Can I Be a Team Player?

One lunchtime in late November of 6th grade, I saw a crowd of students, including some of my friends, huddled around the hallway wall. I nosed my way through and laid eyes on a form reading, “JV Basketball.”
To join my school’s basketball team, I just needed my parents to sign a form. My school, Churchill, is small, with only about 24 kids per grade, and there are no tryouts.
My friends were excited about joining the basketball team and encouraged me to sign up too. I wanted to be with them, but I wasn’t sure I wanted to be on a team. I played basketball just for fun occasionally at the park with my friend, but I liked my competition one-on-one.
Pride in Solo Races
Earlier that year I’d joined the cross-country and track team. In the first stage of a race I felt as if my legs were going to break off, but as the race neared the end I felt lightheaded and stress-free.
Running races gave me some pride in my developing physical build and I enjoyed my new reputation as a speed-demon. This reputation also revived my self-esteem, especially since in gym the year before, I’d run a third of a mile before passing out.
I’d also been playing competitive chess since 4th grade. Chess is a mind game, but like cross-country running, it’s a solo undertaking, just you alone on the field. In a tournament, it’s you and your opponent, the winner moving up the list to play tougher opponents.
I felt good about myself when I psyched out my opponent to win the game. Chess also gave me some pretty shiny trophies.
Left Out of Groups
I liked individual sports because I’ve always worked better with myself than with others. Though I did have a few close friends, I was mostly a secluded individual with a tendency to be stubborn and critical, an attitude that couldn’t squeeze itself in the word “team.”
But my choice to be anti-social was probably less of a decision and more like something I’d been pushed into by insecurity. In truth, I was reluctant to give people a chance because I felt that they would never give me a chance.
When I attempted to work with others in class, I felt left out. No one ever asked me to join their group, and I feared rejection and ridicule if I asked to join them. So the teacher would put me with the few remaining students who needed one more person. It made me intimidated about trying to join groups.
I worried about being fully accepted as a team member if I joined the basketball team. I didn’t want to be bullied or have them disregard my existence and treat me as an outsider.
Do I Want to Share the Pie?
Defensively, I took on the arrogant mindset of the individual warrior, telling myself that team players needed to rely on someone else for their glory. The team I worked with was my body and mind but at least they obeyed my commands and didn’t give me much trouble. I didn’t want to deal with other people’s mood swings or have to care about camaraderie.
Winning in an individual competition made me feel like a titan of my field. I told myself there was no way in a million years I would share the pie with anyone.
Still, while it can be great to have the whole pie, it can get lonely eating by yourself. Despite my handful of good friends, I felt unpopular, and at social settings like dances I’d retreat like a ghost afraid of being seen.
I longed to be noticed by a wider range of classmates. The lunchroom buzzed with talk of Shaq, the Knicks and college teams like Duke and St. Johns. I thought that since people at school were so into basketball, I might become more popular and recognized by my classmates if I joined our team.
But what if I didn’t do well? When I lost a chess match or placed fourth in a track meet, profanity slipped from my lips and all I felt was the humiliation of failure. At least in chess if you fail, you only bring down yourself, whereas in basketball you drag the team down with you. Then not only would I feel guilty about my own performance but I’d have to face my teammates’ bitter criticism.
My friends shared some of my concerns, but they were into basketball and decided to join the team. They encouraged me to take the chance, too.
It was my Pop who finally convinced me to join. He told me that if I never took chances in life and spent too much time assuming what I thought I knew, then I’d be the one losing out. With Pop and my friends behind me, I signed up.
Dribbling Head Down
On the first day of practice I wasn’t feeling panicky or discouraged. My friends were there and the coach, Rob, was soft-spoken. Whenever someone made a mistake, he pointed out what that person did wrong, yet how close they were to making it right. That made me feel more confident about becoming a better player.
And my skills needed work. I dribbled with my head glued to the ball and to the floor, causing me to bump into people and have the ball stolen from under my nose. I couldn’t do fancy tricks between my legs and my left hand was worthless. When it came to shooting, I shot with two hands, instead of using one to direct my shot.
Practicing helped. I trained myself to dribble with my head up and got my left hand used to taking an active role. I practiced shooting at short distances from the rim before expanding my range.
I Was a Ball Hog
But being social was my biggest hurdle. One day I forgot to follow a running pattern when attacking the hoop. The fact that I knew this made it more frustrating, yet when my teammate Andres pointed it out to me, I set my sights on him.
I told him that I knew what I did wrong and it was none of his business to monitor me. Then I lashed out by saying, “Let the coach remind me, at least he has an intelligent perspective.”
Andres backed off but instead of feeling satisfied, I felt like a complete fool for turning something so small into something so personal. It wasn’t until after the second game of our season that I swallowed my pride and apologized for jumping on him at that practice.
I knew he meant no harm by monitoring me and I wanted to give him a chance to see my good side. After that, Andres became a fun acquaintance. Had I not been so obnoxious at that one practice, I would have seen that positive side in him earlier.
In individual sports no one seems to care about your attitude and you are working with yourself. But my ruthless competitive streak made me a very unattractive human being on the basketball court. I put so much pressure on myself that I seemed to forget that I had voluntarily joined a group, and that this was supposed to be fun. I was a ball hog and didn’t cooperate well with my teammates.
Trying to Be More Chill
Luckily, my friends didn’t flat off tell me to chill out. Instead, they took me to the side and told me that it was OK being competitive, but that I was already a great contribution to the team and that all I had to do was enjoy myself. They made me feel less anxious about my performance, and so did my coach. He reassured me that “nobody is perfect,” and if I only simmered down a bit I’d be wonderful.
I knew I had to become more of a team player. So I worked to be chill, relaxed and less focused on myself. Sometimes when I felt myself working up, I focused on my breathing and told myself that I didn’t join the team to be a hero but to have fun and make friends.
By the end of the ninth practice I was able to make a slight grin. That afternoon I had decided to just be myself and as a result I played better and gained some respect from my teammates. They’d tell me things like, “Good going, Fabs.” The more I received such positive feedback, the more I became convinced that it was my unselfish self that everyone wanted to see.
Shy Off the Court
While I was too aggressive on the court, off the court I suffered from shyness. I found I often had to concentrate on what to say in social situations, or how to say it. But often, by the time I came up with a bright idea, the conversation had shifted, making my carefully thought-out addition to the conversation sound absurd.
Once I jumped into a conversation about liking certain girls in our grade. Overhearing talk about “favorites,” I offered that my favorite Poke’mon was Oddish.
George and Mika burst out laughing because somehow liking Poke’mon and girls didn’t go together. Fortunately, these two guys were my friends and I laughed too. Having my friends around made it easier to stretch my social skills because I knew they already accepted me.
Shattering My Stereotypes
I realized that even the popular guys on the basketball team were nice. I’d been so worried about them judging me that I hadn’t thought about how harshly I’d been judging people I didn’t even know.
If a person was sociable, for instance, I assumed he was a limelight thief, always looking to dominate and take advantage of those who had trouble expressing themselves. After the basketball experience I discarded that stereotype. I’d simply say hello or make a comment like, “Great job.” In response that person would thank me and give me a look of respect.
I shattered my stereotypes about team sports, too. I no longer saw team sports as activities played by those who couldn’t handle individual responsibility. Instead, I learned that each player has his or her own special purpose on a team.
The pressure to win felt different on a team, too. My team didn’t take defeat as badly as many individual competitors I knew, including myself, and that turned out to be a relief.
Taking the Losses Together
I learned that support was more effective than criticism for a satisfying team performance. You have to be as willing to give as to take help. When I fouled in a game, Mika said, “don’t worry, Fabulous. You’re the man.”
Those six words changed my dreary mood and pushed me to play an effective defense for the rest of the game. My words of encouragement to George after he launched the ball over the backboard had a similar effect on him.
My largest gain from the season, though, was the simple pleasure of new friends to hang out with. These friends battled with me through the season and if a game was lost we were almost happy to have all taken the hit together. By sharing the loss as a team, the pain was evenly distributed and if one wanted to lament over it there was always someone who would care to listen and help.
I ended the season feeling not only a boost in popularity but an inner strength that I never would have known had I not tried.
I Still Prefer to Work Alone
After that, I played on the softball team for a year. While I liked playing softball and was more confident about my social skills, I was still overly sensitive about making errors and worried about how my teammates might judge me because of them.
So I decided that I am still happiest with individual competition. Now that I’m a junior, my competitive activities include track, cross-country and chess. I’m also on the Student Council, which I see as both an individual and group activity. I had the individual glory of winning a position, but once in power I needed to negotiate and deal with other people cooperatively.
I’m glad I joined the basketball team because I learned that interdependence is just as valuable as independence. I also realized that while I can work with a group, I prefer to work alone. I can’t change my personality. But I’m glad I can now recognize the positive attributes of both team work and individualism.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.