City Teens Demand the Right to Vote

When I turn 18 next year, one of the first things I’ll do is to register to vote. To me, voting shows that a person belongs to a society. It symbolizes maturity and gives the voter a voice among millions. I have a year before I’ll have that right, but what if I could vote right now?
The idea of voting as a 16- or 17-year-old never crossed my mind until I learned about a group of New York City teens fighting for the right to vote in city elections. When I heard they were gathering at City Hall last March to draw attention to their cause, I decided to see what they were all about.
On the steps of City Hall, I met a passionate group of teen members of an organization called Future Voters of America. The teens at the rally told me that since they live in a country that prides itself on being democratic, they should be able to participate in that democracy. They said they felt their needs and ideas were being overlooked by the city.
But they aren’t being overlooked by everyone. In January, New York City Council Member Gail Brewer reintroduced legislation that would allow 16- and 17-year-olds to vote in local elections in New York City.
Young Teens Already Vote
New York City would be the first city in the U.S. to give this right to teens, but a similar effort is underway in Cambridge, Massachusetts, according to the National Youth Rights Association (NYRA). And the NYRA reports that many young teens around the world already have the right to vote, including 16-year-olds in Brazil and Germany and 17-year-olds in Israel and Indonesia.
If the New York City Council passes the legislation and Mayor Michael Bloomberg signs it into law, Brewer estimates that as many as 200,000 16- and 17-year-olds could vote in city elections.
“A 13-year-old can be tried as an adult. A 16-year-old can drive and have a job,” Brewer said. “Teens need to have a say in the policies and decisions that affect their lives.”
Brewer stood by her teen supporters at the City Hall rally to draw attention to teen voting rights. And in a March letter to City Council Speaker Christine Quinn, Brewer argued that the legislation would encourage more teens to get involved in local issues.
“Their voices would be heard on key issues such as education, housing, community development and environmental concerns,” she wrote. “If given a chance to vote, the youth could increase their interest in civic life and continue voting in future years.”
Students at the rally, including La Guardia HS student Eidia Monei, agreed. She said it’s time for teens to stop hiding behind their parents’ ideas and construct their own beliefs. Monei said she’s fighting to preserve the environment, while other teens said they wanted the right to vote on public housing issues.
Making Political Decisions
Aneeba Rehman, an organizer of the rally and a student at Hunter College, felt that voters would have more practice and experience at making political decisions that are right for them if the local voting age was lowered to 16.
Voting in local elections would prepare teens to vote in federal elections and would increase participation in national elections, she said. That would benefit the United States as a whole.
But Council Member Brewer said that many of her fellow council members are not yet convinced of the legislation’s benefits. The legislation’s opponents include Republican City Council Member James Oddo, the council’s Minority Leader.
‘It’s Bad Public Policy’
“We applaud the young activists who have such a strong interest in government, and we wish more of their classmates felt as strongly as they do,” wrote Christopher DeSicco, spokesman for Oddo’s office, in an email to NYC.
“However, they appear to be the exception and not the rule, and we believe extending the franchise to teenagers under the age of 18 is simply bad public policy,” he wrote. “The election of [city] officers is serious business and the city’s elected officials must approve a budget that now exceeds $50 billion annually. The choices made will affect the city for years. We cannot leave such important decisions to kids who are still in high school and who may not yet even have a basic understanding of basic American government.”
I think it will be difficult to prove to other adults that this legislation should be passed. And I’m not sure that many teens would take advantage of their voting rights. I can’t imagine the same kids who play pranks on each other in my high school’s hallways and sneak in from late-night parties as responsible voters.
In the eyes of my parents and some of my teachers, many teens appear apathetic to the events occurring around them. (Of course, the same point can be argued about many adults.)
But the teens who would be most likely to vote if the voting age is lowered, which includes members of Future Voters of America, are certainly not apathetic. Many teenagers have strong opinions and ideas about public policies. We are a passionate group of people with a lot to say.
Many of us want to change our communities and possibly the world. According to the teen advocates, this legislation could make youth even more politically aware and confident.
I’m willing to wait until I’m 18 to vote, but if 16- and 17-year-olds obtain the right to vote, we might be more active in society. Teens could bring a fresh new perspective to politics. Hopefully our energy and spirit will remind adults of the excitement they once felt as youth, when they saw a world before them that was ready to be changed.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.