Last year it came to my attention that a guy in my building was having unprotected sex with another lady in my building who has AIDS. (I used to live in foster care but then I moved to a facility for people with mental and emotional disabilities run by the same agency.) I asked my social worker why she didn’t tell him to use protection, and she told me that she wasn’t allowed to encourage any of the residents to use birth control or condoms because my home is run by a Catholic agency.
I didn’t see how that made any sense, so I asked her to explain some more.
She said, “Well, Catholics don’t believe in having sex before you’re married, and when you do have sex it’s to have babies, so we are not allowed to go against that in any way.”
Now, those aren’t my beliefs, and it bothered me that they were getting pushed on us. (After all, these days, most kids in Catholic agencies aren’t Catholic themselves.) But what really bothered me was that they were pushing them when somebody’s life was at stake. That guy was in that home because he wasn’t really able to take care of himself, but I felt like my agency was failing in its responsibility to take care of him.
Help Us Be Safe
Since then I’ve learned that this isn’t only an issue in my agency. The policy of the Catholic Church is that none of the staff at any of its agencies should give out any type of contraception or encourage residents to use contraception. Staff at Catholic agencies are not allowed to give us information about abortions or help us set up an appointment for one, either.
The government requires that agencies provide us with sex ed classes and information about contraception options, and many agencies do. But when it comes down to us actually making decisions about our lives, our social workers and staff aren’t supposed to counsel us or help us decide what to do.
From talking to kids at different Catholic agencies, I’ve found that some agencies and staff follow these rules more closely and some don’t. But that is the official policy of the Catholic Church.
Workers at these agencies are supposed to direct us to our ACS workers if we ask for help in any of these areas. But sometimes we don’t have much of a relationship with our ACS workers. They aren’t the people whom we know the best and whom we trust. Sometimes we rarely see them, and we may not want to talk about stuff this personal with someone we’ve rarely met.
Besides, some kids need more information in making choices about contraception and abortion, because they don’t have it together enough to decide for themselves. Rather than being silent, we need our staff to counsel us and provide us with access to contraception if they really want us to be safe. And we need them to discuss abortions with us if we’re going to be able to make an informed choice.
Give Us the Facts
That’s backed up by research done by the National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy, which found that just providing sexually active teens access to information about contraception doesn’t increase the likelihood that they’ll use it. They found that it’s important to talk to kids in depth about how they feel about sex, to send strong messages about avoiding pregnancy and STDs, as well as to provide them with access to contraception. When that happens, some studies show that kids are more likely to be safe when they have sex.
What’s more, no (reputable) studies have shown that teaching kids about safe sex makes us run out and have it, or that teaching us to just say no is effective. In fact, according to The National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy, several studies suggest that teaching teens about contraception makes us wait longer before we have sex.
Sex Is All Around Us
So the way I see it, it just makes sense to get kids information and easy access to birth control. It’s irresponsible not to get it to them. And that’s even more true for teens in care. Many of us who come into the system as teens have already had some kind of sexual experiences. Lots of us didn’t get the facts on STDs and birth control before we had sex, but we had it anyway. Then when we come into care, there’s a lot of kids around who are sexually active, and there’s lots of kids who have kids, so it’s easy to feel more encouraged to have sex, and even to engage in promiscuous behavior.
Besides, a lot of times for kids in care, our first experiences with sex came in the form of sexual abuse. When you get abused, lots of times you start questioning yourself. Sometimes you blame yourself for the abuse, and you try to deal with it by continuing to have sex, trying to make sense of the abuse. Sometimes you just don’t know how to say no, and other times you think it’s the right thing to be doing, because that’s what was done to you.
So the reality is that lots of kids in care are having sex and are going to continue having sex, whether or not their agencies believe that they should. With the proper guidance-if our case workers and staff and foster parents talk to us about safe sex, not just once but again and again, and help us work out our own issues while providing us with the information and resources we need-some of us might use protection when we do have sex, and save ourselves from unwanted pregnancies and STDs. If we had someone to talk to openly about sex, some of us might decide to wait.
It’s the duty of our agencies to protect us, because when we come into care, our agencies take over as our guardians. I believe that those Catholic agencies that forbid their staff to support their residents if they need to make a decision about abortion or birth control are not doing their duty. Instead, they’re simply building a wall of silence around something that’s already going on.
SIDEBAR: Staff Disagree With Sex Ed Policies
One Catholic agency wrote in its memo regarding birth control and family planning that its agency won’t provide or promote the use of contraceptive devices. “If the kids come to you and say, ‘I want birth control,'” says Jane (not her real name), an employee at this agency, “we’re supposed to put them in touch with ACS, and tell them about the Options Center-which no longer exists.” This agency’s memo also said it would not provide abortion services, and if a child decides upon an abortion, it is their firm policy to not cooperate in this process. If a teen insists that what she wants is an abortion, her social worker is supposed to inform the teen that the agency does not encourage abortions, but they can give her access to a phone and the phone number of a place where she herself can make an appointment. “If you’re a younger kid and you’re pregnant,” says Jane, “and you’re not sure what to do and your agency tells you, ‘We don’t promote abortion and we think you’re killing the baby if you have one,’ not too many 14-or 15-year-olds are going to buck that and say, ‘I’m doing it anyway.’ ” Many of the staff in these agencies-including some of the nuns-disagree with policies like these and feel they prevent them from providing needed services for the kids they work with. And not providing these services can be seriously damaging. “I had a girl who told me that she had sex with five boys as part of a gang initiation,” said Jane. “She was talking to me about what she was supposed to do. I was like, what would the agency want me to do in this situation, take her temperature and teach her the rhythm method?”
