I found out I had gotten into Stuyvesant. The morning the test results were given out in homeroom, people were crying and screaming about which high school they would be going to in the fall.
All the way home on the bus I tried to connect the paper in my hand with everything that had been beaten into my head about what it meant. To say you went to Stuyvesant meant you were special. Teachers believed and encouraged that idea; there was no question but that it was true.
As for my friends-all of them from the projects near school-they had assumed from the start they would go to their zoned high school, if they went to high school at all.
Togetherness, Then Disillusion
During my first two years at Stuyvesant, the people I met made it more than worth staying there. The school had some singular kids, attracted by a public school that is the most desirable option in the city for those who can’t afford private schools.
There was an intense feeling of togetherness among the students. Despite Stuyvesant’s reputation for malicious competition, I never came across any; we were all very much in it together.
Sometimes during my sophomore year, however, the sheer volume of work became meaningless to me. I never had enough time or energy to devote to any one assignment, and so I became an expert at performing works of illusion, creating respectable papers in last-minute bouts of hellish work.
I was disillusioned about every project I undertook. I didn’t have time to think or read, because on weekends I wanted to remain in a state of mental blankness to counteract the stress I had been under all week.
Soon I had to admit that all my worst suspicions about the school’s administration were coming true. I felt they judged us solely on the basis of our grade point averages, and were pressuring us into straight-line and “prestigious” futures.
No Room For Variation
There was no room for variation. For example, when I went to one of the administrators to ask whether the school offered an internship at a museum (I knew they offered such things at alternative high schools), he erupted through the hole I had poked in his bureaucratic defenses.
He ran through a whole range of tactics to dissuade me from what he perceived as a threat on my part to leave Stuyvesant for an alternative high school.
He assumed that I was either failing, having problems at home, or lacking a social life, and proceeded to interrogate me about these things. He told me to get a job typing at a law office to complement my academics-a suggestion I knew he would never make to a male student.
Finally, the man resorted to the weapon closest to his heart-if I left, he told me, I would be giving up the most prestigious high school diploma in the country. I would never get into a college of status after that, because it was commonly known that everyone who went to an alternative school was a failure.
At that point I snapped. He wasn’t talking about my future, and he didn’t believe that any possible decision to leave the school was going to be mine alone. Everything he said was a reaction to my threatening the foundation of his existence: a belief that only Stuyvesant could provide one with superior status.
If prestige was the only reason he could offer for staying, it wasn’t enough, and I didn’t ever want it to become so.
I transferred to City-As-School, an alternative high school, in January of 1989.
A New Atmosphere
My first exposure to my new school made me feel a headrush of pride. There was no authoritarian role-playing between advisor and student, and no feeling that there was a disparity between the interests of the two.
In my opinion, the atmosphere in specialized high schools creates a self-propagating cycle of division between teacher and student, in which both become equally burned out and bitter.
The teacher has no feeling of control except over her students, and the student has no one in sight to blame for her life-consuming workload except her teacher, when in reality both are victims of the same rigid system.
The people who are really in control of the system are not in sight, as is always the case. These are the people who profit most from a society in which students are educated like bees, to be workers or drones.
The elite accept the system because they are given no reason to question it.
In writing for New Youth Connections, I talked with students at different high schools about issues I never would have talked with them about otherwise, and I got a chance to compare their self-images with those of the students at Stuyvesant.
While at Stuyvesant students would answer my questions at length, assuming their opinion would carry some weight, a common reaction at zoned high schools was for the student to say she didn’t know anything or didn’t have any opinion, that she was sure other students would know more than she did.
Students Who Blame Themselves
The difference was this: Stuyvesant students assumed that any gap in their education was the fault of the school system. At non-specialized schools, students were more hesitant to lay the blame on anyone, because they thought they were both at fault for and alone in their educational failure.
The kids I talked to at other schools weren’t expected to show signs of intelligence or initiative, and I don’t think it is surprising that they did not. Teachers must have conviction in the power of their students’ intellects, for students will only grow as much as they are expected to.
For everything that is wrong with Stuyvesant, a great deal is expected of the students there, and consequently a great deal is achieved.
But it is a crime to separate kids into categories by school no matter what the results of a standard test suggest, because the resulting attitudes and self-images of both groups will only mirror those categories.
At City-As, the attitude toward students is universally one of respect, and one which demands shared responsibility in decision-making. What this amounts to is empowerment: we are given the power to decide how much we want to work, in what situation, and at what pace. We are given control over our lives.
Under these circumstances, my attitude toward major work projects, particularly research projects, has undergone a complete reversal.
Segregated By Class
Now I will only take on projects if I have enough time to work on them thoroughly. I only put my energy into work which seems relevant to what I’m learning, and not which is created to fulfill someone’s bureaucratic responsibility.
At City-As, the responsibility has been put on my shoulders to get as much as I can out of my work, since I am not compelled by grades alone to do well.
Society must necessarily be afraid of giving this power to kids. Even students have been defensive about the idea, as I know from my own experience. Before I attended City-As, I assumed it was just another factory of classes, but one made easy for people who couldn’t bear up under the pressure at the “elite” high schools anywhere else. I found out how wrong I was.
Until the last hundred years, only a tiny sector of the population had any prospect of getting a higher education. And in much of the world today, kids start working and having children long before they reach 16.
So I appreciate the fact that I have been privileged in my opportunities.
But I can’t forget that a quarter of my friends from junior high school-the ones whose only option was their zoned high school-have already dropped out and had kids; most of the others have no prospects of going to college. We have been streamed in two distinct and antagonistic directions, apparently on the basis of economic class.
The school system we are a part of brands the majority of high school students as inferior and saps a specially selected few of their creative energy.
And as long as we continue to ignore the reasons for our separation, we will never recognize our potential power.
How I Escaped Stuyvesant High School-And Lived to Tell About It
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.