Broken Promises: Chancellor Fernandez, 1990-1993

Schools Chancellor Joseph A. Fernandez recently learned that to survive as head of New York City’s twisted school system it’s better not to care too much about your one million students. Despite impassioned pleas from dozens of parents and educators, on February 10, the Board of Education voted 4-3 not to renew Fernandez’s three-year contract.
The chancellor’s opponents claimed that by fighting for comprehensive HIV/AIDS education and a plan that made condoms available in high schools, by standing firm on a multicultural curriculum that urges tolerance for everyone-including gays and lesbians-he was “distracting” the school system from teaching the “Three Rs”: reading, writing, and arithmetic. Fringe groups of religious fanatics and anti-gay bigots-aided by sensationalism in the local media-began a misinformation campaign about Fernandez’s “social agenda.”
But this “social agenda” wasn’t about promoting sex at an early age or any particular “lifestyle,” as some of Fernandez’s critics charged. On the contrary, his programs were an attempt to promote healthy, sound behavior in some very troubled times. They show a genuine commitment for the plight of urban youth-a commitment deeply rooted in Fernandez’s personal experience as a high school dropout, an ex-gang member and onetime heroin user.
“I know firsthand what education can do to save a life. I don’t have to ask the experts or read books about it. I’ve been there,” he writes in his recently published autobiography, Tales Out of School.
“I know about tough neighborhoods. I grew up in Harlem…
“I know about racism and prejudice. In some areas of this country, being Puerto Rican is as tough as being Black.
“I know about dropouts. I was one.
“I know about gangs. I was in a few. I still have the scars.
“I know about the folly of drugs. I used them.
“I know what scratching for an education is like when you finally come to realize its importance. I got my high school diploma in the Air Force. It was my salvation.”
Now, who would you rather have running the schools, street-smart Joe Fernandez, or some uptight college president who grew up in a beachfront mansion in the Hamptons?
Fernandez has brought tough real-world issues like AIDS, teenage sexuality, violence and racism into the classroom-which is as it should be. But he’s done much more than that.
Through his school-based management program, the Chancellor has empowered parents, teachers and administrators at over 240 schools to run their own shows. He has helped design about 50 new, smaller and less anonymous high schools which will specialize in areas like writing and communication, environmental studies and performing arts. And he has pioneered a school choice program which will allow students to attend any elementary or middle school anywhere in the city, if space is available.
Fernandez also cut the school system’s bureaucracy, pushed for higher math and science standards and helped cut the dropout rate. His tenure also saw a rise in reading and math scores (not that those “Three Rs” fanatics could care), and an increase in attendance rates. All that in spite of an unprecedented $750 million in budget cuts over the past two years.
But in the end, the four conservative members of the Board of Ed-Carol Gresser of Queens, Irene Impellizzeri of Brooklyn, Michael Petrides of Staten Island, and Ninfa Segarra of the Bronx-could not be swayed by reason. They had their own political agendas to advance.
When his term officially ends on June 30, Chancellor Fernandez will be survived by a divided and deluded Board of Education-and a million helpless students.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.