“Get Those Tears Flowing”: How Trauma Mining Retraumatizes Youth

In foster care, we’re often pressured to share our most painful experiences.

In 2021, when Sarah was 15, she attended a virtual Youth Advisory Board (YAB) meeting for Fair Futures, a New York City organization that provides coaching and other support to young people with foster care experience.

Sarah is the founder and executive director of Achillea, a nonprofit that provides peer tutoring to youth impacted by the child welfare system. She volunteered with several other high school and college youth in the YAB to use her lived experience to provide advice on programming and youth engagement.

Fair Futures’s funding had recently been cut, and the organization tasked the YAB with convincing city officials to restore their funding by sharing our “foster care stories” and the difference Fair Futures had made in our lives.

“Get those tears flowing,” a Fair Futures worker added. 

One of the youth shared how a family member had abused and neglected her, both mentally and physically. Another youth shared that they had developed severe mental health issues from being in care and that meeting with their Fair Futures coach was often their only inspiration for getting out of bed in the morning. During the call, no one asked the young people how they felt after sharing something so heavy. 

Sarah was uncomfortable but wasn’t sure if she was overreacting. The worker was very friendly and seemed to have a good rapport with the YAB. No one seemed to be offended, or if they were, nobody said anything. 

She also didn’t know what to say because she was not part of the coaching program.

The worker told her, “Well, then you can talk about how amazing Fair Futures could have been for you.” 

She was upset that Fair Futures, like many other organizations with missions to help youth like her, wanted to use her personal and difficult story for fundraising. She also felt the worker’s comments were hurtful and inappropriate, and was frustrated that they didn’t seem to understand that.

Sarah distanced herself from future meetings. She felt like just another replaceable traumatized “poster child,” expected to do her part and share her “trauma,” and the adults (with no lived experience in foster care) would handle the rest.

When we interviewed the Fair Futures worker via Zoom, they denied being present at any YAB meetings and added that Fair Futures is aware of the grave issue of trauma mining in child welfare. To that end, they provide trauma-informed training to their staff, which includes instructing them to avoid asking youth to share their traumatic stories. In a follow-up email, the worker added, “We use an authentic, strength-based, and sensitive approach in all that we do, including being mindful of language.”  

The worker said, “I don’t believe those were my words,” but that if this incident did occur, they felt ashamed and apologetic and “would use this as a learning moment.” They added that they felt “deeply disappointed because this isn’t the Fair Futures approach.”

What Is Trauma Mining? 

“Trauma mining” refers to the practice of creating expectations for marginalized groups to share trauma in order to engage people and make them care. 

According to QuakeLab, a consultancy that helps organizations promote equity, “[trauma mining] serves no purpose to those who are forced to relive their trauma, but attempts to prove… that racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, etc. is in fact real.”

Michael Zink, executive director of At The Table, a nonprofit that provides tutoring to college-aged youth currently and formerly in foster care, says that trauma mining is “quite common” among organizations doing fundraising, marketing, and lobbying in the child welfare space. Emotionally charged testimonials can attract donors and partners—people naturally want to feel good about themselves when helping.

Zink says that organizations “curate” trauma by asking youth to share just enough of their story to “touch people’s heartstrings without unsettling them.” Then, they make a case for how their service is “not just helpful, it is a lifeline” by painting the organization as the savior for the youth’s now-perfect lives. Zink added that this sentiment is disrespectful to the youth they serve because not only is it untrue, but it also discredits the youth’s agency in their own lives. 

Trauma Mining Is Retraumatizing and Dehumanizing

From the moment they enter care, youth are already forced to retell their stories to a constant revolving door of social workers and other adults, often with little preparation or notice. Telling those stories in public can just add to the burden.

According to trauma specialist and psychotherapist Dr. Odelya Kraybill, asking youth to share trauma can be retraumatizing, when a third of foster care alumni already have PTSD. Amy Gladstone, a clinical social worker who also specializes in trauma, says that narrating a difficult personal story can invoke the fight/flight/freeze response. Over time, this constant triggering of the stress response takes a toll on one’s body and mental state, telling us that we aren’t safe even when we are.

With an average employee turnover rate of 30% at child welfare agencies, some as high as 65%, this process is repeated over and over, which can be especially damaging for young people because “their brains are still forming” and could result in long-term health consequences for the youth, says Dr. Gladstone. 

When Michelle was in foster care, she recalls feeling like an object in a museum, being passed around from case worker to case worker. Every so often she would come home from school to an unfamiliar face sitting in the living room, and she knew she’d have to sit and duly recite the events of the traumatic night that put her in care while the stranger scribbled in a notebook. 

“Why do I have to talk about this all the time? Why don’t you guys have a record of it already?” Michelle asked once in exasperation. The worker didn’t offer an answer. It seemed like all they ever did was sit on the couch and ask her to relay the same stories over and over. Over time, the emotions seemed to freeze over. 

“Are you experiencing any suicidal thoughts?” 

“No,” Michelle answered, because she knew that was how she was supposed to answer. The case worker would be satisfied. It felt like no one really saw her or cared about what she needed, that she was just another box off a stranger’s checklist. Despite longing for help, that feeling of invisibility led her to close off for years from family, friends, and social workers. 

Having to continually retell your story just to get services is bad enough. But trauma mining, which is generally for fundraising purposes, can  be especially damaging, because it demonstrates that our trauma is only worth paying attention to when it’s validated by donors. 

There are times when Eleanor is advised to share the worst parts of trauma and other times to minimize it so it doesn’t make donors feel too uncomfortable. After repeating her story so many times, she wonders if she should just “get over it.” But, she doesn’t have access to basic resources such as housing because of her situation. In order to access monetary support, she feels a need to beg by sharing her worst trauma again and again. 

One youth in their mid-20s, who asked to remain anonymous, spent seven years in foster care and says they have often told their story to fundraise for organizations because they wanted to feel valued. 

It’s concerning that youth feel their value depends on others validating their trauma. The youth added that well-meaning adults tell youth that sharing their traumatic personal stories is the only way they can make a difference in the system. The youth said that organizations utilize young people “until they become burnt out and have no more use.”

They also said that most young people are not compensated for their contribution as a guest speaker or consultant. While youth with more education can leverage more compensation, less than 3% of foster care alumni obtain a college degree. “[Organizations] can get [testimonials] for free or very cheap from youth. If you don’t want to share your story, someone else will.”

The youth said it’s unethical to even ask young people to share difficult personal stories because they can have trouble “asserting boundaries” with adults who have more power over them. Dr. Gladstone added that youth who have had inconsistent or abusive caregivers can experience disorganized attachment, making them even more vulnerable. So, it can be particularly distressing for youth when a trusted adult such as a social worker or a staff member engages in practices that may cause retraumatization.

Trauma Mining Is the “Path of Least Resistance”

Lynn Schnurnberger, executive director of Foster Pride, an organization that provides scholarships and career opportunities to young people with a history in foster care, says nonprofits that practice trauma mining are not intentionally malicious. They focus more on how fundraising can increase their ability to serve youth, and are unaware of how sharing trauma can be retraumatizing. 

Zink says that organizations trauma mine because it is “the path of least resistance. It’s a trope and form that’s expected.”

Zink also said that, “The fewer successes you have, the more incentive you have to trauma mine.” Drawing attention to personal stories shifts focus from quantitative program outcomes and allows organizations to be less accountable to their donors or to youth. 

A Culture of Trauma Mining

Trauma mining has fully permeated the culture of organizations to the point that even adults with lived experience in foster care often use similar strategies of sharing their most painful experiences.

Sixto Cancel, founder and CEO of Think of Us, a research and design lab that uses data to create sustainable child welfare practices, uses his lived experience to raise awareness about foster care and fundraise for his organization. Adults like Cancel can certainly exert agency while sharing their stories, and speaking up about a traumatic experience, on your own terms, can be empowering and reduce shame. 

But Cancel’s methodology speaks to a culture of storytelling that expects people to share harrowing stories to raise awareness or fundraise. Similarly, Sarah often uses her story to market Achillea, even when that feels uncomfortable. People shouldn’t have to share their trauma to gain financial stability or improve their careers. Instead, the onus is on organizations and the public to change trauma mining culture.

What Should Be Done Instead

Trauma mining puts youth in a vulnerable position without offering them a seat at the table to make change. Zink suggests offering board of directors positions to foster care alumni so that their lived experience can directly shape organizational policies and procedures, rather than relegating them to Youth Advisory Boards, which generally have no real voting power. Organizations can also hire people with lived experience in foster care as consultants and in leadership positions, which provides them with a meaningful voice and career development opportunities, too. 

Zink suggests crafting a fundraising narrative to focus on the strengths of youth and what they like about the services they are receiving. When pitching to foundations, At The Table discusses student goals and academic successes rather than how foster care alumni are statistically unlikely to obtain higher education degrees, for instance. 

According to Schnurnberger, organizations should avoid trauma mining by prioritizing quantitative over qualitative data. If organizations do collect testimonies, they should focus on individual program outcomes rather than on personal trauma or how youth were “saved” by them. This practice, if implemented, would help shift existing culture and hold organizations accountable to the youth they serve. 

While testimonials educate people about foster care hardships, there is more than enough existing data and testimonials that demonstrate that foster care is traumatic. Moreover, organizations need to be more aware of conflicts of interest created when staff members prioritize fundraising goals over the mental and emotional well-being of the youth they are serving. 

Organization-wide trauma-informed sensitivity training should be mandatory so that adults are better equipped to recognize signs of retraumatization and create healthy relationships with the youth they serve, says Dr. Gladstone. While Fair Futures provides mandatory trauma-informed training to staff, not all organizations do this, and stories like Sarah’s show that training may not be enough.  

Agencies should recognize that staff turnover or frequent placement changes for youth means they have to talk about trauma over and over with new people. Agencies need to improve training, organizational culture, and salaries of front-line staff to minimize that. 

Gladstone also says that youth should receive education on their rights and the damaging effects of trauma mining. Therapy can be incredibly useful for youth both to help heal trauma and to manage stressful situations that may retraumatize them, but many youth don’t have access to effective mental health services, especially after aging out. 

Trauma mining is more common when persuading people to donate their money rather than their time. Compared to actively involved volunteers, “passive” donors don’t have the same exposure to the lives of the people they’re trying to help, which is why organizations try attracting them with reductive snippets of trauma. Donors can help change the trauma mining culture by educating themselves on child welfare and other issues, and regularly providing their time and professional expertise through in-kind donations in addition to funds. 

As youth with lived experience in the child welfare system, we believe that everyone complicit in the toxic culture of trauma mining needs to be involved in changing it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.