Are kids in the foster care system getting enough recreation? Many young people I interviewed believe they are getting enough, but others think they are left hanging when it comes time for recreation.
Okay, hold on, let me define recreation for you.
Recreation is not sitting at home watching TV or playing video games. Recreation means actually getting up and going out-not just standing outside waiting for something to happen, but going to the movies or to an amusement park or playing sports. Now I hope you get the idea.
The Quest
To find out what people who work or live in foster care think about recreation, I interviewed Melinda Medina and Elise Gelbman, who work at Talbot Perkins Children’s Services in Manhattan. This is what Melinda had to say: “I think children from different agencies have a lot of problems to deal with, and there aren’t many programs out there which allow them the opportunity to do something constructive.”
To deal with this, Melinda helped organize and coach a Talbot Perkins basketball team so that her players would have a feeling of belonging to something, and self-worth.
Mrs. Gelbman believes that the kids in her agency are very fortunate because, unlike other agencies, they go places and have fun. “We try to support our kids with recreation opportunities whenever we can, so they should be happy to be in our agency and I think most of our kids are,” she said.
Speak Out
I talked to kids in the system to find out what they do for recreation. Joseph Cunningham, 16, agreed with Melinda that not enough recreation is offered. “Kids in care need do things to do. It would not be fair if they just stayed home moping about their problems. A lot of kids have problems, so I think more recreation will help keep their minds off their problems.” In Joseph’s group home they do recreation activities twice a month, but in other homes that might not be the case.
Phillip Johnson,15, a resident of Catholic Home Bureau, had this to say: “Recreation helps takes foster care residents’ minds off foster care. It could help them from being violent. They will not have to worry about their problems if they are having fun. It would be a time to relax.”
J.R., the captain of Talbot Perkins Basketball team, thought recreation in his agency could be improved. “We don’t get to do what we want to do for fun. I think it’s cool to go places every Wednesday, but it would be better if we got to choose where we want to go. I don’t want to go on trips in New York because I already know what’s happening. I want to go out of state and see different things.”
Joe, 16 (not his real name), a resident of a foster home, had a different feeling about recreation. “Do you really think recreation helps kids with their problems?” he asked. “What does recreation do to help them be in care? Absolutely nothing. I know this because a little sports and games can’t take their minds off the problems they face.”
Joe probably feels this way because he said he doesn’t do anything in his foster home. It might be true that it doesn’t help some kids deal with problems, but for others it may help. I’m not saying recreation’s a miracle worker, though. How about just having fun?
Group Home Tournament
Certain steps have been taken to give kids a chance for recreation. Last summer several foster care agencies organized a basketball tournament. The idea of a basketball league started when a Brooklyn agency contacted Elise Gelbman. She explained to me, “I received a letter from an agency in Brooklyn and they invited me and 63 other agency representatives to a meeting about a city-wide basketball tournament.”
The only problem was not enough agencies participated, Mrs. Gelbman said. “It’s a shame that five agencies participated out of 63.”
The tournament was held in May, June, July. The teams played at the Options Center in the Bronx, and Talbot Perkins won the championship with Catholic Guardian Society the runner-up.
Staying Out of Trouble
“It was an excellent tournament and a great source of recreation, because their attitudes about their future and their values as human beings were very positive,” said Melinda of Talbot Perkins. Melinda was also very happy about winning the championship because it was a great way to end the season. They worked hard as a team and gave all they were worth.
I asked players from the tournament about their views on this recreational activity. J.R. said this, “The tournament was fun because I never won a championship before and it was a good experience. I would like to play next year because I made a lot of friends and it was something to do on my Mondays. The tournament could improve if there is more teams and players.”
Leon Starks said there should be more tournaments because kids in foster care do not get enough recognition. “I think having tournaments will unite agencies into doing more recreational activities.” Leon said it was a good tournament, but he agreed it would be better with more players.
Phillip Johnson said, “I think the tournament was good help because many kids would be wasting their Mondays doing bad things. Thanks to the tournament, kids got things to do. Personally, I think without recreation or this tournament I would probably be doing all the wrong things and getting myself into destructive gangs.”
Deshawn, a resident of a group home in the Bronx, had other thoughts about the tournament and recreation. “The tournament was whack and I don’t see how that is recreation if we are just playing basketball.” I guess Deshawn said that because he stayed on the bench!
A City-Wide League?
Everyone I interviewed believed there should be a city-wide recreational activity league for kids in care. This would be possible if all the agencies came up with money and ideas about what sports or activities would be played. Not every kid gets recreation. If they want and need it, it should be given to them. If an agency does not give these opportunities, then by all means they should do something about it. And recreation should not be based on behavior-it should always be there when it is needed.
Elise Gelbman doesn’t think ACS should start a league but should support it. “It’s up to the [private] agencies to start a citywide tournament.”
Perhaps all agencies who are interested should start their own private recreational tournament, like my agency, Catholic Guardian Society, did. We played a basketball tournament every Tuesday and Friday last summer.
Hopefully, the tournament I played in will eventually turn out to be a permanent city-wide basketball tournament for foster youth. I’m sure if more agencies got involved in providing recreational programs, like karate, basketball, etc., we would see a drastic improvement in their children’s feelings of self-worth.
Congratulations!
Melinda Medina wanted to congratulate her team for winning last summer’s championship.
“I would like to congratulate the Talbot Perkins Dragons for winning the Option Centers championship. I thank you for your hard work and dedication. I also thank you for giving me the chance to coach you. You showed me a great deal of respect and love. You will all succeed in life if you continue to work hard towards accomplishing your goals. Remember-if you believe in your abilities and work hard, you can achieve your dreams. So keep your heads up and aim for the stars, because you can do it.”
Is Recreation Neglected?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.