Many students we asked hadn’t read the code and didn’t offer any opinions about it. Others, including students at four of the 15 high schools represented on the NYC writing staff, said they didn’t get the booklets, in their schools.
LATRICIA RICHARDSON, 17, Martin Luther King Jr. HS: “Yes, I did read it. I believe the discipline codes are outrageous because they go over the limits. They make it seem like we’re criminals or something.”
DMITRY SEMENOV, 16, Abraham Lincoln HS: “Yeah, I read it. It doesn’t make sense because of the dress code. I think the student rights are fair.”
JASMINE VARGAS, 17, Abraham Lincoln HS: “It’s too much to read. I read some of it and I think it was good. They actually gave us rights. I’ll be using it against the teachers, like the part about the pledge of allegiance. I don’t have to stand in class.”
ANNIE CHEN, 16, School of the Future: “Yes. I thought some of the rules were absurd. I thought it was funny. I didn’t take it seriously.”
SAMANTHA ROTHCHILD, 18, City-As-School: “No, I didn’t read it because I don’t get into trouble. I see no reason in reading a book full of repercussions when I don’t get into trouble.”
CARLA BENEDEK, 16, School of the Future: “Yes, I did, but some of the kids didn’t read it. It shouldn’t be that complicated and that strict. I think they purposely made it difficult to read, so kids can say’whatever’ and not read it.”
JERMAINE RICKETS, 18, Martin Luther King Jr. HS: “Yes, I read it. I think these discipline codes are too overruling. There are certain things kids should be able to do, such as bring cell phones to school. I believe this is the only school that obeys these codes because I know of other schools that don’t.”
MELISSA BROWN, 18, City-As-School: “No, ’cause I don’t care. It doesn’t matter to me.”
OMYRA TEJADA, 16, School of the Future: “I think it has too many rules, and no student is going to follow it.”
ELLEN KREPER, 16, City-As-School: “No, I didn’t read it. But I understand the basic rules for our safety.”
DANIELLA COLON, 16, School of the Future: “Yes, I read it. I thought it was weird because it was too broad. I don’t think it works because different people have different responsibilities and you can’t punish them all the same.”
MARIE ROSENSON, 16, City-As-School: “Yes, I read it. It felt like common sense, but I can understand how some people need to read it.”
AVELYN PORTNOY, 14, Abraham Lincoln HS: “Yes, we read it in class. I really didn’t understand it that much. I thought it was kind of stupid.”
Did You Read the Discipline Code Booklet?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.