A few weeks ago, I was reading the book Black Thighs, Black Guys and Bedroom Lies by Hasani Pettiford, a motivational speaker. My mother told me to read it because she wanted me to get better educated about sex and doing right by God.
Pettiford’s a Christian who believes that life would be much easier if people just waited until they’re married to have sex, and that having sex any time before marriage is sinful.
The topic that stood out the most to me in his book was “Condoms (How Safe Are They?)” This surprised me because I’d never seen a writer question how reliable condoms are. Pettiford wrote about condoms, “The average failure rate for preventing the transmission of HIV was 31 percent.” He then referred to three doctors who said that people shouldn’t rely on condoms as a form of protection against sexually transmitted infections.
Started Research
I doubted that this man knew what he was talking about, because he wasn’t a health professional. He’s an author who deeply believes in Christianity. I thought this book might be trying to strongly discourage readers from having sex outside of marriage by trying to exaggerate the risks associated with using a condom.
I wanted to find out if what he claimed was true, so I began to do research. Most of what I found showed that Pettiford’s “facts” weren’t true.
I visited the web site of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), a top government agency committed to providing reliable health information to the public.
CDC Recommends Condom Use
The CDC published a 1993 report on how well condoms protect against HIV infection and other sexually transmitted diseases. The report shows that a properly used latex condom provides a high degree of protection against different sexually transmitted infections, including HIV.
The CDC said other studies show that 98-100% of people who use condoms correctly and consistently did not become infected if they were sexually involved with people who had HIV. The organization made clear that when engaging in sexual intercourse, you can greatly reduce your risk of getting (or giving) sexually transmitted infections by using a condom.
Then, I contacted three health professionals; they all felt that condoms were the most effective way to have safer anal, oral and vaginal sex.
‘Not Perfect,’ But ‘Very Helpful’
“Condoms are not perfect, but if they are used consistently and correctly, they are very helpful,” said Dr. David Rose, who’s the former director of the AIDS center at Mount Sinai Hospital. “They are a good way of protecting oneself from many STDs, such as gonorrhea, syphilis, HIV and hepatitis B.”
Maggie Janes, a health coordinator and HIV counselor for Mount Sinai Adolescent Health Care Center, agreed that condoms are highly effective in protecting against HIV, since HIV can be transmitted through oral, anal or vaginal sex. She also said that condoms are 95%-97% effective in stopping pregnancy when used correctly.
I asked Janes what she thought about Pettiford’s statements that condoms aren’t safe. Janes disagreed, and referred to tests done by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration which allows no more than 4 out 1000 condoms to leak during random checks of condom samples taken from warehouses.
Janes said abstinence is the only sure way to avoid pregnancy or STDs, but that when you use condoms correctly each time you have sex, you are drastically decreasing your chances of getting infected or getting pregnant.
Follow Packaging Directions
Studies show that condoms are more effective against certain infections than others, and it’s best to consult with health professionals to find out the level of protection a condom can give you against certain diseases.
Some health officials also say that studies on condom effectiveness show varying rates because some studies measure typical use. Typical use refers to when people use condoms both correctly and incorrectly; studies that include incorrect use of a condom will show a higher rate of condom failure than studies that measure the perfect use of a condom.
Condoms often rip or slip off because they’re not being used correctly. Being drunk or high increases the chance that you’ll make a mistake.
Officials recommend that if you’re not used to using a condom, you should carefully follow the directions on the wrapping; guys should practice putting the condom on and off and masturbating with it on to get used to the sensation.
Users should take into account condom strength, sensitivity, size and lubrication, depending on the type of sex they’re having; for instance, anal sex is thought to put more strain on a condom than vaginal sex. Teens should talk to a health professional about the best type of condom to use.
Don’t Rely on One Source
According to Nora Gelperin, a training coordinator for The Network for Family Life Education at Rutgers University, latex condoms work best when they’re used with spermicides like nonoxynol-9, which helps kill sperm. Gelperin advises always using two types of contraception.
“Teens can take precautions by talking to their partners, going to the doctor for annual check ups, talking to doctors, using more than one source of protection (condoms, birth control, diaphragms), and sharing their history with their current partner,” Janes said.
Janes said that information from one source should not be your last and definite source. Your search for answers about safer sex should go much further.
Where to Go
Janes advises young people to get information from Mount Sinai’s Adolescent Health Center, the American Social Health Association, and Sex, Etc., a teen-written newsletter about sexual health, at www.sxetc.org. Gelperin said the most reliable information comes from the Centers for Disease Control, the Sexuality Information and Education Council of the United States, and Consumer Reports’ research on condoms.
(For a listing of places in the five boroughs to get information on condoms and safer sex, see page 25.)
After completing my research and interviews, I don’t feel like condoms are perfect, but they greatly reduce the chances of getting an STD or becoming pregnant. If you’re going to have sex, condoms are the best way to protect yourself from STDs, including HIV. I see condoms as a way of practicing “safer sex,” since it’s only abstinence that lowers the risks associated with sex to zero.
How Reliable Are Condoms?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.