Jobs for Teens: Why Wendy’s Said No

Why is it so hard for teenagers in New York City to find jobs?
I am a 15 year old living in New York and this summer, with my sister’s help, I tried to find a job in two stores. I wanted to make money to buy clothes and to save for my college education. But I didn’t have much luck.
My sister worked at Nine West and she asked her manager if he would hire a 15 year old. He said no because of child labor laws. The child labor laws say that employers aren’t allowed to hire young children and that teenagers under 16 can only work three hours a day on school days and eight hours the rest of the time.
Then my sister went to Wendy’s in the neighborhood where she works. They were hiring and my sister asked them if they would hire a 15 year old. Wendy’s just said no.
The Deck Is Stacked Against Us
I was angry and I wanted to know why jobs for teenagers were so scarce in New York City. I wanted to know if it was because adults think we are unreliable or lazy? Or were there other reasons?
To get some answers I went to James P. Brown, a labor market analyst for the New York State Department of Labor. He studies the economy of New York City, finds out what jobs are out there, and tracks the rate of unemployment.
He agreed that it is hard for teenagers to get jobs. To begin with, unemployment in New York City is about twice as high as it is in the country as a whole. (In June, the unemployment rate was 10 percent while for the entire nation it was around 5 percent.) When lots of people are out looking for jobs, employers prefer to have people with experience and often teens haven’t got much.
“If 10 percent of the adults can’t get work in New York City then obviously for teenagers it’s much more difficult,” Brown explained. “When adults can’t get a [full-time] job, they take the part-time jobs that normally are meant for teenagers.”
Too Many Rules
Mr. Brown also told me that many companies set policies requiring employees to be 16 or older.
Because of the child labor laws, employers have to follow more rules for a 15 year old employee, like limiting the number of hours the student works and not letting her operate heavy machinery.
These laws were passed to protect children from being exploited and make sure they stayed in school. But they also make it even harder for teens to find jobs. When employers have other people they can hire, it’s usually not worth their trouble to bother with the extra rules.
Mr. Brown lives in Westchester where, he says, “unemployment is much lower,” and many restaurants and supermarkets hire 15 year olds. In New York City, though, 25 percent of teenagers between the ages of 16 and 19 are either working or looking for work. But of those, 30 percent cannot find a job. And for teens under 16, it’s bound to be worse.
Change the Labor Laws
I understand all the reasons Mr. Brown offered for why it’s hard to get a job, but I still feel I’m capable of doing work just like a 16 year old. What is so big about a one year difference in age? I’m responsible and reliable, and those are the qualities that employers should look for.
I think child labor laws are good for young children because they should spend their time having fun and learning. But for a responsible high school student that law should be changed. High school teens who have above a ‘C’ average should be able to work as much as they want. It should be just like the extra-curricular activities rule: If you fail a class you have to drop the activity. Only with this you’d lose the job.
I also think that if a student doesn’t have any work experience, an employer should ask for a reference from a teacher or another responsible adult. I know that in many careers, you have to have experience to be able to do the job, but for a lot of the jobs teens apply for, this isn’t true.
The Right To Money
If more teens could find ways to make money legally, there would be less crime. And teens wouldn’t have to ask their parents to give them money. They’d learn the value of a dollar and the responsibility it takes to earn it instead.
High school teens should have the right to compete fairly with adults and to earn money to buy clothes and food-or even to gamble all of their money on Coney Island games if they want to.

SIDEBAR: Hats Off for Jobs
It’s tough enough in New York City for teens to find jobs, and sometimes, because of their lack of experience, they make mistakes when looking that make it even harder for them. Wearing hats and applying in groups, for example, are two things teens often do that make employers think they lack maturity and confidence. The New York State Department of Labor suggests that when teens look for jobs, they shouldn’t wear hats or T-shirts with words on them. They should dress like they want the job. They also recommend that if you’re looking for a job, you should come prepared. If you bring your Social Security card and your resume, then the employer will be impressed at how prepared you are. Try and think of all the small jobs you’ve had, like babysitting, or skills you’ve got through hobbies, to tell the employer about. And try to apply to smaller companies-they’re more likely to hire you. The Department of Labor can help. They have counselors in many high schools to help teens find jobs and prepare them for interviews. If you are looking for a summer job, you can apply for the Summer Youth Employment Program through your high school guidance counselor. The application deadline is usually in May.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.