I learned recently that New York City has more out of school and out of work young adults than any other city in the country. “What do these teens do with their time?” I wondered. Do they commit crimes or hang out in the streets? Could they work if they wanted to? What jobs are even available for young people without a high school diploma? I decided to ask David Jason Fischer, Project Director for Workforce Development at the Center for an Urban Future, an organization that works on urban policy in New York City.
NYC: What jobs are available for high school dropouts?
David Jason Fischer: Some jobs don’t require much skill or specialized learning, but these are mostly jobs that pay at or near the minimum wage ($6.75 an hour). In New York City especially, it’s simply impossible to support a family, or even yourself, with that.
Plus, in New York City, there’s more competition even for these low-paying jobs. This city has a very high rate of immigration, and employers generally decide that an adult who’s new to this country and trying to feed his or her children is a better bet to work harder and follow all the rules than a young person.
Even worse, those are the jobs that tend to disappear when the economy goes bad: when fewer people have money to go out to dinner or stay in a nice hotel, it’s the waiters and cleaning personnel who get laid off as their employers have to cut expenses. With very few exceptions, failure to complete high school means a lifetime of scrambling to make ends meet and probably some level of dependence upon friends, family or the government.
NYC: How has the job market changed since the last generation?
Fischer: In the 1950s, many people had jobs that probably weren’t very interesting or much fun, but paid a decent enough wage to support a family and offered benefits and security. Now there are many fewer people working in manufacturing (factory jobs). Plus, back then, unions helped people get higher wages. Now fewer workers are in unions, so they have less power to demand better pay and protection from getting laid off.
One reason fewer people work in manufacturing jobs now is because wages are cheaper in countries like China or Indonesia.
Also, technology and computerization have advanced so much that in many factories, you now only need one person to do the work that maybe six or eight people did 50 years ago. Even if you still want to work in manufacturing, you need at least a high school diploma (and usually more education) because most everything is computerized.
Now, many more people work as computer software designers, medical technicians and lawyers. These jobs require education beyond high school, from an associate’s degree to a law or medical degree. There are also a lot more waiter, retail sales and hotel cleaner jobs now, which don’t require as much education but also don’t pay well or offer much chance to move up. What all these jobs have in common is service-whether it’s designing a video game or bringing a round of Cokes to your table.
NYC: How are high school dropouts affecting our economy?
Fischer: High school dropouts are less likely to contribute to the economy through paying taxes, and more likely instead to cost taxpayers money through their need for support through public assistance, subsidized housing, and other programs, or getting mixed up with the prison system.
NYC: What’s the good news for teens?
Fischer: The retirement of the Baby Boomers (people born between 1946 and 1964) over the next 20 to 30 years means that millions of skilled workers (from upper management in all kinds of businesses to teachers, nurses and scientists) will be leaving the workforce. we’re going to need people to replace them and fill all the new jobs that a growing economy will create. That means you’ll have a decent chance of getting a job if you have a college or advanced degree in one of those skilled fields.
NYC: How does having a high school diploma affect how much money you make?
Fischer: A high school diploma is like a ticket into the part of the job market that might pay enough money to support a family.
Someone who doesn’t finish high school only earns about two-thirds as much as someone who does. Even just starting college, or earning a two-year (associate’s) college degree, increases your earning power by about 30% above finishing high school.
Those who finish four years of college earn almost twice as much as high school graduates. If you get an advanced degree, on average you’ll make more than two and a half times as much as someone who only finishes high school, and well more than three times as much as a dropout. Over the course of a person’s working life, that could be more than $1 million!
Diploma Required
Today's job market is tough for dropouts
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.