I am a 20-year-old male who practically grew up in foster care. I went into the system at the age of seven and I’m still in it. I am angered by the senseless death of six-year old Elisa Izquierdo, allegedly tortured to death by her mother on the Lower East Side of Manhattan last Thanksgiving.
City and State authorities, including the Child Abuse Hotline and CWA, were notified many times that Elisa was being abused, but she was never taken from her home. My siblings and I lived in an abusive foster home, suffering many of the same things as Elisa did, yet no one heard our cries for help.
My four siblings and I were taken away from our natural mother and placed together in several foster homes. We were innocent children, but we thought it was our fault we were taken away.
The foster mother who eventually adopted us was an emotionally unstable woman who disliked children, but was still given a license to provide and care for them.
No Mercy
She often told us that she took us in for the money. She always said she could care less about us, as long as her bills were paid.
She beat us with any object she could get her hands on, and she never had mercy for our faces. She beat us with a thick cowhide belt which she slit into seven strips. She called the belt “Mr. Brown.” My siblings and I had welts on our bare skin for days due to the beatings. We were also beaten with pots and pans, a wooden brush, hangers, broomsticks, and her fists.
Every time we yelled at the top of our voices for help, she turned up the radio so no one could hear our cries. Elisa’s mother also turned up the radio.
A stray dog should not have been placed in the care of my adoptive mother. We were treated as if we didn’t have any feelings or importance. She watched as we bathed, even telling us what parts of our bodies to wash. We weren’t allowed to tell her how ashamed and embarrassed we felt. We were stripped of our pride and dignity.
There were many nights we went to bed hungry. She felt we didn’t deserve to eat because we were “bad.” We didn’t have a normal childhood. We couldn’t play or do any of the things other children do.
When you’re told every day of your life that you’re never going to amount to anything, it puts a painful strain on the mind and heart. I believed the harsh words she said because she was an adult.
Case Dismissed
No matter how much we begged and pleaded to CWA, police officers, and the Child Abuse Registry Hotline, no one reached out to help us. For example, when I was 11 or 12 years old I called the Hotline and a man assured me they would look into my case.
I felt relieved, knowing I was not alone. A social worker arrived the next day. My adoptive mother denied the abuse.
The social worker then asked us-in the presence of our adoptive mother-if we were being abused. Since we were terrified of our adoptive mother, of course we said no.
The case was immediately dismissed. We felt helpless and trapped because we had nobody to turn to.
Every time we ran away from home, a police officer took us back and said, “You kids have it made living here. This is a clean home with plenty of food in the refrigerator, and a loving mother to provide for your needs. You kids are crazy not wanting to stay here.” As soon as the officer left, the beatings continued where they had left off.
Putting On An Act
The police officer never asked us once how we felt or what we were going through in that hell hole. Our scars from her beatings didn’t make a difference to him. He acted as if we deserved the beatings. His only concern was to bring us back home. He took the word of our abuser since she was an adult with a kind appearance and a clean house with plenty of food in the refrigerator.
My adoptive mother was a totally different person in the presence of the police. She would put on an act that looked so natural. She would give the police coffee and donuts and then she would show them her immaculate house-that my siblings and I had cleaned.
The naked eye can be very deceiving. You can see things you only want to see. While riding in the back seat of the police car, I often heard the officers mumble, “Damn, we gotta go through all this paperwork from these kids’ nonsense.” I strongly believe the officer felt his job would be easier if he ignored our pleas for help.
Denying the Abuse
No one saw the physical and emotional pain Elisa Izquierdo carried every day of her life. Those who did see it chose not to get involved, and when others tried, the proper authorities didn’t take action.
People must realize children are terrified of telling someone that they’re being abused. I went to school many days with cuts and bruises on my face. My teachers often asked what happened, and I would always say I fell or tripped over my shoelaces. I was afraid no one would believe I was being abused.
I eventually left the abuse by refusing to go back home, and when I was 14 I was finally signed into a new placement by CWA. My siblings stayed years longer with my adoptive mother and only recently left her home.
If you suspect a child is being abused, report it without any hesitation. I know most people do not want to get involved. For example, some of our neighbors heard the beatings we received, but didn’t want to report it. Years later, they told me they felt it was none of their business. But someone has to take a stand to save the lives of innocent children.
Remember, it is not the children’s fault that they’re being abused.
Parents, talk to your child instead of beating him or her. Trust me-it really works. I know it’s hard to have patience, but what do you have to lose by not beating your child? Also remember-your child is a part of you.
Based on my experiences, I feel there’s a great need for the system to make drastic changes in order to save the lives of innocent and abused children.
Need for Changes
o Child care workers should talk to children outside of the home when there is a suspicion of abuse. A child is more comfortable revealing abuse outside the home and away from adults. My siblings and I couldn’t reveal the abuse in front of our adoptive mother.
o Interview the children separately. Children will be more honest if interviewed separately. They won’t feel the pressure from a sibling to hide the abuse. This will also prevent one sibling from snitching to the abuser about what another child said.
o Social workers, when they make visits, must help the children feel safe. A child is more likely to be frightened by someone they don’t know. In my case, the social worker didn’t make us feel comfortable when she asked us questions.
o Social workers and child care workers should make surprise visits to check on allegations of abuse. Letting the person know you’re coming by isn’t an effective way to investigate the home.
o Screen foster parents more thoroughly. My adoptive mother should never have been approved as a foster parent.
o Increase the budget for foster care. A lack of well-trained and well-paid social workers and caseworkers in the system will only lead to more children being abused.
Elisa didn’t have a chance to fulfill her hopes and dreams. Maybe she would have become a teacher, a mother, or a nurse. Now she can’t be any of those things.
This story was very painful to write because it brought back so many horrible memories, but I have to keep in mind how lucky and thankful I am to be alive and well. I see myself as a survivor, not a victim. I wish Elisa Izquierdo could feel the same way.
I Could Have Been Elisa
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.