For many years, I have wondered: what’s the big hurrah about Saint Valentine’s Day?
I wondered if anybody knew the real meaning of the day and the symbols used to identify the holiday. I wondered if anybody really cared.
So, I went on a quest to enlighten people about Valentine’s Day and the real identity of Cupid, who was not a fat, winged cherub.
A Love Supreme
So let me tell you the truth. Eros was the Greek God of Love. Cupid is the name Romans gave him in their mythology.
Originally, Eros/Cupid was often represented as a beautiful youth who resided on Mt. Olympus. He usually took the form of a man, not a fat baby, and struck the lovelorn with his arrows. Sometimes, he wore a blindfold because, as the saying goes, love can be blind.
In the early days, Eros was just the occasional companion of Aphrodite, the Goddess of Love and Beauty. He was initially said to be a serious youth who bestowed gifts upon humanity, but was eventually portrayed as a mischievous boy or something worse. He was never described as a big, fat cherub.
Eros was an inspiration to Greek and Roman poets and intellectuals. For instance, the philosopher Plato said: “Love-Eros-makes his home in men’s hearts, but not in every heart, for where there is hardness he departs. His greatest glory is that he cannot do wrong nor allow it; force never comes near him. For all men serve him of their own free will. And he whom Love touches not, walks in darkness.”
Obviously, he was a top god. So doesn’t he deserve something more than a false image of himself plastered on shiny windows for a holiday he technically has nothing to do with?
Remembering the “Saint”
Another sucking point of Valentine’s Day is the fact that no one calls it by its proper name, Saint Valentine’s Day.
There are several versions of how Saint Valentine’s Day came about, but I want to focus on the story that has a direct tie-in to paganism.
February 14 was originally a holiday to honor Juno, the Queen of the Roman Gods and Goddesses, as well as the Goddess of women and marriage. On February 15, there was a feast in her honor called the Feast of Lupercalia.
Young boys and girls lived strictly separate lives, but on this day the kids got to draw a name out of a jar. On the eve of the festival of Lupercalia, a young man would draw a girl’s name and be partnered with her for the rest of the festival.
Sometimes folks were paired with a partner for an entire year, which would often lead to the kids falling in love and getting hitched. (Just what every girl needs, to pick some guy’s name out of a hat and be stuck with him for the rest of her life.)
Marriage Outlawed
But under the rule of Emperor Claudius II, the practice of getting engaged or married for young men was rendered null and void. (Can’t say I would have been too upset.)
Under his rule, Rome was involved in bloody and unpopular campaigns. He was dubbed Claudius the Cruel and lived up to the name when he decided to restrict marriages.
Claudius believed young Roman soldiers didn’t want to fight because they didn’t want to leave their families and the women they loved. He refused to believe it was because he was an inadequate ruler.
Then along came a priest named Valentine. He and another priest, Marius, who also eventually became a saint, aided Christians who wanted to marry.
Valentine was arrested for marrying off two people who managed to escape before the soldiers burst in. He was dragged before the Prefect of Rome and was condemned to be beaten to death and beheaded. He was killed on February 14 circa 270.
The pastors of the early Roman Church sought to do away with the Pagan element of the Feasts of Lupercalia, by making them Saints’ Days. Since Lupercalia began in mid-February, the pastors renamed it Saint Valentine’s Day.
Thank God for organized religion.
Lupercalia Day Today?
But what if those crazy Roman Catholics had decided to keep the Pagan element of Saint Valentine’s Day? Would all you happy couples still celebrate it the same way?
Picture this. It’s around 9 o’clock, the stars are twinkling against the inky black sky, the pale moon is out, and there’s a light breeze blowing through the trees.
You’re in an open field with a big bonfire in the center. It’s keeping you warm as it lights your steps. Then you see a bunch of people emerge from the outlying trees and tall grass and they’re dressed exactly like you, in brightly colored tunics.
The sound of steady drumming fills the empty air and soon you find yourself dancing around the fire erratically.
You’re chanting archaic phrases as you move around the huge bonfire. You’re praying to Juno, the goddess of all. Then, the music stops. Everyone halts.
A man in the brightest tunic takes out a clay pot full of yellowed paper. Men form a line in front of this man and slowly take papers out of the pot.
The women look around, exchanging anxious and hopeful glances with one another. The men are picking the women’s names out of the pot.
I’d Rather Make My Own Choice
If by some chance a miracle occurs, you might get the man you want. Otherwise you’re stuck with a man you’ve never seen before. Or that you have met but wished you hadn’t. If you’re really lucky you get to be stuck with him for a year. Even luckier still, you might get to marry him and have a house filled with bouncing babies.
Um, how aboutâNO!
I still loathe Valentine’s Day, but I’d rather be able to stay in my house and watch cartoons than participate in that type of tradition. There is one aspect of Valentine’s Day that I wholeheartedly embrace: namely, free choice.
Cupid, St. Valentine: The Men Behind the Myth
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.