Can a Teacher Be a Friend?

What do you picture when you hear the word teacher? Someone standing in front of the classroom scribbling notes on the board or giving lectures? Is there anything wrong with this picture? Talking to many students, I’ve gotten the feeling that they’d like to change it. They say they want to break down the barriers created by this system and have more personal, one-on-one relationships with teachers inside and outside the classroom.
Some of the qualities students say they value most in their teachers are flexibility and compassion. They say they want to be treated as individuals with their own needs and problems. “Teachers need to be on a personal level with their students because otherwise I could just read from a book,” said Mark Osgood, 16, a junior at Stuyvesant HS.
Some teachers agree with that. “Students learn more and teachers teach better if a one-to-one relationship exists,” said Charles Roemer, an English teacher at Hillcrest HS.
Teachers Who Go the Extra Mile
Many students say they do better in school when a teacher spends extra time and effort on them. Grace Chu (not her real name), 17, a senior at Hillcrest HS, says that her Spanish teacher’s constant efforts helped her pass the Regents. “She made sure I understood what I needed to get ahead,” Grace said. “Sometimes she would stay after class.”
Edgar Quiroa, a junior at Jamaica HS, says a math teacher who sat down with him after class and went over material he didn’t understand helped him pass the course. To Edgar, an ideal teacher is someone who “can teach, does his job, and is also a friend to the students.”
Maghana Taribagil, a senior at Benjamin Cardozo HS, agrees. She says she feels closer to teachers who take time to talk to her outside of class. “I learned more from them than just their particular subjects. I learned about life,” she said.
Teachers who are available outside the classroom may open doors to learning that family or other personal problems might have kept locked. Grace Chu feels that the best thing about some of her teachers is that she can confide in them.
“If I don’t want to go to my family, a teacher would be the next best person,” Grace said. For example, she was able to talk to her health teacher about an alcoholism problem in her family that was troubling her. “He noticed I was depressed and he was willing to listen.”
Charles Roemer, who has taught for 29 years, says the need for more personal teacher-student relationships has grown recently. “I see many more students whose experience outside the classroom has handicapped them, that they are not able to work to their potentials.” He added, “Family and social problems have entered their lives when children shouldn’t have to deal with these things.”
Joel Barsky, a teacher and program director at School for the Physical City, is another who thinks it’s important to have individual relationships with his students. “I stay after class, late in the afternoon,” he explained. “I show my students that each one is important to me.”
Students also feel that teachers need to be flexible when personal problems affect their ability to do their work. Sarah Popkin, 17, a junior at Hunter HS, feels grateful to her English teacher for helping her get through a difficult time.
But I Can Explain. . .
“He knew I was going through a lot of problems, was understanding, and gave assignments to make up my grades,” she said. But Edgar Quiroa complained that his health teacher, who failed him, never listened to students or asked for explanations when they were unable to do the work.
Although most students interviewed said there should be more personal relationships, a few said they can’t see themselves opening up to any teacher. “I really don’t interact with my teachers,” said John Won, 18, a recent graduate of Stuyvesant HS. He says that he sees teachers as authority figures and would have a hard time talking “about personal things with people who can affect your grade.” He added, “I don’t feel comfortable.”
Grades seem to be the most common reason students give for wanting to keep their distance. Ivo Dimitroff, a junior at Forest Hills HS, agrees that there should be a line between teachers and students. “I don’t think that teachers should be involved in our personal affairs,” he said. “Sometimes the grades could be affected, and also the teachers look at the students in a different way.”
Breaking Down the Barriers
Sometimes, both teachers and students say, concern about grades gets in the way of learning and relating to one another. But a bad grade on a math test taught June Lau, a senior at Brooklyn Tech HS, that her teachers care about more than just her grades. June recalls that she was so worried about her grade that she actually started crying. But her math teacher came to the rescue. “She gave me a big hug and said, ‘Just because you got a bad mark on your test, I’m not going to think of any less of you.’ “
A number of teachers are trying to get rid of the boundaries that have existed in traditional classrooms. Joel Barsky believes the best way to do this is to arrange students in groups and allow them to choose their own topics.
Destroy Big High Schools
“I’m not always going to stand up in front of the classroom and put notes on the board, or ask them to read at home,” he said. Barsky believes that getting students to work on their own makes them more responsible. “They begin to ask more questions. They want to learn more for themselves.”
Teachers admit that although they would like to give individual attention to every student, it isn’t always easy to do, especially in large classes and big schools.
What can be done about this? “Destroy big high schools,” suggested Joel Barsky. Charles Roemer, who teaches in a traditional high school, likes the idea of an alternative high school with much smaller classes. “We are starting to move in the right direction with smaller classes,” he said.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.