Give It Up: Speakout on the Environment

NYC’s Melissa Chapman asked teens what they would be willing to give up to help the environment.
She talked to Matt Gross, 16; Maria Caruso, 16; and Debbie Spusito, 18, of Urban Academy; Yvonne Anderson, 18; and Kathy Charles, 18, of Evander Childs HS.
No Air Conditioning?
Would you be willing to give up air conditioning in your home, car, or in the subway to prevent fluorocarbons from destroying the ozone layer?
Matt: “Definitely. The heat doesn’t bother me so much except in the subway, but I could deal with [it] in the subway since I’m not there for a long period of time. We don’t have air conditioning in my house, we have ceiling fans and we keep the windows open. As long as the air is circulating it’s okay.”
Maria: “I don’t know about that…It gets really hot in the summer. Especially in subway cars, if they ban air conditioning…it will cause too much tension. Everyone’s hot and it’s crowded in the subway. In my house we have a temperature control on the air conditioning, and it only goes on in the bedrooms. In all the other places in my house we use fans. But that would definitely be the hardest thing to give up.”
Kathy: “No. I must have air conditioning, especially for the hot summer days. It makes me more comfortable and I wouldn’t be so restless from all the heat.”
Recycle?
Would you participate in the New York City Recycling program once a week?
Yvonne: “In my neighborhood, the northeast Bronx, we separate the garbage-cans, bottles, plastics and newspapers-from the rest of the trash. It could make a difference, but I think the city is going to cut it. It costs extra because there’s a different truck that comes to pick it up. It’s too bad since it really made people realize that there really is a problem in the environment. It’s not just going to go away, and we have to help.”
Debbie: “Yes I do it everyday, plus my apartment building recycles. Recycling and cutting down on excess waste could actually provide more jobs in the future. There will always be a need for people to do these jobs as opposed to [military jobs and equipment].”
Walk, Bike, or take Mass Transit?
Would you walk or use mass transit rather than a car?
Yvonne Anderson: “Yes, I take the train and I don’t really mind. Anyhow, in most places in the city there’s a lot of traffic, so it’s usually more time efficient.”
Debbie: “In New York City you don’t really need a car. In fact, it’s a lot easier to use mass transit or walk. In other countries they’ve made mass transit really accessible to people who live in the suburbs and the city. The government has invested money in these programs and has not been afraid to risk the expense. But in this country, the government has made big deals with major car companies and…put more money into roads rather than public transportation since these companies wouldn’t profit from mass transit.”
Matt: “I do walk and use mass transit mostly because there’s no carbon monoxide coming out of my feet when I walk. I’d rather walk or use a bike because I don’t know where the electricity that is used for subways is coming from. Some electricity is produced in a way that seriously harms the environment.”
No Cars in Manhattan?
Would you support a ban on cars in Manhattan?
Debbie: “Yes, as long as I know the trains are going to keep up with this ban on cars. Meaning that they make sure that there are enough routes which go into all neighborhoods making mass transit accessible to everyone-cyclists, handicapped. If the streets were free in New York City then there’d be so much room for people to walk or bike, it would cut down on car accidents and drunk driving. It’d also keep people healthier. There’d be room to build more parks and trees in place of parking lots and more bike paths.”
Maria: “I don’t think so, because a lot of people have to take a car to work-they’re in carpools. And a lot of times you’re safer in a car than taking the subways. Late at night, the city’s not so safe. I know if I’m coming home at two a.m. I wouldn’t want to take a subway.”
Boycott Stores or Products?
Would you boycott products or stores that use too much packaging?
Yvonne: “Yes. It’s important that we try to see that excess packaging is done away with since it remains in the landfills for many years afterward. I guess if you go to a restaurant or store that uses excess packaging, if you don’t need all of it-napkins, bags-you can just give them back. Like if they give you ten straws for two sodas, you can just give them back.”
Debbie: “I do boycott certain companies or products that aren’t environmentally aware. I don’t buy plastic bags or go to McDonald’s or Burger King because most of their eating utensils aren’t recyclable. I also don’t use any form of styrofoam or disposable pens or pencils.”
Matt: “I’ve never really thought about excessive packaging…I’d try to avoid it, but I wouldn’t totally boycott these companies.”
Kathy: “I wouldn’t be willing to boycott those stores and products…I never boycotted before, I’m more of a person who sits around and waits for a decision to be made.”
Take Your Own Shopping Bag?
Would you take your own shopping bag to the store rather than use another plastic or paper bag every time you go?
Yvonne: “Yes, I guess I could…At first it’d probably be inconvenient. I don’t think I’d remember to bring my own bag or enough bags. But after a while I think I’d get into the routine. Maybe if more stores supply customers with recyclable or cloth bags they could cut down on the excess plastic waste.”
Maria: “Yes, I have cloth bags that I take with me because most plastics can’t be recycled, and it’s easier to carry too.”
Debbie: “I have lots of big canvas or cloth bags that I use. Canvas bags are the best to use because they’re sturdy, they’ll last triple the time of plastic or paper, and you can get them wet.”
Kathy: “It would all depend. The only time I take a canvas shopping bag from home is when I go to buy clothing or if I’m going shopping far away. But if I was going to a grocery store, I’d take the plastic bags from the store. My family usually uses these bags for garbage or storing things in the house and that’s being kind of environmentally aware.”
Lower the Heat?
Would you lower the heat in your house to conserve energy during the winter?
Debbie: “I’d love to…Unfortunately, in most apartment buildings the heat is controlled by the superintendent and you can’t lower your heat without lowering all the other people’s heat on your floor…I spoke with my superintendent and the residents on my floor explaining the situation. It’s a really good idea because you don’t really need that much heat or to wear summer clothing in your apartment in the dead of winter.”
Maria: “Yes. I live in a house so we’re able to adjust the temperature. We basically only use heat during the nighttime, since none of us are home during the day.”
Yvonne: “As long as it wasn’t lowered really low, I wouldn’t mind. Usually we only put it on at night, and I guess that kind of conserves energy to some degree. Normally we have the heat on at 75 degrees…Five degrees lower would be the limit.”
Kathy: “No, because my house gets really cold in the winter. When you’re coming in from the cold, you want to go into a warm house…Maybe I’d be willing to lower it at night and use blankets to keep warm.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.