I can’t recall much about my early years. I know that I was four or five years old when I was snatched by the BCW (on charges of abuse and neglect). I’ve been through four foster homes in 10 years. And although I don’t remember abuse in my biological home (perhaps I was too young to know), I do remember abuse in some of the foster homes that I’ve had to live in.
In latter years, however, I’ve suffered more from emotional neglect than physical abuse. Coming to terms with the universal solitude of this system is quite a hurtful thing. But when I consider this now, I really wonder why I had to be moved so many times. Whether I was near or far from my parents was never really an issue in my life.
However, ACS Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta thinks it was. For he and many other big shots in the foster care business are now endorsing a plan of community-centered reform called neighborhood- based services.
Community-Based Reform
This is a plan for restructuring the foster care system into community-based networks to “better protect children and assist their families,” according to the Center for an Urban Future.
This plan also includes a new policy for community-based foster care placement. Officials cite the tremendous geographical mismatch of foster children to foster homes, where thousands of children are placed in foster homes outside their neighborhoods, when just as many foster homes exist within the neighborhoods the children were removed from.
Serious Implications
Like Crown Heights, Brooklyn, for example, which in 1991 lost 1,496 children to foster care (placed in separate areas) and yet that very same year became home to 1,186 foster children from other neighborhoods. Child Welfare Watch (an adult magazine on foster care) responds to this issue: “This geographic disconnect has serious implications for the children placed in foster care and for their natural families. Consequences include prolonged stays in foster care as well as chaos in the child’s everyday life.”
Okay, good point. So therefore, under the new plan, if a child is removed from a home in a district like Morrisania in the South Bronx (where 63.8 per 1,000 of the children suffer from abuse and neglect, by the way), that child will be placed in a foster home in Morrisania.
I guess it’s time to state the obvious. Neighborhood-based placements and services are absolutely not enough to effectively attack the drugs, violence, and poverty that cause these abuse and neglect situations in the first place. And they certainly don’t do a goddamn to help us kids who have no choice but to stay in the foster care system.
This Is No Place for Any Child
Having grown up in the South Bronx, I can certainly say that it’ll take a hell of a lot more than the ACS to stop the drug dealers and other vermin (some of whom might happen to be my relatives, by the way) from having serious effects on the families that live in these neighborhoods. But perhaps I’m asking too much from the wrong commissioner.
Child Welfare Watch says (in reference to the abuse reports from Morrisania), “[T]he New York City Administration for Children’s Services (ACS) has not expanded the preventive services that could blunt that spike [abuse rate].”
My feeling on preventive services is: unless this package includes (which it does not) a full decriminalization and upgrading of streets, schools, hospitals, and housing in the neediest neighborhoods (the ones that supply most of the foster kids), it is very unlikely that the new policy will play any significant role in blunting this “spike” or any of the other key social ills that most often make foster care necessary.
Child Welfare Watch also says: “When foster care caseworkers have little familiarity with neighborhoods where their clients live, they are not always aware of community resources, like preventive services, drug rehabilitation, mental health services, schools and after-school programs, and they are less capable of working with parents. A speedy resolution to the case is thus undermined.”
True. But perhaps they failed to mention that these cases often take place in some of the deadliest areas in the civilized world. The social workers have every right to be afraid of these neighborhoods. I know I am when I go home every night.
Causes Are Overlooked
I never spend an ounce of unnecessary time outdoors in the South Bronx. I don’t even like to go to the movies there. My adoptive mother thinks it’s because I like to live life lavishly in Manhattan. Man, I just don’t want to get killed! Especially since I’m now going to a school on the Upper East Side of Manhattan. You can imagine the difference.
It’s quite frightening how they (ACS) would rather a child be placed in a nearby foster home in a neighborhood (like mine), where almost all of the children suffer from abuse or neglect, simply because they live there.
The fact is: until sweeping social and political changes are made, it is a crime that children are allowed to live in such places in the richest nation in the world. This community-based foster care policy only adds insult to injury by dealing with the EFFECTS of the problem and not the causes.
Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness
Now, before I get on to my own recommendations, let me say again that I believe these ideas are being proposed without regard to the 20% of children who can never return to their families.
I see this plan as a cop-out that ignores the poor quality of foster “care” itself, which is frequently overlooked when adults discuss the “major” issues.
Since foster parents allegedly commit less than 0.5% of abuse (according to Edith Holzer of the Council of Family and Child Caring Agencies), people don’t see conditions in the foster home as an important topic. Ironic, since system activists often speak of the “trauma” of foster care. They can seldom imagine the trauma that develops when an impatient foster parent with questionable motives ($) doesn’t know what the hell he/she has gotten into.
It also seems like the foster care experts measure success chiefly upon reunification or adoption and as brief an experience in foster care as possible.
While I don’t disagree with the latter, the former strikes me as shifting a bit from the central purpose, which is “child welfare.” Whether reunification or adoption is good for the individual child doesn’t appear to be the issue here, just that they are achieved.
And while every child should be able to grow up with his or her biological parents (no doubt), every living being is also entitled to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. I believe this is what the ACS is there for, to help unfortunate children who’ve lost their parents (in more ways than one, mind you) to live a healthy, happy existence. This means improving the system for those of us who have to stay here. These new policies don’t address this issue, so they are not “foster care” reforms.
If I Were Commissioner
Now, I understand that the ACS needs solutions, so in the spirit of “You gotta better idea, pal?” I have undertaken to construct my own set of reforms, keeping in mind the reality of tight-wad politicians nowadays.
I recommend that the neediest areas of the city be divided into separate sectors where special neighborhood committees observe the conditions in that area (educational, economic, social) on a six-month basis, and then report their findings directly to the mayor for mandatory funding to remedy the situation.
If the removal of a child is considered necessary, social workers should work in conjunction with INDEPENDENT system advocates (local clergy, community activists, etc., who should serve as checks and balances on the system).
They should decide (after much observation) what is in the interest of the child (barring any pre-ordained goals, such as reunification or adoption). The course of action should be decided by the nature of the individual case. And there shouldn’t be more than three cases per social worker at any one time.
And in the area of foster care: foster parents should be told the realities of foster care and be better prepared to take care of kids like us. And under no circumstances should geography, race, religion, etc., be anywhere near the prime criteria for placement in a foster home. This should be determined by the parenting capabilities, awareness, and stability of the foster parents (with higher standards for all three, by the way).
Foster Care Is Traumatic
Now someone might ask: “Where will we put the children if we can’t find ‘perfect’ foster parents like these?”
I’ll answer that in the form of a question: Why take me from my home if you can’t find a better place?
But, of course, someone might also say: “The foster parents don’t have to be great, just as long as they’re mentally and financially stable (which the real parents in this case presumably aren’t). Then it’s all right.”
No. It’s not all right. Being taken from your family (as most people readily admit) is a trauma that can become a paralyzing wound if handled improperly. And when I say “trauma,” I don’t mean mental retardation. It can manifest itself later on in the child’s life in the form of unusual timidness, severe attitude problems, or a simple unwillingness to deal with the outside world.
Therefore, the nurturing responsibility for foster parents is that much greater. Merely imitating a home environment is not the answer. Otherwise, the ACS might just as well send foster kids to live in the agencies (at least we can be sure of food, clothes, and shelter), because having foster parents simply to bring them in for parent-teacher night is not worth the misery.
I also recommend that the ACS, Child Welfare Watch, and other groups bring their concerns about the safety of New York’s (and America’s) children into the public eye.
Children’s Rights Movement
I personally think the interests of our children are as important now as the civil rights movement was 30 years ago. Practical people might say that such a movement for children today would be highly unlikely.
But I see nothing more impractical than spending millions of U.S. dollars searching for little green men on Mars (like NASA). Money like this (and I mean billions) is squandered every year on unnecessary military weapons and numerous other frivolous things.
The truth of the matter is that there is enough capital in the U.S. economy to go into every ghetto in the nation and rebuild them into splendid towns (no exaggeration, folks) for our children to grow up in.
The point: if we really care about our children the way we say we do, then we should look at the terrible conditions under which these families are expected to stay together and do something about them!
Keeping Families Together: Is Neighborhood-Based Reform Enough?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.