The idea of “treating” domestic violence offenders is relatively new, and there’s a lot of debate about it. Can men who batter women really change? And if so, what’s the best way to get them to do that? While all court-mandated programs have to meet certain guidelines, some programs take a hard-line approach, emphasizing that men who batter are choosing to do something wrong and need to take responsibility for that. Other programs are more therapeutic, with an added focus on helping men figure out for themselves why they’vebeen battering and how they can stop. We spoke with Vicki Gorder and Ted Bunch, who run two different treatment programs, to find out more.
Teaching Respect
Interview with Ted Bunch
At Safe Horizons the only program that deals with offenders is the domestic violence accountability program. Offenders who’ve been arrested for domestic violence get sent here by the court. It’s actually not counseling-it’s education and it’s about holding men accountable.
Our perspective is that men don’t need therapy, that they know how to be respectful and non-abusive, but they choose not to. We know that because an abusive man goes through the rest of his life without being abusive.
I think that men need to be re-educated. Domestic violence is a learned behavior that can be unlearned. Counseling has nothing to do with that. It’s about education.
In our classes, we teach the dynamics of power control and what domestic violence is, that it’s not just physical. We also provide education around a number of other topics like the history of violence against women, the effects of domestic violence on children, and how domestic violence is similar to other kinds of oppression, like racism and homophobia. It’s just a different group being the dominant power.
Hopefully we inform men that their behavior is something that they can change right now. They’re acting out what they’vebeen taught by society.
Individually, to stop battering, men need to personally take responsibility and make changes in their life. But we believe that domestic violence is not really an individual ill, it’s a social ill, the same way as if someone is racist. How we can help him stop as a society is to accept that men have been taught to view women in certain ways, and that we have to teach gender equality so that women are respected in the same way men are. More importantly, other men have to speak out and say that this is wrong.
Men who have been through batterers programs re-offend at about the same rate as men who haven’t had any treatment at all, so batterers programs are not the cure. And just because a man doesn’t get arrested again doesn’t mean he doesn’t do it again.
Every man is capable of changing. There’s no doubt in my mind. I know they’re capable of being respectful, because these men are respectful to other people in their life. When he’s angry with his boss or his friends, he doesn’t take it out on them, he takes it out on her. It’s about choice.
But I don’t think that a woman’s life is any safer because a man has been through a batterers program. We tell women whose partners are sent here that when he comes back, she should plan for the man she knows him to be, and not the one she hopes him to be.
Ted Bunch is the senior program director for the Domestic Violence Accountability Program at Safe Horizon, an organization in New York City that seeks to prevent violence and support victims of crime and abuse.
-Reporting by Cynthia Orbes
Can Men Who Batter Stop? Part 2
Two perspectives on treatment
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.