Is the President the Nation’s Bully?

Is the President the Nation’s Bully?

According to the US Constitution, declaring war is up to the Congress. The President isn’t allowed to do it. But President Bush as well as others in the past have repeatedly ignored this law and started undeclared wars on their own initiative.
During the recent crisis in the Persian Gulf, President Bush bullied our representatives in Congress and made all the decisions by himself.
Every neighborhood has a bully. On my block, we were all scared of her because if we did or said something she didn’t like she would hit or make fun of us. So we kept our mouths shut. That’s how a bully is created: when you allow one person to have power over you and don’t speak up.
Congress Went Along With It
Congress didn’t speak up during the six months that led up to the war. They went along with whatever Bush wanted to do. By the time he consulted them, there were half a million troops in the Middle East and the decision had already been made.
Any time you leave that kind of power up to one person you run the risk of creating a dictator. Look at Iraq. The people there let Saddam Hussein take them into a devastating war without asking their consent. In America there is a Congress whose job it is to prevent these kinds of mistakes.
Vietnam-a Big Mistake
In Vietnam the Congress failed to do that job and the president made a big mistake, one that cost over 50,000 American lives. After years of watching the body bags come home, the protests, and disproval of the American people, President Nixon finally got the message and pulled the troops out. Maybe if our representatives had been forced to sit down together and decide in the first place there never would had been a Vietnam War. Or if there were, the objectives would have been clearer to everyone.
People argue that there isn’t enough time to let Congress make those kinds of decisions. But it took six months before this crisis in the gulf finally erupted. Not until the very last minute did Bush go to Congress for their opinion. Nor did Congress go to him.
The last time Congress declared war was when the Japanese attacked us at Pearl Harbor. It took them less than 24 hours. Everyone felt strongly about that one. Maybe when the country is divided and the issues confused, when the debate drags on and on, that should tell us something. War is not something to be gotten into lightly.
The U.S. Constitution guarantees all of us rights which allow us to live in freedom and make choices that affect our lives. If we continue to ignore the Constitution and allow individual leaders to make our decisions for us, we might as well tape our mouths shut and forget about ever speaking up about anything.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.