Looking over the past few issues of NYC, I am truly disappointed to find that so many students are criticizing teachers. They complain that the teachers don’t care, don’t reach out, can’t control the students.
I’m studying communications right now, and part of the definition of a communication problem is that it is impossible for the blame to be entirely on one side. That means that no matter how hard a teacher tries, if her students don’t give at least 50%, she can’t accomplish anything.
If kids want teachers to teach well, they must be willing to be good students.
When someone listens to you very intently and hangs on your every word, don’t you get more confidence and feel like what you’re saying has some meaning?
A Two Way Street
Well, when kids pay attention in class, ask questions, participate, and aren’t distracted, the teacher feels like she’s being listened to, not just heard (there’s a difference) and will respond accordingly. She may spice up the lesson, act nicer, be more willing to listen, and explain things more fully.
Similarly, don’t you get annoyed when someone yawns, ignores you, draws, talks to someone else, or walks away while you’re talking?
Why shouldn’t a teacher feel the same way when kids pass notes and act rowdy? They know the students don’t care and aren’t listening.
As for discipline, we all know a few jerks who insist on instigating no matter what they’re threatened with. You can’t hold a teacher responsible for that.
Yes, there are bad apples-but you’ll find them in every profession. Why should teaching be different?
Many, many teachers are dedicated people who love their job and adore kids. If they aren’t always interesting or approachable, that’s the problem of the individual teacher, not teachers as a whole.
Educators, like Rodney Dangerfield, “don’t get no respect at all.” They are downplayed in today’s business-oriented world, get very little credit for very demanding work, and get salaries that are nearly insulting.
If you want change in the system, look at yourself or look at the school board-not at the person who comes in every day to try to enrich you somehow, often against your will.
When teachers and students work together, school can be a positive and enjoyable experience for everybody.
Oh, and one more thing-if you read this article, thank a teacher!
Don’t Grade Teachers Too Harshly
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.