There are so many things that go into choosing a college, but for me, the biggest issue is whether to go away or stay home.
All my friends, teachers and even my principal encourage me to go away, but I’m very close to my family and I don’t think I’m ready to be on my own. On the other hand, the freedom of life on campus appeals to me.
I decided to ask some current college students, ranging from commuters who attend CUNY schools to those living in dorms in faraway cities, how they made the big decision. As it turns out, going away is as scary as it sounds, at least to me.
Loneliness and Hot Pockets
“Finding friends and getting to know yourself, your study habits and what you need to do is pretty hard,” said Jordan Temple, 20, a freshman at Onondaga Community College in upstate New York.
Tasha Santos, 20, a sophomore at the University of New Orleans in Louisiana, agreed. She said she’d always planned to go away to college, expecting lots of freedom with few consequences. But, she said, “I didn’t expect to feel so lonely at times.”
For instance, when she ran out of money on her meal plan, there was no one to run to. Instead, she ate Hot Pockets for about a month. “Get used to ramen noodles and Chef Boyardee and cheap, gross, disgusting stuff,” she said.
Desiree Bailey, 19, a sophomore at Georgetown University in Washington, DC, also had food problems. Freshman year, to save money on snacks, she began scooping up free cookies in the cafeteria and bringing them back to her room. Pretty soon she realized she’d gained 15 pounds. That’s when she threw all the cookies out. “It’s really hard to eat right,” she warned. “But my dad sent me vitamins and that really helped me.”
A Change of Scene
Students living far from home dealt with noise and a lack of privacy in dorms. It also costs more to dorm than to commute, which was a big reason some of the students I talked to decided to stay home. Lily Mai, 19, a junior at Brooklyn College, said bluntly, “I’m staying home because I want to save money.”
But students also had a lot of good things to say about going away for college. One plus is that all your resources and study tools are so close to you, said Jordan. “I can pretty much roll out of bed and go straight to class,” he said. Spending less time to get places means more time to study. Living on campus also makes it easier for him to focus. At home, he said, “some people aren’t doing the same thing you’re doing. That can be a distraction.”
Jordan chose to go away for a change of scene. His favorite part of living upstate is the “fresh air” and the different people. He says sometimes when he meets a new person he feels such a connection that he thinks, “Where have you been all my life?” New faces are also a plus for Tasha, who has had suite-mates from “everywhere,” from Ohio to Japan.
Students living away from home liked learning to live on their own. Tasha said she sees living in a dorm as a stepping stone to independence. Desiree agreed, explaining that she was happy to get out of the structured routine of home life. “I was so in a shell before,” she said.
Not Ready for Independence
Janill Briones, 21, a senior at Hunter College who lives at home, is happy with her decision because she saves money, but she does feel dependent on her mother. If she’d gone away to college, she said, “I feel like I would be more responsible for my life.”
Even so, after interviewing the college students, my gut feeling hasn’t changed. I feel staying home for college will be a more enriching experience for me because I’ll be sharing it with my family. But for students who are independent and strong-minded, going away might be the right choice. Whether you go away or stay home for college, “If you stay focused on why you came to college, then you should be OK,” Tasha advises. I agree.
Dorm Sweet Dorm?
Students weigh in on whether to go away for college
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.