Names have been changed.
At some point everyone has one friend who they feel is like a sister or brother to them. I am fortunate enough to have had that friend since 1st grade. We met in school when we were 5 years old. I specifically selected her on the first day because her blonde hair made her stand out from everyone else, and I wanted the “special” one.
In 4th grade, even when she moved to a new house an hour away, we stayed in touch. As we got older, she was the only one I talked to about my problems, and she did the same with me. People said we looked alike with our giant hazel eyes, pale skin, and similar body types. Alison always knew the right thing to say to make me laugh and had the best advice in any situation. She was also very intelligent. When I got frustrated easily and was impatient, she was calm and collected.
We would text all the time, and I’d take a bus 50 minutes to visit her on weekends. In summers I’d sleep over at her house, which had a tennis court and swimming pool.
Then one spring she got a boyfriend, Brian, and everything changed.
Lost in Love
Initially I was happy she was in a relationship. She never had a boyfriend before because she always said relationships were too much work. I encouraged her to go for it if she really cared about the guy. Now I wish I could go back in time and warn her against him
.
A month into the relationship, Brian cheated on her with his “best friend,” Jen. Alison was hurt, especially because Brian’s friends defended him and acted like she deserved it. But eventually they made up. Little did I know this would become a pattern: Brian doing something terrible, Alison venting to me about it, then forgiving him.
Afraid to Push Too Hard
Over the next year and a half, Alison stopped hanging out with all her friends, including me. Brian’s friends became her friends. On Friday nights she would sit at his house, sometimes for up to three hours, waiting for him to come home from work.
It worried me that Alison was ignoring her friends so she could be with a guy who treated her badly. But I never confronted her about it aside from mentioning that we needed to see each other because it’d been so long. She would just agree with me and drop the subject, forgetting about it later. I knew I wasn’t as important to her as Brian. Alison didn’t seem to see how hurt I felt that she was blowing me off.
Still, I didn’t want to push Alison away. She’d been my friend since I was four feet tall and I didn’t want to give that up, even if the effort to stay friends mostly came from me. I was the only one she could vent to whenever Brian screwed up. I felt like she needed me.
It Gets Violent
Brian cheated on Alison constantly and lied to her about it. When she confronted him, Brian would get in her face all belligerent, yelling about how she didn’t trust him. After one of these arguments, in which Alison begged Brian to tell her why she wasn’t good enough for him and why he didn’t love her, Alison texted me, shaken. I’d gotten used to her texting me, but this time it was more serious. Brian had shoved her onto the floor.
I was outraged. “What the hell kind of man puts his hands on a woman?” I said. Alison made excuses for him saying, “I did get up in his face” and “I was yelling…”
“What if you had been near some stairs? What if you’d hit your head on the edge of a table and blacked out?” I demanded angrily. I hated seeing her so weak.
I missed the old Alison, who was funny and intelligent and would talk to me for hours. This Alison didn’t have time for me anymore. This Alison was an anxious, sad person.
Advice Ignored
One time she started to sound like she might have had enough. She texted me: “How could he do this to the love of his life? How can he not feel guilty? How is that love?” I encouraged her, so happy that she was finally seeing the truth. Yet my worst fears came true. Once Brian came home and they “talked about it,” everything was magically resolved.
I was so angry when she called. She said, “I don’t really want to talk about it but we worked it out! Anyway, what’s up with you?” But I was having none of it.
“Really? You magically’worked it out?’ It’s going to happen again, Alison. He’s not a good person.”
She replied adamantly, “He is a good person. And I love him. And he loves me.”
Her blindness made me even madder. “Really? Then why is he still talking to Jen? Did he have an answer for that?” She didn’t answer that text message, so I sent her another one explaining why she was wrong about him. A few days later, when she still hadn’t texted me back and I missed her, I sent her a new text talking about something else and our friendship resumed.
It’s been two years now, and I wish I could say they’vebroken up, but they haven’t. Alison’s still stuck in this unhealthy relationship, and Brian is still manipulating the hell out of her.
The worst part about it is that I can only remain in her life if I ignore it. If I keep trying to convince her that Brian is an awful person, she might refuse to talk to me. I wouldn’t be able to handle that because I love her like a sister. So I’m stuck serving as a shoulder for her to cry on.
I feel like I’ve lost my friend. I miss our sleepovers and summers spent together and long talks at night, half-serious and half-funny. It’s frustrating knowing that I’ll never be able to get that back. For now, all I can do is text her, and half-heartedly listen to the next bad development in her relationship with Brian.
I Lost My Friend to a Bad Relationship
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.