The Organizing Page: Is the Youth Voice Being Heard?
To the Editor:
As Director of C-Plan (Child Planning and Advocacy Now), the child welfare advocacy project in the office of New York City Public Advocate Mark Green, I have become an avid and enthusiastic reader of Foster Care Youth United magazine. Over the past several years I have regularly found the magazine to be a “must read” for anyone involved with the New York City child welfare system. As such, I distribute every issue of the magazine to the entire C-Plan staff and often copy and distribute specific articles or notices for use in C-Plan advocate training sessions. FCYU is an invaluable mode of communication and a superb educational tool.
It is precisely because of the high esteem in which I hold FCYU that I feel compelled to comment on what I consider to be a serious factual error contained in Giselle John’s recent article, “Youth Must Have a Voice” (May/June). In the article, Ms. John refers to the recent April 25, 1997 C-Plan conference called “Child Welfare: Starting from Scratch” and notes the “the organizers seemed to forget to invite a very important and distinguished panelist. Who? A child in foster care.”
At first I was confused by the article because in fact Ms. John was one of nine panel participants in the morning session-the Child Welfare Round Table. As I read on, I realized that Ms. John was under the impression that C-Plan had decided to invite a child in foster care to participate on the Round Table only at the last minute, perhaps as an after-thought. She writes:
“Even though our invitation to be on the panel was apparently ‘lost in the mail,’ the end result (after airing our opinions about being left off the panel) was that a space was finally made available for a youth to sit on the panel with all the other ‘distinguished’ panelists.”
As all the members of the C-Plan Conference Planning Committee can attest, C-Plan set aside a place on the Child Welfare Round Table for a child in the foster care system at the group’s first meeting. And as the youth advocacy organizations which I contacted seeking panelist recommendations can confirm, it was left up to these organizations to identify and select the young person who could most effectively represent the youth voice on the panel. The panelist subsequently recommended by Youth Advocacy Center (YAC) was accepted by the Conference Planning Group without question.
When the recommended youth panelist called me the following week and suggested that Giselle John participate on the panel instead of him, I agreed to honor his request. I spoke to Ms. John over the telephone that same day and then sent her a follow-up letter outlining the structure of the Round Table. It is true that the arrangement to have Ms. John participate on the Round Table was made only a week or two before the conference, but the commitment to have a youth in foster care participate was made months earlier.
At C-Plan we are keenly aware of the struggle experienced by youth who are trying to get their voices heard in the New York City child welfare system. It is for this reason that the Conference Planning Group reserved a place for the youth voice right from the start. Ms. John is correct, there are many child welfare organizations, agencies, foundations, and advocacy group which often do forget to include the critically important voice of youth in foster care. For what it’s worth, for this event, C-Plan was not one of them.
Sincerely, Jane F. Golden
Giselle John responds:
I would first like to thank Jane Golden and C-Plan for allowing me to be one of your panel participants at the April 25 conference, “Child Welfare Starting From Scratch.” Also, I commend you for your positive thoughts about FCYU and the way in which you use the magazine. The high esteem in which you hold FCYU is much appreciated.
I must say though, that I still stand strongly by what I wrote in my May/June article, “Youth Must Have A Voice.” Even though you stated in your letter that you hold FCYU in high esteem, that was not so obvious when you were seeking recommendations for a youth panelist. FCYU was not one of the “youth advocacy organizations” contacted. Maybe you did not consider us a youth advocacy organization?
Why weren’t we invited from the start to have a foster youth participate in your conference? Why did our involvement come about only second-hand, when the youth recommended by the Youth Advocacy Center phoned you and suggested you have me speak instead of him?
Since our magazine is the only magazine in which teens write for teens in foster care, I think we are well qualified for an invitation to participate. After all, you did send us information about the event, but not an invitation to participate on the panel itself. So, I still say our invitation was “lost in the mail.”
Furthermore, in the letter you say I made a “serious factual mistake” when I stated “the organizers seemed to forget to invite a very important and distinguished guest. Who? A child in foster care.” I based my statement on your list of “distinguished panelists” that was received at FCYU.
The list showed no indication that a foster youth would be present on the panel. So, can you blame me for thinking that we (youth) weren’t included?
Now, I know that you did have intentions to have a youth representative on the panel, and I’m thrilled to see that you have an interest in the voices of the youth.
All I’m saying is that if your organization knew that there was going to be a youth representative on the panel, it should have been made clear from the list of panelists you distributed. When I read the list of panelists and did not see a youth representative, it led me to write my comments.
Ms. Golden, you have some strong and valid points about my article, but again let me point out that my reaction was based on the information received at FCYU. In other words, some things just weren’t made clear enough. I do respect your points, though, and I also respect you and your organization.
Sincerely, Giselle John
Gettin’ Involved
Helping Parents
Do you have a parent, grandparent, relative, or other family member who has children in foster care and needs help in dealing with problems in the system? If so, the Child Welfare Organizing Project (CWOP) can help.
CWOP helps biological parents and relatives learn about their rights and work on solving their problems. They hold monthly meetings, and anyone with a child in the system is invited to attend. Call CWOP at 212-694-1866.
Learn to Advocate for Yourself
The Youth Advocacy Center is offering an Advocacy Seminar for foster care youth that can help you:
-Learn to solve problems you have in the system.
-Find out how to protect your rights.
-Give yourself a better chance at finding a job.
The YAC seminar, beginning in September, will train teens 16-19 in foster care to learn advocacy-a way to protect your rights while you’re in the system. The seminar will meet after school one afternoon a week for 12 weeks. Teens will work with advocacy experts to learn about the system, their rights, how to write a letter to get what you need, and how to make a good oral presentation. You will solve a real life problem you are having.
Teens will receive a stipend, a graduation certificate, and a letter of recommendation upon completion, and will be eligible for paid work internships. To learn more about applying for the seminar, call Youth Advocacy Center at 212-675-6181 and ask for Danielle or Mohamed.
Stand Up for Your Legal Rights
Many youth in the system don’t know that they have the right to attend their “service plan” meeting (or UCR), which tells them how the system is supposed to help with school, housing, counseling, getting a Green Card, independent living, and other services.
The Legal Services Center, part of The Door, a youth center in Manhattan, wants to help foster youth learn about their “service plan” meetings. The Center also has a free booklet to help biological parents and children in care learn about their rights.
The Door is also starting a group for foster care youth this summer, which will work on advocating about problems in foster care. The participants will work with an organizer, and meet regularly with The Door’s lawyers to work on their individual problems as well as for system-wide change.
The Door also provides many other services for youth, ranging from medical, educational and counseling to recreation and food, all without charge.
For more information, call Kim Hawkins at 212-941-9090, ext. 250.
For Gay, Lesbian and Bi-Sexual Foster Youth
Are you a gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgendered, or questioning youth (GLBTQ) living in the system?
If so, join the Triangle Tribe, a support group that offers youth a chance to talk about their feelings of growing up in foster care. The Triangle Tribe also consults with agencies that seek to provide a more affirming environment for GLBTQ youth.
For more information, call Dr. Gary Mallon or Kevin Te Carr at 212-677-7288.
A Hotline that Can Help
C-Plan has a hotline you can call for help with problems in the system: 212-669-4955. C-Plan also offers weekly meetings where you can discuss your problems and learn advocacy and organizing skills. Call Jane Golden at 212-669-4106.
Is the Youth Voice Being Heard?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.