I took SAT prep courses because I’ll need a high score on the test to get into a top college. But these courses cost a lot of money.
Kaplan and Princeton Review cost about $1,000 for 12 classes. A tutor’s hourly rate can range from $20 to more than $200 per hour. The test itself costs $28.50, and while it’s free to send your score to four colleges, each additional college is $6.50. [Note: All prices in this article are from 2004.]
Most financially disadvantaged students won’t learn the tricks I’ve been learning to get a better score on the SAT. That’s not fair. And in fact, the wealthier a student’s family is, the better he or she tends to do on the test.
It’s not just that richer kids can pay for test preps. They may go to expensive private schools with intense college-prep classes, or live in wealthy suburbs where their college-educated parents expect their kids to go to top schools, too.
A Guessing Game
Critics of the SAT say that the test isn’t fair in other ways as well. For example, males do better than females on the test, even though females get better grades in the same classes. In 2003, females received an average combined score of 1006 and males got 1049.
Researchers think that males may outscore females in both math and verbal because males are more likely to guess. I know I over-think a lot and tend not to guess if I’m not sure of the answer.
But the way the SAT works, it can be better to guess if you think the answer might be right. If you leave an answer blank, you get no points, and if you put down a wrong answer, you get ¼ of a point off. But if you guess right, you’ll gain a point.
So if you guess four times and each time you’re wrong, you’ll lose one point, but if you’re right with each guess, you’ll get four points. If you leave too many blanks because you’re not sure, then you won’t have enough points to get a high score. That’s how the test favors people who tend to guess.
Also, whites do better on the SAT than people of other races, particularly blacks and Latinos. Much of the difference in scores has to do with educational opportunities-white students taking the SAT tend to go to better schools. But that is not always the case, and researchers are still studying why whites do best.
Rebecca Slotnick, coordinator for Options SAT prep course, helps students prepare for the SAT, but she doesn’t believe that the test is an accurate measure of a student’s overall ability because it tests specific skills.
“The test maker argues that the SAT is used to predict how a student will perform in the first year of college. But I don’t think it’s the only indicator,” she said. “A student can get an 1100 but is an A student, while another student gets a 1400 but is a C student. Obviously, the A student would do better in college.”
A Shared Standard
The maker of the SAT, the College Board, responds to such criticism by arguing that the test is used to show a student’s perseverance and ability to think under pressure. If you get tired taking this long test, then you’ll lose focus and won’t do as well.
The test also works as a standard-the same measure for everyone applying to a college. High schools have different curriculums and different grading policies, so colleges can’t always rely on high school transcripts to compare students from different schools. And college admissions offices can’t necessarily count on essays, either, since they could be edited by parents, friends or teachers.
Still, the College Board has changed the SAT in order to better show a student’s learning and reasoning and to deal more with the material taught in high school. The new SAT, which will go into effect in March 2005, won’t have the analogies in the verbal section, but there’ll be an essay and more reading passages. Also, there’ll be higher-level math problems.
The new test will be 3 ½ hours-half an hour longer than the current test. I’m glad that I won’t have to take the new SAT, and I’m sure people younger than me will think that it’s unfair that they get a harder test.
Is the SAT Fair?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.