The Nebraska Supreme Court ruled in October that a 16-year-old foster youth could not get the abortion she wanted because she was “not sufficiently mature.” Nebraska, like some other states, requires parental consent for abortions for girls under 18, so the girl asked a judge back in May for a document to let her make the decision on her own. The girl told the judge that she could not “be the right mom she would like to be” at this point in her life and that she was not financially ready to take care of a child.
The girl was 10 weeks pregnant when she first asked a judge for a document that would let her get an abortion without parental consent. Her case was tricky because her birth parents’ rights had just been terminated (her father broke her collarbone in 2011). She had been placed with new foster parents in February, and they were very
religious and opposed to abortion.
The state Supreme Court decision said that the girl “testified that she mostly raised her younger siblings because her parents’were never around.’ Petitioner will be a senior in high school and plans to graduate early-in Decemberâ. she plans to attend college.” However, the justices ruled 5-2 that the girl was too immature to make the decision not to have a child in part because she lacked work experience. (This is precisely why the girl wanted the abortion-she could not support a child while finishing high school!)
The statistics on teen moms suggest that this girl made, in fact, a very mature decision to not become a mother at age 16. A large 2007 study of teens in the Midwest found that, by age 19, about three in 10 teens aging out of foster care had children living with them. Of those young parents who had not enrolled in college, nearly one in six said the need to care for children was the top reason.
This “Immature” girl was also being realistic about her child’s chances for a good life-kids born to teen moms are at greater risk for ending up in foster care. For example, one 2012 study found that being born to a teen parent was one of four major risk factors for a child ending up in the child welfare system. A 2011 study found that roughly 60% of children placed in foster care were born to mothers who had their first child as a teen.
The girl was 10 weeks pregnant in May, and the Supreme Court decision was published in October. The young woman may have been able to get an abortion in time (her lawyer would not say). But regardless, her case should be an example for other states to learn from. Forcing a teen to have a child she knows she can’t take care of is terrible policy for all involved.
In the News: Nebraska Denies Abortion to Teen in Care
By Anonomous
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.