How Safe Are We at School?

Treated Like Criminals: Do cops belong in high schools?

My school dean and a stern male security guard escorted my friend Lenny (not his real name) and me to an empty classroom near the dean’s office. They ordered us to put our bags against the wall and stand in the middle of the room, apart from each other. We tried to explain ourselves, but the guard hissed at us and told us not to be “wiseguys.”
The dean checked our bags, opening every single pocket and unzipping each zipper, looking through my notebooks and folders and even checking my wallet and cell phone. The guard frisked us and asked us to turn out our pockets so that he could make sure there was nothing inside.
After that, the dean said that we were lucky we didn’t have anything we weren’t supposed to and that they’d let us go. But they said they’d still call our parents and tell them what we had done.
What we had done was get my bookbag out of Lenny’s car, a block from the school, after gym class. We returned to school on time, but behind everyone else from the class. I didn’t know this was against the rules. More importantly, I didn’t know that it meant I would be treated like a criminal when I re-entered the building.
Cops in Schools
That was the first time I was frisked and I’ve got to tell you it wasn’t a good feeling. It felt like I was under arrest and they were about to read me my rights.
After what happened to me, I wasn’t surprised to learn that some people are questioning the safety measures being used in what are known as Impact high schools around the city.
The Impact schools safety initiative was created in 2004 by Mayor Michael Bloomberg, the Department of Education (DOE) and the New York City Police Department, to make schools safer.
They picked 12 schools that had high levels of violence, disorderly behavior or crime. The program brought surveillance cameras, metal detectors and large numbers of uniformed and armed police officers to those schools. They started a zero tolerance policy where even minor incidents like disorderly behavior could be punished severely. The idea was that small crimes can lead to big crimes if they’re not addressed quickly.
Schools that improved would be taken off the list and have the security measures reduced. So far, 24 schools have been put on the list and 15 have been removed.
According to the DOE, the program is working. In a press release from last April, the department said that overall crime has gone down 33% and major crime has gone down 59% at Impact schools.
But not everyone is happy with the program. New York University’s Wagner School of Public Service recently released a study about the effectiveness of the Impact schools initiative.
During the 2005-2006 school year, a team of NYU graduate students tried to answer the question: Are the Impact school policies an appropriate approach to creating safe school environments?
After a lot of research and interviewing leaders in the education system and the community, the team made this conclusion: the Impact approach may be effective, but it’s not appropriate.
They found that police officers, though effective in the short-term, would only hurt schools in the long-run. They suggested that the presence of cops dares some students to commit crime and makes the rest of students feel threatened.
Prevention, Not Punishment
The report also pointed out that Impact schools tend to be underfunded and overcrowded, and that might be part of the reason there’s so much crime in these schools. It recommended that city officials focus on reducing over-crowding and increasing funding instead of law enforcement and severe punishment.
The report recommended that the city government and the DOE should focus on treatment rather than punishment by hiring psychologists and guidance counselors for schools instead of police officers.
All in all, the report had a negative view of the Impact school initiative. But I figured that students who attend these schools would know better than any report what’s good for them and their schools. So I decided to interview a couple of students who attend Impact schools.
‘I Feel Safe’
Jescine Jarvis, 15, is an NYC writer and a sophomore at Harry S. Truman HS, an Impact school in the Bronx. Her school has metal detectors, security cameras on every floor, and a police presence.
“I’ve thought about how I would feel without the police there, and I would be scared,” said Jescine. “I feel safe whenever I see them as I walk down the hallway or outside the school.”
She said the cops have arrested a few students, but she’s not afraid of the police. She said students often joke around with the cops as though they’re friends.
“It helps me to see uniformed officers in schools. It’s like seeing a uniformed police officer at the carnival or at a parade.” said Jescine. “[It] makes me feel as if nothing can go wrong, and that if something does go wrong, then they’ll fix it.”
‘We Felt Like Criminals’
But a student at an Impact school in Queens, who asked to remain anonymous, had a different opinion. Six cops were stationed on each floor of her school for a year and a half. They were supposed to spread out, but she said that they just stood together and stared at students who walked by.
“You don’t want to look at them because you don’t want them to say anything to you,” she said. “We felt like criminals. It made me uncomfortable.”
She admitted that there were a lot of fights before the school was named an Impact school, and that after the cops came, “basically all the fights stopped and there was a lot less theft.”
She thinks the cops’ presence did help, but not because of anything they did-she never saw them do anything in the school. She thinks the school became safer simply because being labeled an Impact school made everyone pull together to improve the school and get rid of that label.
Like the NYU report, she believes that prevention would probably have been a better solution to the school’s safety problems.
I have to agree. If what happened to me at my non-Impact school made me feel like a criminal, I can only imagine how most students who attend Impact schools feel, where that kind of treatment is the norm.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.