Complaints Ignored for Years: Students Claim a History of Abuse at I.S. 143

On May 10, demonstrators marched in front of I.S. 143 in Manhattan’s Washington Heights. They shouted in unison that they wanted Howard Lehrberger, an I.S. 143 dean arrested on April 18th and charged with the sexual abuse of a female student at that school, out of the district. After his indictment, Lehrberger was removed from the school and placed only a few blocks away at the district office.
The demonstration was organized by the Student Coalition For A Better Education. The coalition was formed on May 1st after the father of the student allegedly abused asked for community support in an open meeting at Broadway Temple, a local church.
One of the leaders of the coalition, Eddie Silverio, 20, a youth counselor at Alianza Dominicana, a local youth program, claimed that Lehrberger isn’t the only abusive teacher in the school. He said the purpose of the demonstration was to make people in the neighborhood and city aware of abuse and other problems students face in the school.
Most of the students from I.S. 143 are from Washington Heights’ Dominican community. Silverio said language barriers between teachers, parents, and students fuel an atmosphere where immigrant students are left on their own at the mercy of an indifferent and abusive school environment.
Communication Barrier
“If they don’t know how to read or write in their own language, how are they going to read and write in English?” asked Silverio. He said one out of every four young people that he works with at Alianza Dominicana are illiterate in Spanish. He said students at the school joke about teachers who can’t speak Spanish, but teach the ESL curriculum.
But Silverio said even those teachers that have a grasp of “ABC” Spanish still can’t cope with the Spanish spoken by many immigrants. He said as with English, it’s rare that “perfect” Spanish is spoken.
Silverio said he knows teachers at I.S. 143 are failing because at George Washington HS, which many students in the district attend, 738 students out of 3,000 are absent on a daily basis.
Because many parents and students have a non-questioning acceptance of the word of autho- rity figures, Silverio said I.S. 143 students are vulnerable to abuses.
Coalition members said the school administration was hostile to their organizing efforts. They attributed police hostility during their march to the influence of the school administra- tion. Two leaders of the Coalition were arrested during the march.
On May 15, the Coalition held an open meeting at Broadway Temple to discuss the effectiveness of the demonstration and what to do next. I was there to record what was said.
Catherine Perez, 12, a student at I.S. 143, expressed concern about being involved in the Coalition’s organizing efforts. She said students were being threatened by the school with being held back from graduating or being kept from promotion if they joined the coalition.
She was reassured by four people in the Coalition that students couldn’t be suspended for what they did after school on their own time.
Librarian Reprimanded
Susan Epstein, a library teacher at I.S. 143, was present at the meeting and talked about a letter she received from the principal of the school, Howard M. Gross, that reprimanded her for giving out copies of a Village Voice article about Lehrberger to students who wanted to read it. The letter described Epstein’s actions and stated: “I hereby order you to cease and desist immediately. If you continue to distribute this article on school premises I will bring disciplinary proceedings which may include, but not be limited to, charges of insubordination.”
Epstein rhetorically asked the people in attendance, “What does he have to hide? This is public knowledge. This is a newspaper.”
Sanchez and Silverio, leaders in the Coalition, and Alianza Dominicana director Moises Perez, met on May 17 with Anthony Amato, superintendent of the district, to discuss what the Coalition wanted.
They asked for an assembly within the school where students can learn about their rights and the rights of teachers, and where students could speak up about incidents where they felt wronged by a teacher.
Amato wouldn’t discuss the details of the meeting, but the Coalition says that as a result of the pressure they are applying, attempts are being made to move Lehrberger out of the district to another office, possibly 110 Livingston at the central Board.
A Cover-Up?
“If the children have anything to say, they are not going to say it to them,” said Daniel Abreu, a bilingual education teacher in I.S. 143, about the Coalition’s assembly proposal. “It has to be done by an objective body,” he stated. He said the school administration and the district can’t make up that body because they have been involved in covering up the abuse. “They had information on this teacher [Lehrberger] at least two years ago,” Abreu claimed.
“This dean had a lot of contact with a lot of students,” said Abreu. He said there should be questions on people’s minds, like: are there more teachers like Mr. Lehrberger? And are there any other students that might have been abused by Lehrberger?
Abreu said it was unlikely that Board of Education authorities would investigate them- selves. And that it was even more unlikely that community organizations would be allowed to. He stated that the District Attorney could be an objective body, but parents would have to go to the police and many are reluctant. “We have to sit back and wait for the next victim,” he said with disgust.
Abreu reported that on the same day of the meeting between the Coalition and Amato, an after-school emergency staff meeting was held by Gross, the principal. Abreu said Gross explained Amato’s suggestion that a committee of teachers be formed to meet with community organizations to solve the problems of the school. It was also recommended that discussions be held with the students of the school.
Abreu said one such discussion was held in one of his classes by the sixth grade assistant principal and an interpreter. He said his students reported to him after the discussion that they felt the assistant principal was trying to convince them that Lehrberger was innocent.
Having taught at I.S. 143 for 13 years, Abreu said he supports the Coalition’s goals because he and other teachers have wanted to support greater parent and community involvement in the running of the school for several years.
Those teachers formed the Hispanic Educators Association. The HEA supported parents in the past who documented reports of abuse. Abreu says the inspector general at the Board of Education was given the reports. He said when Koch was Mayor his education liaison received the reports, along with Andrew Stein’s office.
Broader Protest
From talking to students in I.S. 143 and her own experience, Jessie Media, 15, a high school student with the coalition, said students don’t know what their rights are in the school. Students have told her that I.S. 143 teachers have very low expectations for students, and don’t conduct lessons if students let them get away with it.
I asked Coalition members what hope they had of achieving their goals. Sandino Sanchez, a youth counselor at Alianza Dominicana, said if Lehrberger is found guilty by the courts, it would be a beginning. “Once we achieve that, then we can begin our struggle to clean up I.S. 143,” Sanchez said.
But at the May 15th meeting, Epstein, the library teacher said, “The problem is not only Mr. Lehrberger. He’s really a minuscule part of the problem in my opinion.”
She said, “If we limit the protest to’Lehrberger out,’ it’s like one little battle in a war…We have to seriously think about broadening the protest to hold the people responsible, who should have been stopping this. Do you really think that Mr. Gross has no idea what’s going on? I would suggest that you hold the administrators of the school responsible for what’s going on.
“Even if you’re not being kicked or abused, or anything like that, do you think you’re getting the kind of education you could get when people like this are running the school?” asked Epstein.
I asked Sanchez what would happen if Lehrberger wasn’t convicted.
“It will make it harder for us, definitely,” said Sanchez, but he said a major victory for the Coalition would be the removal of Lehrberger from the district. Then it would show, he said, that the community is a force that can’t be ignored in improving education.
If you wish to join the Coalition, write P.O. Box 228, New York, N.Y. 10032.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.