Names have been changed.
Southpaw High School’s crack team of IT professionals had finally caught me, and boy, were my hands red.
Everyone in the Georgia school, students and teachers, had their own computer network account which they could use for storing documents and pictures. However, it was also possible for troublemakers like me to store games and other unofficial, extracurricular stuff there, and today the IT staff had opted to do a routine check for games on the network. They found a score of suspicious things in my account.
I was in the library sitting next to my partner in crime, Jake. We had chosen to sit at the back of the library, because we were committing two crimes at once-not only were we playing Super Smash Bros., we were doing it using the librarian’s personal account. I’d found her password on a sticky note stuck to the carpet. (Her password was “books.” So much for security.) Students aren’t allowed to install programs, so it was thanks to this lucky find that we were able to install and play our game of Super Smash Bros.
Busted!
An administrator entered the library wearing a serious look, like someone had thrown up in the hallway or cut in the lunch line, and walked straight toward us.
“Conor Dawson?”
“Ma’am.”
“What are you doing?” she asked, taking control of the keyboard and mouse without waiting for my answer. She noticed the game, and the account I had been using. Although the look on her face told me she did not like this, she wasn’t here to talk about Super Smash Bros.
She took me to an empty classroom where another administrator was waiting and the two of them eyed me like I was vulgar graffiti in the boys’ bathroom.
She did most of the talking. “What were you thinking? What’s a smart boy like you doing with things like this? What are you trying to prove? Did someone put you up to this?” I wanted to answer her, but I didn’t know what exactly to ‘fess up to.
Mile-long List
Maybe they had found the games, I thought. I had everything from first-person shooters to Pong, and I made sure everything was available to other bored students. Or perhaps they were mad about what I’d done in my typing class. I was already a proficient typist, so I’d figured out how to make the typing program into a networked instant messenger.
Then again, could it be the Coke machines that I put a fake error message on to discourage kids from paying the school for sodas? Maybe it was the mile-long list of usernames and passwords that my associate Jake had, which we used to get into our classmates’ files so we could replace photos on their projects and insert typos into their papers.
There were a few computers that we set up to display everything upside down, or sideways; it was hilarious watching kids tilt their heads 90 degrees just to read. Sometimes we would schedule one of the students’ accounts to start printing random pictures from the Internet while we weren’t even in the room.
We were 21st century pranksters, getting kicks from our endless electronic gags. We were always a couple of steps ahead of the staff (clowns), never really fearing repercussions. Until today.
An Accidental Discovery
It turned out that I wasn’t in trouble for the Coke machines, the pranks, or the games. Three months earlier, I had been sitting alone at a computer in one of those cheap trailers they used in lieu of classrooms. I’d noticed that my health teacher was still logged on. This was the first time I’d ever seen a teacher’s account, and I decided to take a look around.
With her account, I was able to see a hidden drive that students had no access to. This drive contained folders for every teacher as well as a folder simply called “Programs.”
And that’s where I found the teachers’ grading programs, which is sort of like finding a hammer when you don’t have any nails, or for that matter, wood. I realized after five minutes that I needed an actual grading file, which would be on each teacher’s individual classroom computer, to change any grades.
Furthermore, I would need another, separate password. I had neither of these, but, in defiance of common sense, I nonetheless copied the files and put them in my account.
I didn’t actually want to use the grading programs; I only copied them so that I could say that I had them. I thought I might never see this stuff again and it would be best for me to archive it. The programs had lain dormant for three months until the staff (clowns) noticed them while scanning all the students’ files for games.
Judgment Day
After Jake and I were pulled out of the library, the principal sentenced us to in-school suspension. The following weekend, there was a hearing to decide further disciplinary action. Jake was just as screwed as I was-he didn’t have anything related to grading in his account, but he had a laundry list of hacker tools that the school board decided were directly linked to my crime.
We had to go to the school board building, down the road from the high school. My mom and stepdad walked into the room in front of me. I saw Jake and his mom and stepdad sitting there already. I had on a new suit that my mom bought me at K-Mart and was kind of excited to be there.
It was a really small room, only the size of an office, and there was a huge round table in the middle. A few school board members were sitting around the table. It was covered in legal pads and stacks of paper.
I saw a copy of my “confession essay” that they had made me write while I was suspended-a two-page explanation of exactly what happened. Jake’s essay was on the table, too. Jake and I sat opposite the board members, and our parents sat on cheap plastic chairs behind us.
Defending Ourselves
“OK. We’ve got the letters you wrote and signed here. Before we start, is there anything you want to change now?” one of the board members asked us.
“No, sir,” I said as Jake shook his head.
Then they laid it all out on the line. They would expel both of us, preemptively, for a crime we were incapable of committing: changing grades. Jake and I couldn’t believe it had come down to this.
Even though it was already decided, we explained the whole story again, emphasizing the fact that we hadn’t actually changed any grades, nor had we intended to. I pointed out that, even if I’d wanted to, there was no way for me to use the program without up-to-date files and a password.
But it was no use. They replied to every one of our arguments with, “Well, that may be, butâ”
‘The Only Answer’
“Is this going to affect my son when he tries to go to other high schools or applies to college?” my mom asked, always looking out for my academic interests. They talked her down, saying that I could come back to Southpaw next January.
I laughed at this suggestion. I couldn’t believe that they would go through with this expulsion only to re-admit me after a year. There was no way I was going to come back here after this. I wondered for a moment if they set it for a year just because they regretted losing an asset in their efforts to boost test scores. (I usually did well on tests.) It seemed like this kind of move would fit with their attitude.
“Will there be a lawsuit?” Jake’s mom asked warily in her thick German accent. “We can’t afford something like that.”
“No, there won’t be any legal action. As long as Jake and Conor agree not to set foot on campus for a year, there will be no further hearings.”
“That’s a relief, but even still, don’t you think this is a little harsh?” my mom asked.
“We treat computer fraud cases even more seriously than students looking at porn,” one of the school board members said. “Expulsion is the only answer for this kind of case.”
I wanted another chance. I wanted to graduate with my friends and go to reunions with them. But I also felt indignant. It seemed crazy that the school board would use its harshest penalty on two cooperative, smart, and nonviolent students with no prior offenses.
Frustrated and Bored
I was expelled. It was my own poor decision-making that put me in that hearing room, but it was the school board’s incompetence that threw me out.
I was so frustrated with the board members. They didn’t understand half the things I did to their own computer systems, and they didn’t care. Their reaction only served to cement my anti-authority mentality.
I had never wanted to change my grades. I was comfortable with where they were, and in fact I felt like they spoke more to the school’s shortcomings than my own. I tested in the 96th percentile on the state’s standardized tests and the PSAT, but I had straight Bs. My grades never reflected my abilities because I never felt challenged enough to participate in class.
Encouragement, Not Expulsion
I felt like a baseball player watching kids play t-ball. Doing worksheets and problems from textbooks-I felt that these things were a waste of time when I was more interested in exploring computer systems and pushing my knowledge to the limit.
I hacked the school computers because I was 14 and I was bored. I did it because there were a bunch of other kids at the school who were interested in hacking and I knew I would get cred. I did it just because I could.
It seemed harmless enough and I even tried-once-to use my knowledge to help the school: I figured out a vulnerability that could be used to access the hidden C: drive, and then showed the IT staff. But they shoved me out of the office with the words “We don’t care” ringing in my ears. I could have helped them, but they clearly weren’t interested.
Looking back, I understand that expelling me was an effort to protect the students and the grading system. I accept responsibility for breaking the rules, but I still think they could have handled the situation a lot better.
The school valued the ability to follow rules more than intellectual curiosity. What I needed was not expulsion, but encouragement. My teachers should have pushed me to accomplish more and encouraged my interest in technology. If I could have turned in a soldering project instead of a book report (soldering is fixing electrical connections by fusing them), I might still be going to Southpaw today.
Starting Over
After we were expelled, Jake’s parents sent him to an alternative school called, ironically, the Give Center, where his classmates were pregnant teens and gang members. I really resent the public school system for putting him in the situation they did. Neither of us thought then that he would end up in a halfway school with a low chance of getting into a good college. Luckily, he moved to Florida and is now going to a top-tier school where he’ll have a second chance to be successful after this debacle.
Meanwhile, my mom decided that it would be best for me to try living with my dad in New York. I wasn’t really impressed by the regular schools here, either, but I found a place at an alternative school that I’m happy with. My new school allows me to focus on my interests more and work independently.
Sometimes when my friends and I go to the library we still play Super Smash Bros. in our spare time, even though I’m not supposed to here, either. Hacking and exploring networks is something that comes naturally to me, but I try to avoid doing anything too risky at school because I don’t want to get in any more trouble. (Anyway, at home there are dozens of secure wireless networks for me to play around with.)
Although I think my old high school made an ideological mistake by throwing me out, I don’t regret leaving Southpaw and moving to New York.
Thanks for everything, Southpaw High, and oh, by the way, did you fix the Coke machines yet?
Hacker High
Computer pranks made school fun-then I got caught
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.