understand that the problem with portfolios is that they’re hard to assess. For the most part, the Regents exams are graded automatically, so it’s easy to grade thousands of exams. One might think that it would be impossible to grade a large number of portfolios using consistent standards, but it’s not.
Starting in the spring of 2005, students will be taking a new SAT that includes an essay. The SAT essay will be graded on a scale of 1 to 6, by two different independent readers. A similar setup could make it possible for students to graduate by compiling portfolios instead of taking the Regents.
New York City has some very successful alternative schools, where the teachers are responsive to the students’ needs. Many portfolio schools perform better than Regents-bound schools. Both attendance and college acceptance rates are much higher for Humanities Prep students than the citywide average. We have seen what makes a school succeed: small classes, and teachers who are willing to work hard to provide a good learning environment for each student. Understanding teachers and interesting work motivate kids more than difficult tests.
Sam Greenlee
Humanities Preparatory Academy, Manhattan

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.