It’s the year 2025, and you’ve just been diagnosed with the HIV virus. No problem. Doctors can simply extract a white blood cell from your body, produce hundreds more exactly like it, and rid your body of HIV.
A cure for HIV? It seems too good to be true. Yet scientists say it may be possible with the process of cloning-duplication of the DNA of a particular organ (such as the heart) or animal, including humans.
Cloning humans may sound like a process out of a science fiction novel, but in fact it is a very real possibility. In 1996, a team of scientists in Scotland cloned Dolly the sheep, and recently, a pig was cloned in Scotland.
Should We Clone Humans?
Some scientists say it is only a matter of time before humans are cloned. But human cloning makes many people nervous. Is it right to clone humans? Most say absolutely not; a few say there are definite benefits. Others fall somewhere in between-they believe that cloning whole people is immoral, but do see advantages to cloning human organs, such as the heart or the lungs.
Cloning human organs could save lives. If a person clones her heart at the age of 18, by the time she is 40, her cloned heart will be fully grown. Then, if that person needed a heart transplant later on in life, she would have a fully grown “spare” heart that would function perfectly with her own body. This process could save people who would otherwise die of heart disease.
Jennifer Chan, 16, a junior at the New York City Lab School, is completely in favor of this type of organ cloning.
“I want to be a doctor, and cloning body organs will help save many patients’ lives,” she said. “I think that cloning is an amazing medical breakthrough. And the process could stop at cloning organs-if we’re responsible, it doesn’t have to go any further.”
‘It’s Creepy’
But what about going further? Can cloning possibly stop only at organs? Rhonda Ahmis, 17, from Bronx High School of Science, worries that science won’t stop there.
“What if after we clone human organs, scientists decide to take it further and actually clone real people?” Rhonda said.
Cloning humans is where the real controversy erupts.
“I can see the benefits of cloning organs for medical purposes,” said Jessica Santiago, 14, a Lab School freshman. “But I just can’t imagine cloning humans. It’s creepy.”
Cloning human beings is indeed scary. Think about it: if you were cloned, there would be another you walking around the Earth. You would be able to see yourself when you were young-a human who looked exactly like you, but wasn’t you. It’s almost like bringing your mirror image to life.
So far, the closest thing to cloning humans is identical twins, but they’re created naturally. Cloning is not natural. It’s like making a Xerox copy of yourself.
Some people call cloning “playing God”-it’s making a replica of a human.
Sandra Rubin, 15, from Edward R. Murrow High School, said she prefers the term “playing nature.” “I don’t believe in God, but I do feel that cloning goes against what is produced completely naturally,” Sandra said.
However, Dr. Richard Seed, a controversial Chicago physicist who favors cloning human beings, offers a counter-argument. In response to a question posted on the Human Cloning Foundation website, he said, “God made man in his own image. God intended for man to become one with God. Cloning and the reprogramming of DNA is the first step in becoming one with God.”
In an interview on National Public Radio, he also said he wants to create a human cloning clinic. He’s entitled to his opinions, but I think Dr. Seed is more than a little strange.
A Cure for Infertility?
The Human Cloning Foundation, a pro-cloning organization, argues that there could be advantages to cloning humans.
They believe one benefit could be producing genetically identical children for infertile women.
With cloning, an infertile woman would be able to bear a child who has her exact genes, instead of those from an egg donor.
Jena Morgan, 15, from the Lab School, said she finds that idea shocking, but not impossible. “Personally, I think it’s crazy. I could never raise my clone as my child…it’s too weird!” she said. “But if some couples are OK with that, then it’s their decision.”
Emily Darr, 14, agreed, but added, “Anyone who would clone themselves and raise it as her or his own child is egotistical and self-absorbed.”
Bringing a Baby Back to Life
HCF also believes cloning could help couples whose baby dies. With one cell from the dead baby, cloning would theoretically allow them to re-create their baby and raise her as if she had always been alive. This sounds weird and creepy, but maybe some parents would want to do it.
Jessica Zhou, 16, from the Lab School, thinks it makes sense. “If a parent loses a child, it’s tragic. Their child lost its chance at life, and cloning would give it another chance,” she said. “And it’s not like these couples are cloning irresponsibly. They just want their child back, and that’s legitimate.”
Cloning could also help us improve the genetics of the human race. According to HCF, the average person carries eight defective genes inside her body, and those genes can make people seriously ill.
“With human cloning and its technology, it may be possible to ensure that we no longer suffer because of our defective genes,” said the HCF spokeswoman.
Dr. Seed argues that cloning humans is a positive process “for the advancement of science, for the advancement of technology, and for the advancement of humankind.”
Unnatural Solutions
Yet many of the teenagers I talked to see more logic with anti-cloning arguments. Jamie Brown, 16, from LaGuardia HS, said she thinks cloning just goes against what was meant to happen.
“The definition of life is being born when nature thinks it’s right and dying when nature thinks it’s time,” Jamie said. “Cloning can definitely extend people’s lives, but I think there’s something to be said for dying naturally when God says your time is up. It’s not natural to clone your heart so that you may live longer.”
Besides, people die so that new people can take their place. Cloning is a process that will be able to save a woman who might otherwise die, but nobody can prevent death forever.
Would Jamie change her views if it were her own mother or father who needed a new heart-a cloned heart-in order to survive?
“Obviously, if it were my mother, I’d do anything to prevent her death,” said Jamie. “If you bring in personal scenarios, you can’t really answer objectively. Generally, I say let nature take its course.”
Should Cloning Be Legal?
The controversy over cloning will undoubtedly rage for a long time to come, even if scientists perfect a process to clone humans effortlessly. Scientific American magazine said, “Most ethicists’ initial reaction [to human cloning] is that such an action would be unconscionable-although in the U.S., unlike in the U.K. and many other countries, it is not explicitly illegal.”
Therefore, an important question is: Should the government be allowed to ban human cloning? And if cloning is forbidden, will it actually stop scientists from trying? I think it should, although I am not sure we can stop the experimenting.
If scientists who are in favor of cloning discover a foolproof method, I believe cloning will only escalate. But the problems that may result from cloning are also unavoidable, and I think we will regret it if we take cloning too far.
SIDEBAR: How Cloning works
If you’ve sat through a year of freshman biology, chances are you know the basics about cell structure and reproduction. To recap: the human body is made up of millions of tiny cells. Inside each cell is a nucleus, and inside each nucleus are 46 chromosomes. A chromosome is made up of a long, coiled strand of DNA, which contains each person’s specific genetic code, or genes. Genes determine the basics of who you are: your hair, eye and skin color. While you share these traits with one or both of your parents, your genes are unique. You’ve probably heard the saying that no two people on Earth are exactly alike. This is absolutely true. When your mother’s egg and your father’s sperm unite to form a fetus, you may have your father’s brown eyes and your mother’s large frame, or you may grow up to be 6’5″ while neither of your parents reach past 5’7″. But whomever you are, you are a randomly selected, completely special individual. Cloning can change that. Cloning is a process where the DNA of a particular organism is duplicated and used to create a new creature, the clone, which is exactly like the other-inside and outside. Both the original creature and the clone will have the exact same hair color, eye color and skin color, not to mention identical cells and genes (at birth). Cloning is pretty complicated, but it basically involves taking a cell from a particular creature and causing that cell to reproduce until a new creature is formed-a creature exactly like the original. Many people call cloning “playing God” and think it is too frightening and bizarre-to really do. But ever since Dolly the sheep and Tetra the monkey were cloned, the cloning of humans has become a much more imminent possibility. It can happen, and, scientists say, probably will happen within the next 25 to 50 years.
