“I would rather be a guy than a girl.” How many times have you said that to yourself? Growing up, I remember wishing that I was a boy on several occasions. Sometimes I still feel that way. Sometimes I think I would be better off.
Is it that I’m sick of people telling me that it’s a compliment when men whistle, gawk, and grab whenever I wear anything cut above my knees? Or maybe I’m tired of hearing stories about girls having to “earn” their grades in school by wearing short skirts.
Maybe it’s the way some male teachers make wisecracks about how a girl will never be as competent as her male classmates that just makes me feel so proud to be a member of the female gender.
But many teenage women don’t seem to mind not being taken seriously. Women face discrimination all the time and most aren’t even aware of it. “It starts when you’re a baby,” said Irma Johnson, 17, of Hillcrest HS. “You’re dressed in pink and the boys get to run around and get dirty while you sit with the ribbons in your hair.”
Many girls just accept the fact that their parents won’t let them drive a car or stay out late-things that would be allowed if they were boys. In many cases, parents will expect their daughter to do chores such as laundry, babysitting, and dishwashing which would not be expected of the males in the family. “Parents give more responsibility to girls,” said Tanya (not her real name), 17, of Townsend Harris HS.
Dirty Old Teachers
Boys and girls are often treated differently at school too, though they don’t always realize it. Several female high school students I spoke to insisted that there was no sex discrimination in school. But many of the same ones mentioned teachers at their schools who have reputations for being unfair to female students. Such behavior ranges from male teachers not calling on women as often as men to jokingly asking for sexual favors in exchange for high grades.
Liz Kim, 17, of Bronx Science HS, told me about a teacher making obscene comments in class and explained that, to her, the teacher was “not sexist, just horny.” Sexual harassment at work, school, and on the street is all too common but we often choose to overlook it or take it as a compliment or a joke.
“There is a difference between sexual harassment and a compliment,” says Diane Welsh, president of the New York chapter of the National Organization for Women (NOW). It’s OK to say, ‘I like your sweater.’ It’s not OK to say, ‘I like the way your breasts look in that sweater.’ “
Tanya remembers a time when one of her teachers at her old school ran his hand down her leg. “I felt violated,” she recalls, but she did not report it to the school.
There were stories going around about the same teacher holding girls’ hands and snapping their bra straps. Eventually someone came forward and he was investigated and removed from his teaching position.
No Big Deal?
In spite of this experience, Tanya thinks that “women are overplaying the whole sexual harassment issue” and questions the motives of those who come out to tell the public that they were sexually harassed or abused.
Students from high schools around the city told me that, to their knowledge, the issue of sexism and harassment has never been formally discussed among the faculty or student body of their schools. Why not?
“People will say, ‘What sexual harassment? Look at what you’re wearing,’ ” said Irma “People say ‘Hey, it’s OK.’ But it’s not OK. They think that it’s healthy to be a pervert.”
Many high schools have ethnic clubs like the Asian Cultural Society at Bronx Science and the African-American Club at Humanities HS. These clubs were formed not only to have parties, but to introduce students to specific cultures and to history which is not covered in the school curriculum. It is also the club’s duty to discuss issues which are relevant to that group of students.
Where Are the Women’s Clubs?
Women also have a history and issues which need to be discussed but are not covered by the curriculum or talked about openly. Why not have women’s organizations and women’s studies in high schools like they do on practically every college campus in America? “There’s no men’s club,” replied Angel Hong, 17, of Bronx Science.
Irma disagrees. She considers sports teams to be essentially men’s organizations since they often exclude women. At Hillcrest HS, open tryouts were held for the handball team, she said, but hardly any girls signed up for fear of being called a “dyke.”
Entire schools can even be considered to be a men’s organization according to Irma. “High schools are run by men…most of the principals are men,” she said. Female teachers pass down ideas and rules which are essentially from the male point of view.
Why do we put up with it? Diane Welsh of NOW says, “Girls [in high school] don’t want to rock the boat. They are still carving out their identities.” They are also trying to be accepted by the opposite sex. “An average high school girl’s self-esteem revolves around guys,” explained Irma.
Another reason young women don’t get involved in women’s issues until college is because of what Welsh calls the “accumulation of [bad] experiences.” She thinks that if every teenage girl took a truth serum, at least a third of them would admit to having been sexually abused, harassed, beaten, or raped.
Blaming the Victim
Welsh said that when something like that happens to a young woman she’ll usually say to herself, “I f-ked up.” It’s easier to deny the problem exists or pretend that it’s personal than to acknowledge that it’s really society’s problem and it can happen to anyone, anytime.
Joining together and defending our rights isn’t always easy. “Girls learn to be so catty and distrustful of other girls,” said Irma. “We have to learn to come together…that’s the only way to stop discrimination.”
Irma recommends that students start women’s organizations at their schools. At first the clubs “would not be taken seriously,” she warned. “But it doesn’t matter if they don’t take us seriously, we have to take ourselves seriously.”
SIDEBAR: What Is a Feminist?
“A lot of people think that we have secret Saturday services where we sit around with our hairy legs and armpits and that we are man-haters,” said Diane Welsh, president of the New York chapter of the National Organization for Women (NOW). But Welsh says people in the feminist movement don’t hate men, “we just hate a lot of things that men do.” Some of the teens I spoke to said feminists were all self-centered and thought they were better than men. But Irma Johnson, 17, of Hillcrest HS said she would be “flattered” if someone called her a feminist. She said to her it would mean she was a strong person who had her own ideas. Liz Kim, 17, of Bronx Science HS said a feminist was anyone who considered a women equal to a man. Susan Chan, 17, of Cardozo HS, agreed and added that it also meant “[knowing] that you deserve the same benefits [as a man].” But according to Tanya (not her real name), 17, of Townsend Harris HS, there’s more to it than what you believe: “A feminist feels strongly about women’s rights and issues,” she explained. “[But] they also take an active role in the fight.” Still, Tanya would not want to be called a feminist because she feels most feminists support abortion and she doesn’t want to be associated with that. Diane Welsh said neither she nor her organization were “pro-abortion” but she would “defend to the death” a woman’s right to choose. She added that not all women’s organizations are pro-choice or deal with abortion at all. That, she said, was yet another media stereotype. Welsh said that feminism wasn’t just about women’s issues either. “We want to change society so that there is no racism, no ageism, no homophobia,” she said. One of the top priorities of the feminist movement is “consciousness raising,” Welsh explained. “They can legislate until they’re blue in the face but if you don’t change the way you think [you can’t change society].” She said women’s organizations at the high school level should focus on education. Action comes later. “If a situation happens, protest,” Welsh said.
