Recently, filmmaker Spike Lee encouraged people to take a day off from school or work on November 20 to attend the opening day of his movie “X” about the life and times of the African-American leader Malcolm X. The idea has sparked a lot of controversy. It got me thinking about another controversy. This year is the 500th anniversary of Columbus’ “discovery” of the Americas. Have you ever wondered what we’re really celebrating? Have you ever wondered who Columbus really was or who he discovered America for?
Some people have suggested that we shouldn’t honor Malcolm X because to them he was a hater of White people. If that’s true then why do we take a day off every October to celebrate Christopher Columbus, a man who had nothing but contempt for people of color?
Columbus wrote in his journals that the “Indians” (he thought he was in India) were ignorant because they didn’t speak his language, but that they would make good slaves.
He was so hungry for gold that he and his men forced the Native Americans to bring him a certain amount every month. If they didn’t, the Spaniards would have their hands cut off. The worst part of it was that there was practically no gold to be found; it was like looking for water in a desert.
If the indigenous people tried to flee into the mountains, Columbus would have them chased down with dogs. A hundred years after he arrived here, entire tribes had been completely wiped out.
Some Hero!
Many people think of Christopher Columbus as a great explorer, the discoverer of “The New World.” It seems strange to me that we are taught to think of him as a great hero.
Imagine how you would feel if aliens landed on Earth and “discovered” you. Imagine they called you stupid because you didn’t understand their ways and then went on to make you their slave, to destroy your people. When they are finished with you they bring another race of people to do their dirty work. Then they set aside a day to celebrate the day it all began.
Columbus’ voyages began the destruction of Native American peoples and their cultures. He started a cycle of racism for all of us that continues to this very day.
This summer I met a 16-year-old girl named Jenny, a Sioux Indian from South Dakota. She told me that she is afraid of making close friends because her friends often commit suicide. Native Americans have the highest rate of suicide of any racial group in the country. Alcoholism and unemployment are also common. Many are on welfare. Jenny says that she and her people are called “prairie n-gers” by some Euro-Americans.
Many history books portray Native Americans as savages, and as a problem for the brave settlers trying to settle our nation. But the problems and achievements of Native Americans are almost never recognized.
What About the Indians?
Did you know that the U.S. Constitution is partly based on the Iroquois nations government plan? Or that in 1492, Tenochitlan, the capital of the Aztec empire in central Mexico, had four times as many people as London, England? Native Americans also had vast systems of roads and agriculture. Many of our interstate highways are built over their roads.
Did you learn about the “Indian Wars” or the diseases like small pox and measles which wiped out so many Native Americans? What about the way their land was taken from them and survivors were forced to live on reservations? Why don’t we learn about these things in school?
Native Americans are not the only ones who have not been adequately recognized in history books. The contributions and struggles of African-Americans, Asian-Americans, Latinos, and working class Whites are rarely mentioned either. Malcolm X is a perfect example.
History is our first class in racism. Things such as Black on Black crime, alcoholism, and drug abuse all come from a sense of underachievement, a sense that we have no past and very little future. History books and the media help give us that.
I didn’t learn the truth about Columbus until I went out and did my own research. All I learned in school was that Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492. I also learned he was a great man.
I still don’t know anything about Malcolm X, except that he was a leader fighting for his people’s rights “by any means necessary.” I sure didn’t get that from history books.
I just don’t understand why African-American, Latino, Native-American, and Asian-American leaders either get put down, or go unmentioned altogether. Yet no matter how bad a leader like Columbus was he gets built up. There are positive people of all colors. We should make history everyone’s story.
Columbus Day: What Are We Celebrating?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.