Every high school had a college counselor who is supposed to help you decide which colleges to apply to. They also should help you fill out your applications and inform you about financial aid.
There are hundreds of seniors in each school, but most schools have only one college counselor. Is that enough? Are students getting the help and advice they need? Is the college counseling in our schools working?
“I went to the office and they didn’t give me s-t,” complained Ayndee Markoa, 17, of Humanities HS in Manhattan. Sophia Matthews, 17, of Columbus HS in the Bronx, said things were the same at her school. “They haven’t told us nothing much. All they told us was what you need to get in college,” she said.
Joan Foley, the administrator of the Board of Ed’s College and Career Planning office, said that a counselor’s job varies from school to school. But the main responsibility of all college advisors “is to get the applications out on time,” Foley said. An advisor is also supposed to meet with college representatives; be familiar with the different types of financial aid and how to apply for them; and know enough about their students’ interests and abilities to be able to help them find the right school, Foley said.
One Is Not Enough
But many schools only have one college counselor. It seems unrealistic to expect that hundreds of seniors will all be able get the services Foley describes. Most of the students I talked to thought the main problem was a simple lack of time. “I think there should be more than one college advisor,” said Stephanie Clemente, 17, of Graphic Communications HS.
Dr. Donald Comras, the college advisor at Columbus HS, said that many college counselors are given other responsibilities too, like being a grade advisor or having to teach.
Besides being the college counselor and running the whole college office, Dr. Comras is also the guidance counselor for foreign students at Columbus. “I have time, unfortunately the time is limited,” Dr. Comras said.
Even some students who have gotten to spend time with their counselors had complaints. Several seniors I talked to felt that their college advisors hadn’t given them a fair chance.
Iraida Vega, 17, of LaGuardia HS, said, “I felt that when I showed [my counselor] my list of colleges, automatically she began limiting my choices. The only thing she seemed concerned about was SAT scores…the biggie.”
Iraida also said her counselor only seemed interested in “telling me what she thought was best for me and getting me out of the office.”
Shooting Too High
Danilo Rodriguez, 17, of Brooklyn Tech, had a similar complaint. He said that his counselor had decided he was “shooting too high” based on his average and SAT scores. The counselor told Danilo he didn’t have much of a chance of getting into the schools he was applying to.
But Danilo is going ahead and applying to the colleges of his choice, anyway. Danilo thinks that students should decide what they’re capable of, not counselors.
I asked Dr. Comras whether he thought counselors discouraged students because of their academic records. “I never discourage anyone in their aspirations,” he said. “However, there is the reality of their academic record which we have to deal with.”
Everyone I spoke with agreed that college counselors in public high schools are overburdened. Jonathan Priess, the college advisor of the Henry Street Settlement’s Operation Athlete program in lower Manhattan, blames the Board of Ed’s budget and the way schools are structured. “I don’t think college advisors can do the job they’re asked to do,” he said.
You’re On Your Own
Henry Summers, the director of Options, an alternative college counseling program in Forest Hills, said that school counselors “can’t do the job that we do” because they are only available during school time. His office is open all year round.
Joan Foley of the Board of Ed said that, unfortunately, “We all have to face the fact there is a fiscal crisis and work around that.”
For most of the seniors I spoke to, that means finding the information they need by their own means. Many are writing letters to colleges or asking family and friends for advice because they are not getting all the information they need from their advisors. As Terese Rivera, 18, of Humanities HS, said, “School helps me out, but it’s not enough.”
Comras said the way things are now he spends every minute of his day with students and some of them still feel neglected: “I literally eat lunch in my office and visit with students…there’s simply not enough time.”
SIDEBAR: You Can Help Yourself
The advisors at the alternative counseling programs suggested that students do more research about college and financial aid on their own. Students could gather college information and then share what they’ve learned with their classmates by giving small seminars or doing one-to-one peer counseling. Dr. Donald Comras, the college advisor at Columbus HS, agreed that students have to take a more active role. “They tend to be a little too dependent…it’s a very scary and stressful period for them…that’s what gets in the way of them seeking out the information,” he said. Joan Foley of the Board of Ed’s College and Career Planning Office suggested that students who are dissatisfied with the college counseling services at their school go straight to the principal. She is the one responsible for figuring out how many staff people are assigned to the counseling office. Some principals might feel that college counseling is less important than other services the school has to provide. Students who disagree should also talk to their student government leaders, the assistant principal of guidance, and the Parents’ Association. If students and parents get together, they might be able to get the principal to change her priorities.
