So you’re sitting in biology class, waiting endlessly for your teacher to finish rambling on about this old dead guy named Darwin, when, out of the blue, you’re asked to explain the theory of evolution. Of course, you freak out: were you actually supposed to be paying attention? I mean come on, in the whole scheme of things, evolution doesn’t really matter, right?
Actually, wrong. In fact, the teaching of evolution has recently ignited an important debate that could change how much religion influences your education.
Evolution is the theory that over millions of years, human beings descended from monkeys, who themselves descended from less complicated animals. The evolutionary process is the basis for modern biology.
Ever since Charles Darwin came up with the theory of evolution in 1859, some religious Christians have opposed its teaching. They say that humans were created in a single day by God. This conflict led the Kansas School Board to remove evolution from its statewide school curriculum last August, setting off controversy across the country.
Science vs. Religion
Many New York City students feel that the Kansas decision shows that religious groups have too much power over public education in America. They fear that what happened in Kansas might pave the way for schools all over the country to be shaped by certain religious beliefs rather than by scientific knowledge.
Opponents of the decision say the Kansas School Board was afraid that evolution would turn students away from the teaching of the Bible. But school board members who support the resolution say that evolution is simply bad science, because it cannot be reproduced in a lab.
However, “the process [of evolution] is so slow that it obviously can’t be reproduced in a matter of minutes,” said Vanessa Lee, a New York City junior. “Humans are still evolving and it’s already taken millions of years to get where we are.” And much of science cannot be reproduced in a lab.
Church and State Should Be Separate
Besides, evolution is accepted as truth by most scientists. “When people talk about this issue they act like there’s a controversy in science but there’s not,” said Molleen Matsumura of the National Center for Science Education. “Everyone in science accepts that evolution happened.”
“Religion can’t tell you what a good scientific explanation is any more than a scientist can tell you what church to go to,” said Ms. Matsumura.
In any case, public schools in this country are not supposed to be influenced by religion, since the Bill of Rights says that church and state (including public schools) must be kept apart. The Kansas decision “is a complete breach of separation of church and state-it’s a contradiction of the law!” argued James Kraft, 13, a member of a religious youth group at Grace Church, in Manhattan.
Some people feel that without evolution in the curriculum, Kansas students will miss some of the scientific background they will need for later studies, since evolution is the basic foundation upon which the study of animals is grounded.
Kansas is “denying children truth and scientific education,” said Elijah Campbell, another New York City student. “Even if evolution doesn’t exist, everyone in power believes in it,” he said. “By denying the education of evolution, they’re denying students of their future opportunities.”
What About Adam and Eve?
“The people that removed evolution from the curriculum are ignorant. Their particular religious beliefs confined them and closed their minds to science,” Elijah added.
In fact, of the six members of the Kansas School Board, four ardently believe in creationism. Unlike evolution, which came from the analysis of evidence in the environment, creationism is based on the literal interpretation of the Bible. Creationists take it as an exact explanation when the Old Testament says that God produced Adam in His own image in a single day.
‘Evolution Could Have Been Caused By God’
Ms. Matsumura, who has been researching the Kansas decision, said that one of the Board of Education members is part of a group called the Creation Science Association for Mid-America, whose website says that the Bible is “the only trustworthy source of information regarding the meaning, purpose, destiny and conduct of human lives.”
But the conflict is not really between religion and science, said Ms. Matsumura. Many religious Christians accept the Old Testament’s teaching, believe in God and also use evolutionary theory to clarify their understanding of where humans come from, she said. “Evolution could have been caused by God,” agreed James Kraft.
“You can take aspects of both [creationism and evolution] and blend them in with one another,” explained 16-year-old Melanie Leong. “For me, there are a lot of missing things in science, so if I was asked to pick between religion and science, I would choose a medley of both.”
Science Belongs in Science Class
But for many people, including creationists who don’t want evolution taught, evolution and creationism are completely contradictory theories, so if you believe in one, you can’t believe in the other. “If God created Adam and Eve [in the form we are today], it can’t be true that they changed from monkeys,” explained 13-year-old Jeannie Quintero, of the Grace Church School.
Still, whatever the personal beliefs of the people who run them, public schools are not allowed to teach religion-and they shouldn’t stop teaching science to make room for it. “The whole point of separating church and state was so religion wouldn’t dominate society,” said Irene Krugam. “Things get dangerous when this gets altered.”
Church vs. State
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.