Bringing the Jets and Nets Back to New York

Sleek New Arenas, But At What Cost?

Sports fans in New York may have a lot to be excited about over the next decade. Will the city finally host a Super Bowl? The National Football League (NFL) has already answered yes if the Jets get their stadium built in midtown Manhattan’s Far West Side by the 2009-2010 season. The stadium would also boost the city’s bid for the 2012 Olympics.
Across the East River, the New Jersey Nets are planning to build a new $435 million home in Brooklyn. Adding a basketball arena in Brooklyn would give the borough its first professional franchise since baseball’s Dodgers moved to Los Angeles in 1958.
While politicians and developers have passionately backed these plans, many New Yorkers question the value of building expensive sports arenas. The teams’ owners would pay part of the costs, but the city and state governments would have to spend hundreds of millions, too. The project’s opponents think it’s wrong to spend taxpayers’ money to support private businesses instead of necessities like education.
Others worry that huge arenas and heavy traffic before and after games will destroy neighborhoods. Some face losing their homes and jobs as buildings are knocked down to create room for these new facilities.
The proposed Jets stadium, called the New York Sports and Convention Center (NYSCC), is controversial because of money. At about $2.2 billion, it would be nearly three times more costly than the NFL’s current most expensive stadium.
The Jets promise to pay at least $800 million of it, but the rest would come from public money. According to the plan, the city and state would contribute $300 million each to construct a platform over the rail yards that are currently on the site and build the stadium’s retractable roof.
The costs of building infrastructure like roads and sewers would require even more taxpayers’ money, as much as $1 billion. Plus there are plans to extend the 7 train, an estimated $2 billion project. Critics ask how we can spend that kind of money on a privately-owned team when we still have overcrowded classrooms.
Futuristic Glass Design
But Mayor Michael Bloomberg is pushing the Jets plan because he sees the stadium as necessary for New York City to win its bid for the Olympics. And getting the NYSCC means the world to the Jets too.
The Jets, who moved to New Jersey from New York City in 1984, want to return to New York. They are also one of the least money-making teams in the NFL and are hoping that their new stadium, which would include more luxury suites to attract wealthy corporations, will make them financially competitive.
The NYSCC would be a state of the art stadium, with a retract-able roof and a sleek, futuristic design featuring an exterior glass “veil” that covers the main structure and would look like it’s floating above the ground when seen from afar.
The stadium would replace the West Side rail yards between 11th and 12th Aves. and W. 30th and 33rd St in Manhattan. In addition to hosting Jets games, the 75,000-seat stadium would also be an expansion to the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center, which is directly north of the site. With the extra space, the city could host an extra 30 to 40 conventions and exhibitions a year.
The Jets’ plan also includes a large retail space along 11th Ave. A huge entrance on 32nd St. would allow people to get a clear view west to the Hudson River. Pedestrian bridges would be built over the neighboring West Side Highway and connect the riverside to the stadium.
Jobs for Construction Workers
Recently, I went to check out the site. An ugly gray wall now covers the perimeter of the rail yards, which are owned by the MTA, and the neighborhood is filled with old graffiti-covered warehouses. It felt surreal to be the lone soul walking down these decaying streets on a bright, sunny afternoon.
As I looked at the rail yards from the Javits Center, imagining a gigantic glass structure towering above, I talked with Marty Small, a construction worker. She said she wouldn’t mind having the stadium built, “for selfish reasons. I’ll have a job.” Such a large scale project would create many construction jobs.
Marty may get her wish, since the stadium has already won an auction for rights to build over the rail yards and gained backing from the Empire State Develop-ment Corporation and the City Council. But it still needs one final approval from New York State’s Public Authorities Control Board.
It is also fending off a lawsuit by Cablevision, which owns nearby Madison Square Garden and opposes the proposed stadium. Four other groups have filed a lawsuit to get the MTA to redo the auction and sell the rights to the highest bidder.
The proposed Nets arena is less expensive, but it has angered local Brooklyn residents because it involves tearing down housing. Roughly 1,000 people would lose their homes and businesses. The 19,000-seat arena itself would be built over another MTA train yard, the Brooklyn Atlantic Yards, but is part of a bigger development project that includes 17 high rise apartment and office buildings.
Like the Jets’ stadium plan, this $2.5 billion development would require government money-at least $100 million each from the city and state-to cover infrastructure like road and sewer improvements.
Local developer Bruce Ratner bought the New Jersey Nets last year with the desire to move them to Brooklyn. He already owns the new Atlantic Center Mall, which is across the street from the proposed stadium site.
Making People Move
Ratner’s mall and the Brook-lyn rail yards are separated by car-filled Atlantic Avenue. To me, the shiny new mall building, major stores, and crowded sidewalks looked bizarre compared to the steel fence-enclosed rail yards and the aged building behind them.
On the second floor of the mall by a window overlooking the rail yards, Brooklyn teenager Takeisha Tate shared her opinion on the controversy. “Granted, it will bring more money into the area, but it’s also making people move who’ve lived here the majority of their lives,” she said.
Ratner has already bought many of the condo units in the buildings he wants to tear down, but some homeowners refuse to sell their property to him. If they won’t sell, the city may jump in.
The government is permitted to take private property, as long as the owner is paid fairly, for “public use.” That generally means taking land to build schools or highways, not stadiums. So far, the city hasn’t taken anyone’s property for the Nets development, but some area residents are worried.
Too Much Traffic Already
And like its West Side counterpart, this plan has drawn concerns about adding traffic to an already crowded neighborhood. “As bad as it is now, it’ll be hell when they come here,” said Bedford-Stuyvesant resident Curtis Jackson, 25, sitting on a bench inside the mall. “You don’t add to an existing problem.”
But Mayor Bloomberg and Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz believe that the Nets arena would not only give Brooklyn a pro team to root for, but that the added housing, retail and offices will improve the area and bring in more money in taxes.
In March, Ratner reached an agreement with the city and state to build the arena. He said he’d reserve half of the total housing for low- to middle-income residents and agreed to hire residents of the local community for many of the project’s jobs.
Ratner’s plan still faces many approval procedures, including backing from city authorities and the Public Authorities Control Board. It is also facing possible lawsuits.
Should the city’s tax dollars be spent on these stadiums? If they end up benefiting the teams or their owners more than their new neighborhood, then I don’t think so.
The arena projects are supposed to benefit their surrounding neighborhoods, but I’m not sure that will happen. Shea Stadium and Arthur Ashe Stadium, each a short train ride from my house, have done little for their neighborhood. Each facility is surrounded by chop shops, polluted ponds, and a crumbling park.
But if the Jets and Nets arenas get built and bring even the smallest improvement to the neighborhood, then it’ll be worth it. Having the Jets and Nets back in New York may mean more championship teams and Hall of Fame players performing in our backyard.
I admit that as a lifelong Knicks fan, I hope the Nets stay in Jersey because, in my eyes, New York has only one basketball team. But as a hardcore Jets fan, I’d love to have my team play just a subway ride away in a beautiful, state-of-the-art stadium.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.