Guys Tell Why They Talk Nasty

Cat calls. We hear them all the time. Whether we’re walking down the street or riding the subways. “Hey baby, you got it goin’ on!” “Your ass is phat!” or “What’s up with you and me?”
Ever wonder why guys yell out these things about a woman’s body? Is it that they want to look cool? Do they think that women like it? Or is it just because they have nothing better to do?
I asked several guys and some of their answers were enough to make my skin crawl. “Sometimes you just want to see their reaction,” said Sinohe Terrero, 18, of Humanities HS. “You just test them to see how good they think they look.”
I asked Sinohe to tell me the kinds of things he says. “If she got big tits,” he explained, “[I’ll say] let me throw something on them and lick them to the last drop!” Is this right? Is it harassment or just plain fun?
According to Sinohe, talking this way can’t really be considered harassment because he doesn’t do it “constantly,” just once in a while. Sinohe doesn’t think his comments are all that bad. “I try to keep it low, I have a friend that throws bottles at them.
“They should be happy,” he continued. “At least you’re payin’ attention to them.” But even if they were happy, girls are certainly not paying attention back. Every one of the guys that I interviewed said that the girls usually ignore the comments they or their friends make.
“They just put their hands up,” said Jonathan Ortiz, 14, also of Humanities HS. “They don’t bother.”
A Slap In the Face
When that happens the guys don’t always just walk away. They often respond with things like “B-ch,” “Sl-t,” or “H-.” According to Frank Morales (not his real name), 24, “Sometimes they [even] try to grab the girl’s arm.”
In spite of being ignored, Sinohe still insists that a lot of women seem to like it. “Some women, if you say that they have a nice butt, they’ll change the way they walk,” he claimed.
Maybe men are somehow getting a mixed message. Maybe there are a few girls who smile when these comments are made or others who yell back comments about the male anatomy, but this is only a tiny minority. I have heard more stories of girls slapping guys in the face.
Peter Anthony Collado, 23, even told me about one girl who brought a group of guys to beat up the people that were saying these things to her.
“[Women] don’t really like it,” said Alex Yablakov, 17, of John Dewey HS. “If a girl has any respect for herself, she wouldn’t like it. I wouldn’t like it.”
Even Sinohe admitted that making crude remarks can make life miserable for someone. “I knew a girl once who was afraid to go out of her house because old men would be harassing her,” he said.
So if girls don’t like these comments, if they ignore them and keep away from the people who make them, what makes some guys continue to do it?
Just Showing Off
Many of the ones I spoke to feel that it’s peer pressure. “It makes me look good in front of my friends,” says Richard Santana, 18, of Humanities HS. Frank Morales agrees, saying that although he himself doesn’t do it, he knows plenty of people who do-“the whole block,” in fact. “Sometimes they want to show off,” he said.
Damien Estevez (not his real name), 17, also of Humanities HS, admitted that he does it more when he’s with his friends, “because I got more support. They can back me up.”
Not all guys do it though. There is a group that doesn’t agree with the cat call routine. “It makes [guys] look stupid. Most of my friends that say those things, I never seen them with a girl,” explained Jonathan. Alex agrees. “It’s not a good line like some people think,” he says.
I asked these guys how they’d feel if it were their sister or mother who were being yelled at and they all said that they’d feel disrespected. Sinohe told me about a time when he and his mother were walking down the street together and several guys started to yell things out to her. “When they yelled at my mother, I felt insulted!” he said.
Although this has never happened to Peter, he says that he would feel disturbed if it did. “I’d probably turn around and start cursing them out,” he told me.
So if these guys feel insulted and disrespected when others yell out these comments, then why do they still do it?
The truth is, they don’t feel that they are doing anything wrong. They are merely expressing themselves in the only way that they know how. “You can’t break tradition,” explained Sinohe.
But Alex disagrees. “There’s better ways of expressing yourself,” he said. “I’ve never seen people get far with it.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.