Dear Food Diary: What We Learned from Recording Every Bite
As part of our reporting on food and nutrition, YCteen’s summer writers kept food diaries, recording every bite (and sip) for four long weeks. Along the way, our writers made some surprising discoveries about themselves and their diets. At the end of the month, nutritionist Kristen Mancinelli evaluated the diaries and counseled the group on how they could improve their eating habits.
don’t Drink Your Calories
Looking at my diary entries, I realized my food intake consisted largely of dairy and carbohydrates, with very few fruits or vegetables. On the other hand, though my solid-food diet was pretty unhealthy, I must credit myself for drinking wisely. Almost all the liquid I consume is either water or seltzer, two drinks that the nutritionist we spoke to recommended highly. She told us that high-calorie drinks may be more responsible for the obesity epidemic than high-calorie foods.
For me, wasting my calorie and sugar allowance on drinks was never an issue; I rarely drank soda as a kid, and I don’t usually crave it. I also realized at a young age that juice isn’t as healthy as many people believe. Fruit juices don’t contain fiber, and fiber is an important ingredient in solid fruits. Fiber can’t be digested, but its presence in foods helps you feel full and metabolize the sugar in fruit. By drinking a liquid form of fruit without fiber, you end up consuming more sugar than you should. (The ideal serving of juice is only four ounces, but many “Individual” bottles contain three or more times that amount!)
By replacing fruit juices with actual fruits, and drinking water or seltzer, you’ll consume less sugar. You may even find that more fiber in your diet curbs your appetite.
-Suzy Berkowitz
Wait Out the Cravings
Whenever you’re craving that sugary snack, stop and wait 15 minutes. Cravings will often pass with time.
Junking Junk Food-Without Going Hungry
I’ve always promised to lay off junk food for a week, but when I stare at the Doritos bag or that tray of Oreo cookies, my resolve never lasts. Since I’m so skinny, my concept of being healthy means eating more to gain weight. And because of its accessibility, junk food has played a large role in my “eat more to be healthy” regime.
But I know that eating to gain weight isn’t the same as eating healthily. So I decided to volunteer for a one-week, no-junk-food diet as part of the New Youth Connections workshop. This time, I knew I would stick to my plan: since I’d be reporting on my diet experiment for this issue, I finally had a concrete reason not to indulge.
Letting go, however, still proved difficult. Usually, I have milk and pound cake for breakfast. During the no-junk-food week, I had only milk. It didn’t fill me up, but I didn’t consider eating anything else. I believed that cutting out junk was enough to constitute a healthy diet.
During the week, lunch consisted of a Caesar salad from McDonald’s with lettuce, ranch dressing, croutons, and tomatoes. The salad was a healthier alternative than the pizza I usually had, but I didn’t enjoy it because I don’t like tomatoes, and in general, it wasn’t satisfying. At lunchtime on the second day of the diet, I was close to buying pizza and only resisted because the other writers threatened to tell my editors on me.
In my household, we eat traditional dinners, which mainly consist of rice with other foods. For the no-junk-food diet, my dinner meals remained largely the same: sometimes I ate rice with chicken, other times with spinach, fish, lettuce, or beans.
On Friday, Saturday, and Sunday of the diet week, since the workshop wasn’t open, I had more time for breakfast. So, in addition to milk, I ate fruits like cherries and strawberries-something I rarely do for breakfast on a typical day. I had no lunch during these days, because I decided that I didn’t want to travel to my local McDonald’s for another salad. I couldn’t think of any lunch that wouldn’t be junk food and would seem like a real meal. I had dinner early those days.
The week after my diet ended, we met with the nutritionist. Ironically, she told me I’d failed to eat healthily even while on a no-junk-food diet. For starters, I was consuming too few calories. Drinking only milk for breakfast was a bad idea, because it neither satisfied me nor included a mixture of food groups. Instead, I should have supplemented the milk with fruits, like I did during the non-workshop days, and some sort of high-fiber, low-sugar carbohydrate, like oatmeal or whole wheat toast.
Furthermore, skipping lunch on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday was also an unhealthy choice. Instead of getting a salad with little protein and lots of high-fat dressing, I could’ve gone to my local deli for a whole wheat bagel with cream cheese and maybe some yogurt, another piece of fruit, or some veggies.
Clearly, eating healthy doesn’t need to mean having a bad time. I was eating foods that I didn’t like, but after talking to Kristen, I realized that oatmeal, peanuts, carrots, and whole wheat toast are all healthy foods that I actually enjoy. Also, by making sure I eat some protein and unsaturated fat-foods like avocadoes, nuts, and lean meats-along with several servings of whole fruits and vegetables each day, I don’t need to feel hungry while eating well.
If I’d used my diet as a chance to explore healthy foods, it would’ve been more fun and I would’ve had more energy. Completely eliminating junk food from one’s diet isn’t easy, but adding more good food is easier than I thought.
-Mohammed Hussain
Size Matters
When I started my food diary, I hoped it would give me some insight into why my weight fluctuates. Though I’m portly, I tend to eat a balanced diet, abundant with vegetables, fruits, and protein. I can’t say I don’t adore potato chips, cheese curls, and Chinese takeout, but I eat them much less than I do my mom’s homemade meals.
There’s something important to note about those meals: Besides the weekly frittata and occasional pasta or salad, most of my mother’s cooking is what she was fed while she was growing up in India. Thus, I will eat potato masala, a traditional Indian dish made with vegetables and spices, before I eat French fries.
Look to the cuisine of your parents or ancestors and you’ll probably find something that’s healthy as well as delicious. Traditional cuisines are made with fresh, whole ingredients. I usually eat sambhar for dinner, which is a soup made from yellow lentils, garlic, ginger, black pepper, and vegetables, along with many spices: cilantro, coriander, cumin, asafoetida, and mustard seeds. Traditionally, sambhar is eaten with a rice product, but I like it best on its own. It has a hearty taste since it’s been simmering all day, and it’s wholesome, thick, and savory.
Alongside the good news my food diary showed me, though, there was a bit of bad news. I usually overeat by at least a portion size, especially when I go out to eat. This is a problem even when you’re eating healthy food.
The nutritionist who reviewed NYC writers’ food diaries gave me specific advice about portion size. She suggested I take a single serving and eat at a slow pace, chewing thoroughly and enjoying each mouthful as if it were my last for that meal. When I’m halfway done with my portion, I should check in with myself to see if I’m still hungry. If I am, I can keep eating. If I’m still hungry after finishing that first portion, then I can get a second portion-but if I’m no longer hungry, I should stop.
Although it’s hard to let go of my entrenched habits, knowing just how much I eat will make me more aware of how food is affecting my waistline and I’ll be more inclined to change my habits.
-Parameshwari Maragatham
Eat to Get Full, Not to be Wasteful
don’t serve yourself more food than you actually need just because it’s tasty. It takes a while for your stomach to register fullness, so eat slowly. Have a second helping only if you still feel hungry after about 20 minutes.
Follow Your Appetite, Not the Crowd
When I started my food journal, I was ashamed to write down what I normally ate. I wanted to manipulate the end result so my journal reflected a healthy diet. To do that, I only ate salads and drank water for our first week. That didn’t last long.
By the second week, I found myself falling back into my old habits of Chinese takeout and fast food every day. At the end of each day, I was tempted to lie about what I had eaten, not only because it seemed unhealthy, but also because I was disgusted with it. I didn’t want to add those two extra cheeseburgers to my food diary. But I was honest and soon my journal seemed like a book of overindulgence.
As I wrote my journal entries I discovered something else: I wasn’t eating to give my body nourishment, but to help me blend into social settings. I ate food I didn’t want because someone brought it home for me. I also ate because I was out with friends and I didn’t want to be the only person without a plate in front of me. There were times when I wasn’t hungry, but I found myself unconsciously reaching over for a friend’s fries. I only noticed this because I had to write it down. I was always hanging out with friends and family, and my food journal helped me to see that I was just eating what they ate, not letting my own appetite lead me.
I made a conscious effort to change my eating habits. My food journal haunted me, and every time I shared a meal with someone I thought, “If I eat this I am going to have to write it down in my food journal. Am I actually hungry or am I just eating to blend in?” I also started eating healthier foods, which became easier to do the more I learned about a balanced diet.
I stopped writing in my journal the first chance I got, but my new, healthier eating habits are still in place. I didn’t need to overhaul my whole diet, as I feared when I began. I just needed to do a little repair. Mostly, I needed to make sure that I eat because I’m actually hungry, not just because I’m around other people who are eating.
-Chantal Hylton
Combine When You Dine
The combination of protein, fiber, and a little fat will satisfy your belly the best. For a filling snack, try a piece of whole wheat toast (fiber) with a smear of peanut butter (fat and protein), or a piece of cheese (fat and protein) with an apple (fiber).
Skipping Meals Is Not Ideal
It’s important to eat something healthy in the morning, even if you’re not very hungry. This way you have the strength to make it through the day without resorting to vending machines or fast food.
If You’re Able, Read the Label
Know what’s in your food. If the list of ingredients is long and contains lots of things you can’t pronounce, look for something else.
Detecting the Fakes (and Flakes)
Keeping a food journal helped me spot the “fake” healthy foods in my diet. My usual breakfast consists of Raisin Bran with milk and a cup of tea. After writing it down day after day in my journal, I started wondering how healthy it really is and decided to read the label on the back of the cereal box. I was surprised to see that two main ingredients were sweeteners: sugar and high-fructose corn syrup, which are both high in calories but have no nutritional value.
We grow up thinking that cereal is healthy because it’s made from grains and has lots of health claims on the box. But when a nutritionist reviewed our journals, she recommended that we not eat cereal at all, which surprised all the NYC writers. She explained that the flakes in most cereals have gone through a refining process that strips the grain of nutrients and fiber. Later, nutritional additives are baked in to make the cereal appear healthier-but we’d be better off eating oatmeal, which isn’t refined in the first place.
Another bad thing about many cereals is that they are loaded with sugar. In fact, half the weight of some cereals is just sugar. Examples of sugar-loaded cereals are Trix, Cap’n Crunch, Apple Jacks, and Corn Pops. (There are a few good cereals, Kristen said, that have little or no sugar and are made from whole grains, like unfrosted Shredded Wheat and Grape Nuts.)
Most teens-like me-find it almost impossible to wean ourselves off cereal. But we can make small changes to find more balance in our diets. For example, we can reduce the amount of cereal in our bowls and add fruits such as blueberries or bananas. Then we’ll be getting a good dose of grain, fiber, and fruit.
-Annmarie Turton
Local is So Cool
Local food from farmers markets takes less fuel to get to you, which is good for the environment. Plus, if you get food stamps, you’re rewarded for shopping at the farmers market with Health Bucks coupons, which provide a $2 voucher for every $5 you spend using food stamps.
You don’t Have to Be Wealthy to Eat Healthy
When I was first handed a composition notebook and told to record everything I ate, I thought, “No problem.” I believed I ate healthy most of the time. Over the next four weeks my food diary proved me wrong.
After the first week, I started to realize that my diet mainly consisted of just meat-in other words, protein, which we’re advised to consume in relatively small quantities. I also realized I wasn’t consuming many fruits or vegetables, which we’re supposed to eat in abundance.
Like a lot of the other NYC writers, I thought eating healthier would mean spending more money. I started adding it up: Four days a week for two weeks straight, I had bought a ham and cheese sandwich on a hero (with a little lettuce, tomato, and mustard), cranberry juice, and a banana at a local deli for lunch. It cost eight dollars in total, which meant I spent $64 just on lunch over two weeks. I thought this was fairly healthy and not too expensive.
However, after talking to the nutritionist, I realized that I could have had a healthier lunch for less money if I’d been willing to do a little more work. I could have bought healthier bread, like high-fiber whole wheat, at a nearby grocery store, along with ham and cheese. I could have easily added lettuce, tomatoes, and mustard from home. If I made my own sandwich, I could even ensure that the sandwich was packed with more veggies (spinach or green peppers, even) and a little less ham and cheese than a typical deli sandwich. I could also buy cheaper fruit at a local fruit stand and simply drink tap water instead of high-calorie juice. Certainly I would have spent less than $64 if I’d made these healthy adjustments.
I realized that it really takes thought and effort to eat healthy. It’s not enough to pick out a few things that you think may be healthy; you really have to take into consideration the balance of food groups, make an effort to find out what is actually in your food (look at labels!), and work a bit harder to create your own healthy meals.
-Jaminson Robinson
Soda Is a No, Duh
Soda is liquid sugar. Many health experts say an increase in soda consumption is a big contributor to the obesity epidemic. Trade in soda for seltzer or water.
Can the Confusion
Confused by conflicting health advice? Stick to this mantra from author Michael Pollan: “Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.” (âFood” meaning whole foods instead of highly processed “food-like substances.”)
Reduce the Juice
You should get your calories from food, not juice, so trade in high-calorie orange juice for a filling, fiber-rich, low-calorie orange.
If you want to know more aboutâ¦
A balanced diet and making healthy food choices: www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/
The environmental and health impact of products you buy, from food to shampoo: www.goodguide.com
Where to find farms, farmers markets, or food and nutrition programs in your neighborhood: www.eatwellguide.org
Cooking with teen-friendly recipes: www.kidshealth.org/teen/recipes
Dear Food Diary
What We Learned from Recording Every Bite
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.