Maybe the girl with the long brown hair sitting in front of you in chemistry is an Italian-American. Perhaps the owner of the local deli is of Italian extraction. Most Italian-Americans have last names that end with vowels, like Russo and Gambino.
But who are the Italian-Americans?
Some four million Italian immigrants entered this country between 1880 and 1915. Roughly 85% came from areas south or east of Rome. This area, called the Mezzogiorno, supplied America with mostly peasant farmers who could not withstand the heavy tax burdens and financial injustices of the Italian government.
However, during the 1920s, the United States began closing its doors to immigration. A popular saying of the time, according to Father Cogo of the American Committee on Italian Immigration, was “America for Americans.”
But weren’t the founders of this country also immigrants from England?
Immigration Quotas
In the 1920s, strict immigration laws encouraged immigration from Northern Europe, but severely reduced immigration from Southern Europe by setting strict quotas. The new laws seemed to be the result of anti-Italian attitudes, since Italy is in Southern Europe.
This anti-immigrant attitude was even echoed by our leaders.
Professor Richard Gambino, author of “Blood of My Blood,” a work describing the Italian-American experience in the U.S., quotes Theodore Roosevelt in a speech he gave at Carnegie Hall in 1915:
“There is no room in this country for hyphenated Americans. . . There is no such thing as a hyphenated American who is a good American.”
The hostile attitude was especially visible when, after seven years of prosecution, Italian-Americans Nicolo Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti were executed in 1927 for a murder that, to this day, no one is even sure they committed.
Italian immigrants were often paid less than their fellow workers for the same jobs.
Under the immigration laws of the 1920s and the McCarran Bill of 1952, Italian immigration was limited, but in 1965 a new immigration law was enacted. The new law was, in Father Cogo’s words, “fair and equitable because it was based on sound principles.”
The Mafia &’Cujines’
But how are Italian- Americans viewed today?
Frequently, they are the subject of many destructive stereotypes. Some very popular movies, such as “The Godfather” and “The Untouchables,” have portrayed Italians as Mafioso. Many people view all Italians as gangsters.
A couple of weekends ago, a person who had just learned that I live in Bensonhurst, a mostly Italian area, asked me, “Are there a lot of mobsters in your neighborhood?”
Although his question annoyed me, some other teens don’t feel as strongly as I do about the Mafia image.
Tina Albanese, 17, of Lafayette HS, says, “It’s always been like that. The Italians are associated with the Mafia, but if you can’t laugh at it, what can you do? You can’t cry.”
Michael Bongiovanni, 17, of Lafayette, says, “It bothers me that when you think of Italians in the movies, you always think of them as fat and greasy.”
John Falzone, of Dewey HS, just about summed it up when he said, “The Italians don’t take the stereotypes seriously, but others do.”
Another upsetting media image of Italians is the one in which they are seen stuffing their faces. We frequently see Dom De Luise enjoying his food from a Ziplock food storage bag on TV.
Vanessa Caputi was asked if she thought there was any truth in that stereotype. “I’ve been in Spanish, Italian, and Jewish homes,” she said, “and it’s all pretty much the same in that each parent tries to push food.” Michael Bongiovanni simply said, “Italians have a good taste for food.”
One result of these stereotypes is the view Italian-Americans have of themselves. I say this because my neighborhood has its share of Italian-Americans who belong to a category called cujines (pronounced “ku-jeans”).
Cujines are the guys wearing thick gold chains and driving around in “Dadillacs” (Dad’s Cadillac) with blaring disco music. Most people regard this behavior as a passing teenage phase, but other teens frequently make fun of cujines.
Inferiority Complex?
Could it be that these Italian-American kids, who, to an outsider, seem to have no goal except to own the biggest Cadillac on the block, are the products of their own poor image?
I’m not saying that, because Italians have been the object of hostility in the past, they are now and forever doomed. What I am suggesting, how- ever, is that Italian-Americans might have a subconscious inferiority complex, which makes them satisfied with low ambitions, whether monetary, social, or whatever.
Vanessa Caputi was asked why some Italian teenagers are cujines. She said, “The kids think it’s attractive to copy the gangster image. It’s the whole idea, like the head man with all his boys hanging around-money, guns, women. It’s an adventurous situation and it’s appealing to young people.”
Italians and Education
I have noticed differing attitudes toward education among my Italian-American peers, but in the end it all comes down to one thing: your family’s values.
“It’s how you were brought up,” says Tina Albanese. “It’s not just Italians who are not going to college. There is no doubt in my mind that I will be going.”
“More Italian guys than girls attend college, I think,” comments Vanessa Caputi. “I do, however, have Italian girl-friends who are very bright and are attending college. There are some who can go to schools that meet their expectations, whereas others are willing to go anywhere they are accepted.”
It seems that the girls have a more positive attitude toward education, because Michael Tomasino, of Lafayette HS, says, “When you think of Italians, you think of tile laying, construction.”
“It’s all in your attitude,” according to Michael Bongiovanni. “If my parents were nerds, I’d be smart. My father works, we have money, so I don’t think about college. Some kids go to college and don’t make money.”
But despite the friction they have encountered in the past, Italian-Americans are mostly Americanized and enjoying everything that other teens do, because we are simply teenagers.
As Jerry Chiapetta of the American Italian Coalition of Organizations says, “When we have been looked at objectively and not referred to as stereotypes, we have been able to succeed in all endeavors. Just look as far back as Da Vinci and as close as Supreme Court Justice Scalia.”
Italian-Americans Face Many Stereotypes
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.